A textile manufacturer exporting through a group foreign trade capital company asked whether it can set aside a doubtful receivable provision for an uncollectable receivable after administrators were appointed to the foreign buyer and payments stopped.
The Administration's view:
- Under TPL Art. 323, a provision can be set aside for (unsecured) receivables in litigation or enforcement, including foreign receivables. It must be set aside in the year litigation or enforcement begins and cannot be set aside in later years.
- In an intermediated export, the right to set aside the provision essentially belongs to the intermediary exporter making the foreign sale; but if the manufacturer can and does bring lawsuits and enforcement in its own name against the foreign buyer, the manufacturer may set aside the provision, in which case the intermediary cannot.
- If the manufacturer cannot pursue the foreign buyer in its own name, it cannot set aside a provision; if its receivable from the foreign trade company is uncollectable, it may do so by starting proceedings against that company.
The ruling is relevant to manufacturers and suppliers exporting through intermediaries.
Full text
Subject: Whether the manufacturer can set aside a doubtful receivable provision when the receivable cannot be collected because administrators were appointed to the foreign buyer in an intermediated export
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the review of your ruling request forms and petitions referred to above, it is understood that, stating that:
- you manufacture textile products and export sales make up a significant part of your manufacturing/supply-based sales,
- your company, as producer/supplier, makes its foreign sales through … A.Ş., a foreign trade capital company among your group companies with which you signed an intermediated export agreement on …,
- four administrators were appointed to … Limited, established in …, one of the firms you export to, and payment of receivables was stopped; this was notified to your firm's finance manager on … by a letter dated …; the situation will be documented by an apostilled letter from the competent authorities abroad, but it has not yet been obtained due to the year-end workload in … and the pandemic,
- in sales made through … A.Ş., that firm does not purchase the goods in its own name and for its own account but only exports them under the intermediated export agreement, has no responsibility for finding customers or collecting receivables for the exports it intermediates, and the principal creditor of the export is your company,
you request our Administration's opinion on whether you can set aside a provision for doubtful receivables for the uncollected receivable you previously recorded as income.
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in paragraph (B) of Article 3,
"Proof: In taxation, the real nature of the taxable event and related transactions is essential...
Where a situation not in line with economic, commercial and technical requirements or not normal and customary given the nature of the event is claimed, the burden of proof lies with the party making the claim."
- in the third paragraph of Article 8, "Except for cases accepted by tax laws, private contracts concerning tax liability or tax responsibility do not bind tax offices.",
- in Article 323,
"Provided they relate to earning and maintaining commercial and agricultural income;
1. Receivables in litigation or enforcement;
2. Receivables not paid by the debtor despite protest or written demand more than once and not exceeding TL 3,000 (TL 14,000 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 556);
are deemed doubtful receivables.
A provision may be set aside in liabilities for the above doubtful receivables according to their recoverable value on the valuation date.
The receivables to which this provision relates are shown in the provision account. For secured receivables, the provision is limited to the amount remaining after the security.
Amounts of doubtful receivables collected later are transferred to the profit and loss account in the period collected.
Taxpayers keeping books on the business account basis record doubtful receivables determined under the above paragraphs in the expense section of their books, and amounts later collected in the income section in the period collected, in a way showing which receivables they relate to."
In this context, under Article 323 of Law No. 213, provided they relate to earning or maintaining commercial and agricultural income, receivables in litigation or enforcement, and unsecured receivables not in litigation or enforcement but not paid despite protest or written demand more than once and not exceeding TL 3,000 (TL 14,000 for 2024), are deemed doubtful receivables; receivables not of this nature or not meeting these conditions cannot be recorded as doubtful receivables. For a receivable to be accepted as in litigation or enforcement, a lawsuit petition must have been filed with the court or an enforcement petition with the enforcement office, and these applications must be pursued seriously.
