A company with an R&D centre certificate asked about the R&D deduction and incentive treatment of raw materials, personnel and depreciation costs of test production and prototype work at its factories outside the R&D centre, carried out to measure the usability of the final product, and of private health insurance and clothing provided to R&D personnel.
The Administration's view:
- Expenditures for testing the final product inside or outside the enterprise are within R&D; raw materials actually used in test production and depreciation of equipment installed on production lines for testing and of the related lines can be subject to the R&D deduction.
- Depreciation of lines also used in other activities is taken into account only for the days used in R&D; lines whose days of use cannot be determined cannot be included.
- Wages of R&D personnel for time necessarily spent on test/prototype work outside the centre are within the withholding incentive, subject to management approval and informing the Ministry; support personnel and non-R&D-centre personnel cannot benefit.
- Private health insurance premiums are included in wages; they are deducted from net wages up to 15% of the wage and the annual minimum wage limit, and the incentive is applied accordingly.
- Clothing given as fixtures and taken back on leaving is exempt; other clothing benefits are included in wages and taken into account in the wage on which the incentive is based.
The ruling is relevant to R&D centres carrying out test production outside the centre.
Full text
Subject: R&D, innovation and design expenditures
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that your company holds an R&D centre certificate, that the activities of your R&D project are carried out within the physical boundaries of the R&D centre, but that, at the stage of creating the final product, you carry out test production and prototype work at your factories outside the R&D centre's physical boundaries to measure the usability of the product and make necessary changes, and that test production is necessarily carried out on the production lines at your factories because the production lines within the R&D centre are not of adequate size and capacity. Our Administration's opinion is requested on whether, for the test production and prototype work at your factories outside the R&D centre:
- the raw materials and supplies used in test production,
- personnel expenses relating to the time R&D centre personnel spend at the factories during test production,
- labour costs of personnel who take part in test production but are not R&D centre personnel,
- depreciation of plant, machinery and equipment at the factories used in test production, in proportion to the test period, and depreciation of equipment purchased solely for test production and installed on existing production lines,
- and private health insurance and clothing expenses included in R&D personnel payroll as wages in kind
can be subject to the R&D deduction.
CORPORATE TAX LAW
The first paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 5746 provides:
"(1) R&D and design deduction: All R&D and innovation expenditures made in technology centre enterprises, R&D centres, R&D and innovation projects supported by public institutions and organizations, foundations established by law or using funds or loans from international institutions or public institutions under technology development project agreements to support R&D projects, or international funds, pre-competitive cooperation projects and by those benefiting from techno-entrepreneur capital supports, and all design expenditures made exclusively in design projects supported by the above institutions under this Law and in design centres (...), are deducted in determining corporate income under Article 10 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 dated 13/6/2006 and commercial income under Article 89 of Income Tax Law No. 193 dated 31/12/1960.
..."
Article 7, titled "Scope of R&D, innovation and design expenditures", of the Implementation and Supervision Regulation on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities lists the expenditures that can be subject to the R&D deduction, and its first paragraph states:
"(1) Expenditures considered within R&D and innovation activity and design activity are as follows:
a) Raw material and supply expenses:
1) Covers all kinds of direct raw materials, auxiliary materials, operating supplies, intermediate products, spare parts, prototypes and similar expenses, and expenses for acquiring tangible assets that cannot be depreciated under Tax Procedure Law No. 213 dated 4/1/1961.
2) Costs relating to the part of raw material and other material stocks actually used in R&D and innovation or design activities are R&D, innovation and design expenditures. Therefore, cost amounts of raw materials and other materials not yet used in these activities must be monitored in stock accounts, and those used, sold or disposed of must be deducted from stock accounts.
b) Depreciation:
1) Consists of depreciation of depreciable assets acquired to carry out R&D, innovation or design activities.
2) Depreciation of machinery and equipment also used in activities other than R&D, innovation or design is calculated according to the number of days they are used in R&D, innovation or design activities.
c) Personnel expenses:
1) Wages accrued for R&D or design personnel employed to carry out R&D, innovation or design activities and within the income tax withholding incentive, and similar expenses. Wages corresponding to time spent outside R&D or design centres and considered within the income tax withholding incentive within limits set by the President are also subject to the R&D and design deduction.
2) Wages within the income tax withholding incentive of support personnel taking part in and directly related to R&D, innovation or design activities, not exceeding ten percent of the number of full-time equivalent R&D or design personnel, and similar expenses are also personnel expenses.
3) In case of part-time work, wage amounts found by taking into account the ratio of time personnel devote to R&D, innovation or design activities to total working time are considered R&D, innovation or design expenditure.
ç) General expenses:
...
