A company that purchased a software use service from an Ireland-resident firm to hold video meetings with customers asked how the payments are taxed.
The Administration's view:
- If the software is used in the business or sold to end consumers without modification and/or reproduction, the foreign firm's income is commercial income; no withholding applies under CTL Art. 30.
- Under Article 7 of the Turkey-Ireland DTT, Turkey has no taxing right if the firm has no permanent establishment in Turkey; if it has one, taxation is limited to profits attributable to it.
- Since the service is benefited from in Turkey, it is subject to VAT; if the firm has no permanent establishment in Turkey, the company pays the VAT as responsible party with Return No. 2 and may deduct it in Return No. 1.
The ruling is relevant to companies obtaining software or cloud services from abroad.
Full text
Subject: Whether withholding applies to payments for software purchased from an Ireland-resident firm
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the review of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that a "…" software use service was purchased from the firm … (…), whose legal seat and business centre are not in Turkey, to hold video meetings with your customers, and that the firm sent you an invoice, you request our Administration's opinion on the taxation of the purchase of this program.
I- CORPORATE TAX LAW
The second paragraph of Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that institutions listed in Article 1 whose legal seat and business centre are both outside Turkey are taxed only on income earned in Turkey, and the third paragraph lists the income items constituting corporate income under limited liability.
Article 30 of the same Law provides for corporate tax withholding at 15% on the income items of institutions subject to limited liability listed in the article by those paying or accruing them, in cash or on account, including advances; withholding rates were set by Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 published in the Official Gazette dated 3/2/2009. However, the article contains no provision for withholding on payments within the scope of commercial income.
According to these explanations, if the software use service obtained by your Company from the Ireland-resident firm for video meetings with your customers is sold to end consumers or used in the business without any modification and/or reproduction, the income earned by the foreign-resident firm will be commercial income, and no tax will be withheld on such payments.
II- DOUBLE TAX TREATY
The Agreement between the Republic of Turkey and … for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital Gains has applied since 1 January 2011.
Article 7 of the Agreement, the text of which is available on our Administration's website www.gib.gov.tr, contains provisions on the taxation of business profits.
Within these provisions, if computer programs obtained by your Company from the …-resident firm are used in your business or sold to end consumers without any modification and/or reproduction, the income earned by the Ireland-resident firm will be business profits and will be assessed under Article 7 of the Agreement. In this case, Turkey will have no taxing right over the income as long as the firm has no permanent establishment in Turkey under Article 5 of the Agreement. Otherwise, Turkey will also have a taxing right limited to the amount attributable to that permanent establishment. Article 5 of the Agreement clearly specifies when a permanent establishment will or will not arise in the other state.
On the other hand, under the Agreement, double taxation arising where Turkey has a taxing right will be eliminated in Ireland by the credit method under Article 23 ("Elimination of Double Taxation").
III- VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities,
- in Article 1/2, that all kinds of imports of goods and services, are subject to VAT,
- in Article 4/1, that a service is any transaction other than deliveries, deemed deliveries and imports of goods, and may take forms such as doing, processing, creating, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, preserving, preparing, evaluating, leasing something, or undertaking not to do something,
- in Article 6, that a transaction being performed in Turkey means goods being in Turkey at the time of delivery, the service being performed in Turkey or being benefited from in Turkey,
- in Article 9/1, that where the taxpayer has no domicile, workplace, legal seat or business centre in Turkey, and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold the parties to taxable transactions liable for payment of the tax in order to secure the tax receivable.
Section (I/C-2.1.2.1.), titled "Transactions by Those Whose Domicile, Workplace, Legal Seat and Business Centre Are Not in Turkey", of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:
"2.1.2.1.1. General
Under Article 1 of Law No. 3065, a service must be performed in Turkey to fall within the scope of VAT. Article (6/b) of the same Law provides that services performed or benefited from in Turkey are deemed performed in Turkey.
Accordingly, services performed in Turkey by those whose domicile, workplace, legal seat and business centre are not in Turkey, and services they perform abroad but which are benefited from in Turkey, are subject to VAT.
In such services, although the taxpayer is essentially the service provider, since it has no domicile, workplace, legal seat or business centre in Turkey, the full VAT is declared and paid by the domestic counterparty benefiting from the service as responsible party.
Where the service is exempt from tax, or performed and benefited from abroad, no VAT is declared as taxpayer or responsible party.
For VAT to be declared as responsible party, the counterparty benefiting from the service in Turkey need not be a VAT taxpayer. Those without VAT liability must also withhold VAT for such services and declare and pay it with VAT Return No. 2.
Examples of services obtained from abroad that must be subject to withholding include, by firms without a domicile, workplace, legal seat or business centre in Turkey:
- an architectural project service drawn abroad and sent to Turkey for a shopping centre to be built in Turkey,
- consultancy services provided from abroad on operating a power plant in Turkey,
- computer software services provided from abroad to a general budget administration without VAT liability,
- a service of sending information from abroad on worldwide legal developments related to its field to a civil society organization without VAT liability."
Accordingly, the "…" software service you purchased from … Limited, resident in …, is subject to VAT under Article 1 of Law No. 3065. If the said firm has a permanent establishment in Turkey due to this service, the VAT calculated on the invoice for the service must be declared by the firm with VAT Return No. 1, and the VAT shown on this invoice can be deducted in your VAT Return No. 1. If the firm has no permanent establishment in Turkey due to these services, the calculated VAT must be declared and paid by you as responsible party with VAT Return No. 2. VAT declared and paid with VAT Return No. 2 can be deducted in VAT Return No. 1.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.