A company acquiring a new passenger car by 36-month financial leasing asked whether VAT on the monthly invoices is deductible, whether the interest is a financing expense, and whether insurance, fuel and similar costs are subject to the passenger car expense limitation.
The Administration's view:
- The monthly rent cap does not apply to financial leasing payments; payments are split into principal and interest, interest is added in the first year to the car's cost in the Rights account and in later years taken, optionally, as expense or cost.
- If later years' interest is expensed directly, at most 70% is deductible; at most 70% of running costs such as repair, maintenance, fuel and insurance is also deductible. If interest is capitalised, depreciation is limited to the depreciable amount for the year of capitalisation.
- If ownership passes to the company at the end of the contract, VAT borne on the car cannot be deducted under VATL 30/b.
- If ownership stays with the leasing company, the transaction is a rental service; VAT on rents and running costs is deductible in proportion to the part accepted as an expense.
The ruling is relevant to companies acquiring passenger cars by financial leasing.
Full text
Subject: Expense limitation and VAT deduction for passenger cars acquired by financial leasing
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that a brand-new passenger car was acquired in your Company's name by financial leasing, that instalment payments of principal, interest and value added tax (VAT) will be made to the bank over 36 months for the passenger car, and that the bank will issue monthly invoices under the financial leasing, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the VAT in the invoices issued can be deducted, whether the interest expense to be paid will be taken into account as a financing expense, and whether expenses such as comprehensive insurance and fuel for the passenger car will be considered within the passenger car expense limitation.
IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW:
The first paragraph of Article 6 titled "Net Corporate Income" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers within an accounting period, and the second paragraph that the provisions of Income Tax Law No. 193 on business income apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 40 titled "Deductible Expenses" of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
"The following expenses are accepted as deductible in determining net income:
1. General expenses incurred to earn and maintain business income. (Taxpayers engaged in exports, construction, repair, assembly and transport activities abroad may, in addition to the expenses in this subparagraph, also deduct expenses they calculate on a lump-sum basis for their expenses relating to these works abroad, provided they do not exceed five per thousand of the revenue they obtain in foreign currency from these activities.) (Excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, the part up to 5,500 (26,000) Turkish lira of the monthly rent for each passenger car acquired by leasing, and the part up to at most 115,000 Turkish lira (690,000 TL) of the total special consumption tax and value added tax on the acquisition of passenger cars, may be taken into account as expenses.
...
5. Expenses of vehicles acquired by leasing or included in the business and used in the business (...), (provided that, excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, at most 70% of expenses relating to passenger cars may be deducted."
Detailed explanations on the subject are given in the fifth section titled "Deduction of Expenses and Depreciation of Passenger Cars from the Tax Base" of General Communiqué on Income Tax Serial No. 311, and Article 13 of that Communiqué states that, excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, the monthly rent for each passenger car acquired by leasing may be taken into account as an expense within the limits in the article. Paragraph 5 of the same article states:
"Payments relating to passenger cars acquired by financial leasing will not be considered within Article 13 of this Communiqué, and there will be no monthly rental expense limitation on those payments. The third paragraph of Repeated Article 290 of Law No. 213 defines financial leasing; subparagraph (1) of the second paragraph of the same article provides that the right to use the economic asset subject to financial leasing capitalised by the lessee is subjected to revaluation and depreciation under the principles set for the leased economic asset in Repeated Article 298 and the first section of the third part of the third book of that Law, and subparagraph (4) provides that payments made by the lessee under the financial leasing contract are separated into principal repayment and interest expense, and that the separation is made so as to apply a constant periodic interest rate to the remaining debt at the end of each period. Accordingly, payments made by the lessee under the financial leasing contract must be separated into principal repayment and interest expense, this separation must be made by applying a constant periodic interest rate to the remaining debt at the end of each period (the date payments in the financial leasing contract are to be made), and the interest expenses calculated must be added to the cost of the economic asset in the first year and taken into account as expense or cost in subsequent years. In this context, for passenger cars capitalised by financial leasing, payments will be separated into principal and interest, the interest expense will be included in the first year in the cost of the passenger car tracked in the "Rights" account, and in subsequent years will be taken into account, optionally, as expense or cost."
Article 14 titled "Repair, maintenance, fuel and similar current expenses relating to passenger cars" of the same Communiqué states:
"(1) Excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, at most 70% of expenses relating to passenger cars may be deducted as expenses in determining net income for income and corporate tax.
(2) Expenses of passenger cars included in the business or inventory and used in commercial or professional activity are limited, and this limitation essentially covers expenses of passenger cars excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways.
(3) Expenses within the first paragraph are generally current expenses of vehicles such as repair, maintenance, fuel, insurance and similar.