2) Insurance expenses relating to R&D, innovation or design activities and expenses for books, journals and similar scientific publications are also within this scope.
3) Shares to be calculated on common general operating expenses according to various criteria, excluding rent or depreciation, water and energy expenses calculated for R&D or design centres, are not considered within this scope.
..."
General Communiqué Serial No. 6 on Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities states:
- in Article 3, titled "Scope of R&D and design activities",
"...
(6) Under Law No. 5746, R&D activity essentially ends at the stage where trials end and first production is made. The R&D project is deemed completed from the moment the product obtained becomes marketable. Expenditures made after this date are not considered R&D expenditures. However, work to develop the product obtained from a completed project is considered a new R&D project.
(7) Expenditures made to test, inside or outside the enterprise, products obtained at the stage of creating the final product in order to measure their usability and make changes where necessary are within R&D activity. However, expenditures on planning commercial production and the mass production process, and on samples produced and distributed to promote the product, are outside R&D activity."
- in Article 4, titled "Expenditures that can be subject to the R&D and design deduction",
"(1) Expenditures made within R&D and innovation activities and design activities that can be subject to the R&D and design deduction are as follows.
...
b) Depreciation: Depreciation of depreciable assets acquired to carry out R&D, innovation or design activities is within this scope. In this framework, all depreciation calculated under the Tax Procedure Law on immovables allocated only to R&D and design projects or used exclusively as R&D or design centres can be taken into account in determining the deduction amount. Depreciation of machinery and equipment also used in activities other than R&D, innovation or design is calculated according to the number of days they are used in these activities.
...
ç) General expenses: Covers expenses made to ensure the continuity of the activity carried out in R&D or design centres, such as rent, water, energy, maintenance-repair, communication, transport expenses (including post, cargo, courier and similar) of these centres and maintenance and repair expenses of machinery and equipment used in them. Expenses that can be taken into account are those incurred for places used exclusively as R&D or design centres and other expenses directly related to these activities. Therefore, rent expenses for immovables leased and used exclusively as R&D or design centres are also within this scope.
...
2) Shares to be calculated on common general operating expenses according to various criteria, excluding rent or depreciation, water and energy expenses calculated for R&D or design centres, are not considered within this scope.
..."
Under these provisions and explanations:
- since the costs of the part of raw materials and supplies used in test production actually used in your R&D activity, and the expenditures you make to test products obtained at the stage of creating the final product inside or outside the enterprise to measure their usability and make changes where necessary, are within R&D activity, the depreciation of the equipment you installed on existing production lines to test the final product inside or outside the enterprise and of the production lines on which that equipment is used can be taken into account in calculating the R&D deduction amount within the explanations in the said Regulation and Communiqué. In this context, expenses for raw materials and supplies used in test production at your factories outside the R&D centre can also be subject to the R&D deduction.
- it is natural that, for depreciation calculated on your existing production lines also used in activities other than R&D, the part corresponding to the number of days these lines are used in R&D activity can be taken into account in determining the R&D deduction amount.
- however, depreciation of production lines not used in R&D projects throughout the accounting period and of production lines whose number of days of use in R&D cannot be determined cannot be subject to the R&D deduction.
- on the other hand, it is natural that wages accrued for R&D personnel employed to carry out R&D and innovation activities under Law No. 5746 and within the income tax withholding incentive are considered within R&D, innovation and design expenditures.
INCOME TAX LAW
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 61, titled "Definition of wages",
"Wages are money and goods given, and benefits provided that can be represented in money, in return for services to those working dependent on an employer and attached to a specific workplace.
The fact that wages are paid under the names of allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial liability compensation), appropriation, raise, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense allowance or other names, or are set as a certain percentage of profit provided this is not a partnership relationship, does not change their nature.
..."
- in Article 63, titled "Actual wages",
"...
3. Provided the insurance is concluded with a pension or insurance company located and headquartered in Turkey: 50% of premiums paid by the employee for life insurance policies for the employee, spouse and minor children, and premiums paid by the employee for personal insurance policies such as death, accident, health, illness, disability, unemployment, maternity, birth and education (the total premiums to be deducted cannot exceed 15% of the wage earned in the month of payment and the annual amount of the minimum wage on an annual basis. The President is authorized to reduce the rates in this subparagraph by up to half, increase them up to twofold and redetermine the limit, not exceeding twice the annual amount of the minimum wage.)
..."
- in Article 94, titled "Tax withholding",
"Public administrations and institutions, state economic enterprises, other institutions, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed persons obliged to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural income on the balance sheet or farm account basis must, when making the payments listed below (including advances) in cash or on account, withhold tax against the income tax of the beneficiaries.
