A company headquartered in a technology development zone, with a branch running both an R&D centre under Law No. 5746 and, through a separate team, software services for foreign customers, asked whether it can use the R&D deduction and the CTL Art. 10/1-ğ deduction together at the same branch address.
The Administration's view:
- Article 4/5 of Law No. 5746 provides that those benefiting from its incentives cannot also benefit from CTL Art. 10/1-ğ and Provisional Article 2 of Law No. 4691.
- However, if the revenue, expenses and costs of the foreign software activities carried out at the same branch with different functions and personnel are tracked in separate accounts, common expenses are appropriately allocated, the activity is run independently of R&D and its expenditures are not subjected to the R&D deduction, using the R&D deduction does not prevent the CTL Art. 10/1-ğ deduction.
- From 1/1/2023, the CTL Art. 10/1-ğ deduction is 80%, provided all the income is transferred to Turkey by the return filing date.
The ruling is relevant to companies with R&D centres that also provide software services abroad.
Full text
Subject: Benefiting from Law No. 5746 and CTL Art. 10/1-ğ at the same address
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that:
- your Company was established to provide information technology services needed by the finance sector and serves … institutions in … countries by producing creative and effective solutions,
- software development is carried out under Law No. 4691 at the company headquarters in …,
- at the company branch in …, you carry out R&D centre activity under Law No. 5746, and at the same address, software services are provided to foreign customers by software and support personnel working as a separate team,
- deductions under Article 3 of Law No. 5746 and Article 10/1-ğ of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 are applied to your income from activities carried out by personnel at the branch address separated by function, and the revenue, expense and cost items of these function-separated structures are tracked and recorded separately in your legal books,
and our Administration's opinion is requested on whether your legal entity can benefit from the deductions under Article 3 of Law No. 5746 and Article 10/1-ğ of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 for your structures separated by function.
The first paragraph of Article 10 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, titled "Other deductions", lists deductions that may be made from corporate income in determining the corporate tax base provided they are shown separately on the corporate tax return, and subparagraph (ğ) provides:
"80% of the income earned exclusively from these activities by service enterprises operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance upon the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal seat and business centre are abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, and by enterprises operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Turkey (phrase amended by Article 59 of Law No. 7491; in force 28.12.2023 to apply to income earned from 1/1/2023), provided that all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is earned must be filed.
To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the customer abroad.
..."
Provisional Article 2 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 provides: "Income earned by managing companies under this Law and income earned by income and corporate taxpayers operating in the Zone exclusively from software, design and R&D activities in this Zone are exempt from income and corporate tax until 31/12/2028."
The first paragraph of Article 3, titled "Deduction, exemption, support and incentive elements", of Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities provides that all R&D and innovation expenditures made in technology centre enterprises, R&D centres, R&D and innovation projects supported by public institutions and organizations, foundations using funds and loans from international institutions or public institutions established by law or under technology development project agreements to support R&D projects, or international funds, pre-competitive cooperation projects and by those benefiting from techno-entrepreneur capital supports, and all design expenditures made exclusively in design projects supported by the above institutions under this Law and in design centres, are deducted in determining corporate income under Article 10 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 dated 13/6/2006 and commercial income under Article 89 of Income Tax Law No. 193 dated 31/12/1960.
On the other hand, the fifth paragraph of Article 4, titled "Application and supervision principles", of the same Law provides: "Those benefiting from the deductions, exemptions, supports and incentives under this Law cannot also benefit from the provisions of Article 89/1-13 of Law No. 193, Article 10/1-ğ of Law No. 5520 and Provisional Article 2 of Law No. 4691."
Under these provisions and explanations, 50% of the income from services provided abroad before the amendment by Law No. 7491, and, after that amendment, to be applied in following periods including income earned from 1/1/2023, 80% of the income provided that all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date the corporate tax return for the relevant period must be filed, can be deducted in the return.
On the other hand, it is stated that the R&D and software service activities you carry out at the branch address of your Company, whose headquarters operates in a Technology Development Zone, are completely separate from each other, carried out by completely different teams in separate areas and locations, accounted for separately on a project basis, and their income and expenses are tracked separately.
The fact that you benefit from the R&D deduction under Law No. 5746 will not prevent you from benefiting from Article 10/1-ğ of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, provided that the revenue, expenses and costs of the foreign software activities your Company performs at the same branch address but with different functions and personnel are tracked in separate accounts, common expenses are appropriately allocated, the software activities are carried out independently of the R&D activities, and the expenditures for these activities are not subjected to the R&D deduction.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.