(4) Whether the expenses relate to passenger cars registered in the business or inventory or acquired by leasing is of no importance.
...
(5) Where taxpayers wish, optionally, to take directly as an expense interest expenses relating to passenger cars acquired by financial leasing for periods following the period in which those passenger cars were capitalised in the "Rights" account, at most 70% of these expenses may be deducted as expenses in determining net income for income and corporate tax
...
(6) At most 70% of expenses corresponding to the period after the effective date of the Law relating to passenger cars acquired or obtained by leasing before 1/1/2020 may be deducted as expenses in determining net income for income and corporate tax..."
On the other hand, paragraph 7 of Article 15 titled "Depreciation expenses relating to passenger cars" of the same Communiqué states:
"For passenger cars capitalised by financial leasing and tracked in the "Rights" account at the lower of fair value and the present value of rent payments under the contract, where the capitalised amount exceeds the depreciable amount set for that year, at most the part of the depreciation set aside for each passenger car corresponding to these amounts may be taken into account as an expense in determining net income for income and corporate tax."
According to these provisions and explanations, payments made under the financial leasing contract by your Company, whose main activity is not partly or wholly leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, must be separated into principal repayment and interest expense, this separation must be made by applying a constant periodic interest rate to the remaining debt at the end of each period (the date payments in the financial leasing contract are to be made), and the interest expenses calculated must be added to the cost of the economic asset in the first year and taken into account as expense or cost in subsequent years.
In this context, where interest expenses for periods following the period in which the passenger cars acquired by financial leasing were capitalised in the "Rights" account are, optionally, taken directly as an expense by your Company, at most 70% of these expenses must be taken into account as expenses in determining your corporate income, and at most 70% of current expenses such as repair, maintenance, fuel, insurance and similar relating to those vehicles may also be deducted in determining your corporate income.
On the other hand, it goes without saying that where interest expenses paid for passenger cars acquired by financial leasing and tracked in the "Rights" account are, optionally, added to the cost of the passenger car in periods following the period in which these assets were capitalised, at most the depreciable amount set for the year of capitalisation of the depreciation set aside for these assets may be taken into account as an expense in determining net income.
IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 29/1-a, that taxpayers may deduct, from the VAT calculated on their taxable transactions, unless otherwise provided in this Law, the VAT shown in invoices and similar documents issued for deliveries and services made to them relating to their activities,
- in Article 29/3, that the right of deduction may be used in the tax period in which the relevant documents are recorded in the legal books, provided the calendar year following the calendar year in which the taxable event occurs is not exceeded,
- in Article 30/b, that, excluding those used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, VAT shown in purchase documents of passenger cars belonging to businesses cannot be deducted from the VAT calculated on taxable transactions,
- in Article 30/d, that VAT paid on expenses not accepted as deductible in determining income under the Income and Corporate Tax Laws cannot be deducted from the VAT calculated on the taxpayer's taxable transactions.
Section (III/C-2.1.) of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:
"...
b) Under Article (30/b) of the Law, VAT paid on purchases of passenger cars and shown separately in invoices may be deducted by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing passenger cars, taxi operation or operating passenger cars in various ways, for passenger cars they use for this purpose. Accordingly, taxpayers operating passenger cars in the ways above may use the right of deduction for passenger cars used for this purpose.
However, VAT shown in purchase documents of passenger cars acquired by taxpayers outside the purpose of the business cannot be deducted. This non-deductible tax may be taken into account as an expense or cost element depending on the nature of the work under the Income and Corporate Tax Laws. This also applies to passenger cars purchased outside the purpose of the business by taxpayers engaged in passenger car operation.
...
Under Article (30/b) of Law No. 3065, excluding VAT shown in purchase documents of passenger cars used for this purpose by those whose activities consist partly or wholly of leasing or operating passenger cars in various ways, VAT borne by VAT taxpayers on passenger car purchases cannot be deducted.
...
ç) Under Article (30/d) of the Law, VAT paid on expenses not accepted as deductible (non-deductible expenses) in determining income under the Income and Corporate Tax Laws cannot be deducted from the VAT calculated on the taxpayer's taxable transactions either.
Accordingly, VAT shown in documents relating to expenditures other than those necessary for carrying on the activity, not related to the business or in the nature of expenditures for the private consumption of the business owner, and other non-deductible expenses will remain with the business or business owner in the position of consumer."
Accordingly, where ownership of the passenger car acquired by financial leasing passes to your Company at the end of the contract term, the VAT borne on the passenger car cannot be deducted.
However, where ownership of the passenger car remains with the financial leasing company at the end of the contract term, since that transaction will be considered a rental service, the part of the VAT on rents and on expenses such as fuel, maintenance and repair of the passenger car corresponding to the part accepted as an expense in determining income under the Income and Corporate Tax Laws may be deducted.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.