From wages paid to employees and payments listed in Article 61 deemed wages (excluding those benefiting from exemption), under Articles 103 and 104,
..."
- and in subparagraph (18) added to the first paragraph of Article 23 by Article 2 of Law No. 7349: "Wages of employees corresponding to the amount remaining after deducting the employee social security premium and unemployment insurance premium from the monthly gross minimum wage in force in the month of payment (However, in taxing wage income exceeding the exemption, the income bracket amounts and rates at which tax is calculated are determined taking into account the amounts within the exemption. The tax payable is calculated by deducting from the tax so found the part attributable to the exempt amount. The tax not collected due to the exemption cannot exceed the tax that would be calculated on the monthly minimum wage in the relevant month. For those receiving wages from more than one employer, this exemption applies only to the highest wage.)."
Article 4 of Law No. 7349 added, after the phrase "papers relating to wages" in paragraph (34) of section "IV- Papers relating to commercial and civil matters" of Table (2) annexed to Stamp Duty Law No. 488, the provision "(For wages under subparagraph (18) of the first paragraph of this article, the exemption applies to the part corresponding to the monthly gross minimum wage.)".
The necessary explanations and examples are given in General Communiqué on Income Tax Serial No. 319, published in the Official Gazette dated 27/1/2022 and numbered 31732.
In addition, the minimum living allowance under Article 32 of the Income Tax Law was abolished from 1/1/2022 by Article 3 of Law No. 7349; explanations on the minimum living allowance are given in General Communiqué on Income Tax Serial No. 265, published in the Official Gazette dated 4/12/2007 and numbered 26720.
On the other hand, Article 27 of the Income Tax Law, titled "Equipment and ration allowances", provides:
"...
2. Clothing given as fixtures (clothing given to employees by public and private offices and establishments as required by the work and taken back when they leave);
..."
Provisional Article 75 of the same Law provides: "Until 31/12/2023, 95% for those with a doctorate and those with at least a master's degree in one of the basic sciences under Law No. 5746, 90% for those with a master's degree and those with a bachelor's degree in one of the basic sciences, and 80% for others, of the income tax calculated, after applying the minimum living allowance, on wages earned for this work by R&D, design and support personnel specified in the second paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research and Development Activities dated 28/2/2008 is cancelled by deduction from the tax accrued on the withholding tax return. During this period, the provision of that article contrary to this article does not apply."
On the other hand, the second paragraph of Article 3, titled "Deduction, exemption, support and incentive elements", of Law No. 5746 provides:
"(2) Income tax withholding incentive: For R&D and support personnel, excluding public personnel, working in technology centre enterprises, R&D centres, R&D and innovation projects supported by public institutions, foundations established by law or using funds or loans from international institutions or public institutions under technology development project agreements to support R&D projects, or international funds, or carried out by TÜBİTAK, in enterprises benefiting from techno-entrepreneur capital supports and in pre-competitive cooperation projects, and for design and support personnel working in design projects supported by the above institutions under this Law and in design centres, 95% for those with a doctorate and those with at least a master's degree in one of the programme areas to be supported, 90% for those with a master's degree and those with a bachelor's degree in one of the programme areas to be supported, and 80% for others, of the income tax calculated, after applying the minimum living allowance, on wages earned for this work is cancelled by deduction from the tax accrued on the withholding tax return. Wages corresponding to earned weekly rest and annual paid leave periods and the holidays in Law No. 2429 on National Holidays and General Holidays dated 17/3/1981 are also within this incentive. Wages for hours over forty-five per week and overtime cannot benefit from this incentive. Where it is necessary to carry out part of the activities within a project outside the R&D or design centre, provided it is directly related to projects carried out in these centres by R&D or design personnel working there, subject to the approval of the R&D or design centre management and informing the Ministry of (...) Industry and Technology, the part of wages for these activities outside the centre to be determined separately or together by the President, not exceeding one hundred percent, and the part of wages for time spent outside the centre by R&D or design personnel working in R&D or design centres (...), not exceeding one and a half years for those doing a master's degree and two years for those doing a doctorate, to be determined separately or together by the President, not exceeding one hundred percent, are considered within the income tax withholding incentive. In addition, where doctoral graduate personnel in R&D or design centres teach in R&D and innovation at universities or R&D and design personnel mentor entrepreneurs in technology development zones, this work is considered within the income tax withholding incentive provided it does not exceed 8 hours per week. Further, time spent outside these centres other than in the cases specified in this paragraph is also considered within the incentive, provided it does not exceed twenty percent of the total number of personnel working in R&D or design centres within the incentive or of total working time subject to the incentive. The President is authorized to increase this twenty percent rate up to seventy-five percent in regional and/or sectoral areas to be determined or reduce it back to its statutory rate."
Article 1 of the Decision annexed to Decree No. 2016/9091 dated 1/8/2016 provides:
"(1) Where it is necessary to carry out the following activities outside the R&D or design centre, provided they are directly related to projects carried out in these centres by R&D or design personnel working in R&D or design centres established under Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities dated 28/2/2008, subject to the approval of the R&D or design centre management and informing the Ministry of Science, Industry and Technology, one hundred percent of wages for these activities outside the centre is considered within the income tax withholding incentive.
a) Laboratory, analysis, testing and experimental work.
b) Work carried out at other R&D or design centres.
c) Field research.
ç) Activities for prototype development.
d) Scientific events, limited to personnel working on the projects.
..."
The first and fourth paragraphs of Article 10, titled "Application of the income tax withholding incentive", of the Implementation and Supervision Regulation on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities state:
"(1) For R&D and support personnel working in technology centre enterprises, R&D centres, R&D and innovation projects supported by public institutions, foundations established by law or using funds or loans from international institutions or public institutions under technology development project agreements to support R&D, innovation or design projects, or international funds, or carried out by TÜBİTAK, pre-competitive cooperation projects and enterprises benefiting from techno-entrepreneur capital supports, and for design and support personnel working in design projects supported by the above institutions under the Law and in design centres, of the tax calculated on wages earned for this work, after deducting the minimum living allowance under Article 32 of Law No. 193 before 1/1/2022 and the tax corresponding to the minimum wage exemption under Article 23/1-18 of Law No. 193 after 1/1/2022, 95% of the remaining tax for those with a doctorate and those with at least a master's degree in one of the programmes to be supported, 90% for those with a master's degree and those with a bachelor's degree in one of the programmes to be supported, and 80% for others, is cancelled by deduction from the tax accrued on the withholding tax return.
...
(4) Where it is necessary to carry out part of the activities within a project outside the R&D or design centre, provided it is directly related to projects carried out there by R&D or design personnel working in R&D or design centres, subject to the approval of the R&D or design centre management and informing the Ministry, the part determined by the President, not exceeding one hundred percent, of wages for these activities outside the centre, and the part determined by the President, not exceeding one hundred percent, of wages for time spent outside the centre by R&D or design personnel, not exceeding one and a half years for those doing a master's degree and two years for those doing a doctorate, provided it is notified to the Ministry by the R&D or design centre management, are considered within the income tax withholding incentive.
a) The documentation and responsibility that time to be spent outside the R&D or design centre within activities to be determined by the President is within the project and necessary lies with the R&D or design centre management. In this context, the list of R&D or design personnel who benefited from the incentive is reported by project in the annual activity reports submitted to the Ministry.
...
c) Activities carried out outside R&D or design centres under this article and time spent outside for postgraduate education also benefit from the deduction, support and incentive elements provided under this Regulation...."
Under these provisions and explanations:
- within the decision taken by Article 1 of the Decision annexed to Council of Ministers Decision No. 2016/9091 dated 1/8/2016, where it is necessary to carry out test production or prototype work within a project outside the R&D centre, provided it is directly related to projects carried out in your company's R&D centre by R&D personnel working there, subject to the approval of the R&D or design centre management and informing the Ministry, wages for time spent in these activities outside the centre can be considered within the income tax withholding incentive. Wage payments to support personnel cannot be considered within this scope.
- personnel who are not R&D centre personnel but take part in test production or prototype work cannot benefit from the income tax withholding incentive.
- premiums paid for private health insurance taken out for R&D and support personnel working under Law No. 5746 and meeting the exemption conditions must be treated as wages within benefits provided to employees and included in monthly payrolls; this premium amount must be deducted in determining net wages, provided it does not exceed 15% of the wage earned in the month of payment and the annual amount of the minimum wage on an annual basis; and of the income tax calculated on the net wage (income tax base) so determined, after deducting the minimum living allowance under Article 32 of Law No. 193 before 1/1/2022 and the tax corresponding to the minimum wage exemption under Article 23/1-18 after 1/1/2022, 95% of the remaining tax for those with a doctorate and those with at least a master's degree in one of the basic sciences, 90% for those with a master's degree and those with a bachelor's degree in one of the basic sciences, and 80% for others must be cancelled by deduction from the tax accrued on the withholding tax return.
- clothing given to employees as fixtures as required by the work and returnable when they leave can be exempt from income tax; otherwise, where clothing is given to employees or a cash clothing allowance is paid, these benefits must be treated as wages, included in monthly payrolls and taken into account in calculating the wage on which the income tax withholding incentive under Article 3/2 of Law No. 5746 is based.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.