In applying that article, provided they relate to earning and maintaining commercial and agricultural income (entered as revenue in the business records or related to the cost of goods or services traded), a provision can be set aside for all (unsecured) receivables in litigation or enforcement, and since it does not matter whether the receivable is domestic or foreign, the article also applies to foreign receivables. However, a provision for doubtful receivables must be set aside in the year litigation or enforcement begins, and a provision cannot be set aside in later periods for receivables for which no provision was set aside in the accounting period in which they became doubtful.
On the other hand, Article 5 of the Communiqué on the Status of Foreign Trade Capital Companies (Export: 2004/12) states:
"Foreign Trade Capital Companies are responsible, in terms of administrative and criminal liabilities, for all documents issued relating to the production, supply and export of goods they purchase and supply themselves domestically in their own name and for their own account in exports.
In exports carried out by manufacturer or supplier companies through Foreign Trade Capital Companies under an intermediated export agreement, unless the agreement provides otherwise, the manufacturer and supplier companies are directly and exclusively responsible for all documents relating to the production or supply of the goods and for administrative and criminal liabilities under export, foreign exchange, customs and other legislation relating to the export of the goods."
In addition, the intermediated export agreement signed between your company and … A.Ş. states:
- in article 2.3, that the customer/buyer abroad is obliged to pay the price of the goods bought from your company to your company through … A.Ş.,
- in article 3.1, that … A.Ş. intermediates foreign sales made by firms purchasing services from it as manufacturers or under their own brands,
- in article 3.3, that markets and customers abroad are found by your company, and all legal transactions and contracts between your company and the foreign-resident customer bind your company,
- in article 3.6, that your company is exclusively responsible to the customer, third parties and relevant official institutions, including claims from enforcement proceedings and lawsuits brought by third parties against … A.Ş. due to the manufacture/supply, packaging, stacking, transport and other aspects of the exported product, that compensation of all damages in these matters is legally, criminally and financially borne by your company, and that you will fulfil or pay to that firm all domestic/foreign payment claims directed at … A.Ş. arising from exports in line with its instructions,
- in article 3.13, that if the price of the exported goods is not paid on time, paid incompletely or not paid at all, all responsibility under the legislation in force and the initiatives to be taken with the customer lie with your company, … A.Ş. may seek recourse from your company for any material damage, criminal liability lies exclusively with your company, and where your company does not sue the customer or third parties over export problems, … A.Ş. may sue at your company's expense,
- in article 3.21, that your company's export receivable shown as a credit in … A.Ş.'s current accounts becomes definite when it reaches … A.Ş.'s domestic bank account, and that your company and third parties cannot claim any right for receivables not received from abroad, i.e. not definite,
- in article 3.22, that the factoring agreement between your company and … A.Ş. also covers this agreement,
- in article 6.1, that the date on the dispatch note you issue for the products to be exported will be the same as or earlier than the date of the invoice to be issued by … A.Ş. to the customer for export, that you will invoice … A.Ş. within seven days of the dispatch note date at the Central Bank (CBRT) buying rate on the registration (actual export) date in the customs declaration, not exceeding the month of actual export, and that … A.Ş. will not be deemed indebted or liable to your company for invoices issued in its name if the export is not realized or the price is not received,
- in article 6.2, that the invoice your company issues to … A.Ş. will be determined by multiplying the export price on that firm's invoice to the customer by the CBRT buying rate on the registration date in the customs declaration,
- in article 6.3, that the price of the goods will be paid to your company when the products are received by the customer and the amount is credited unconditionally to … A.Ş.'s account,
- in article 6.4, that if the price cannot be brought from abroad under Law No. 32 on the Protection of the Value of Turkish Currency, your company cannot claim any right or amount from … A.Ş. and responsibility lies with your company,
- in article 6.8, that whatever the payment method, the product price will be paid to your company after it is credited to … A.Ş.'s bank account, and that firm will transfer the Turkish lira equivalent of the foreign currency product price to your company's account after deducting commissions and other expenses.
Accordingly, in this specific case, for receivables arising from your foreign sales made through the intermediary exporter, setting aside a provision under Article 323 of the Law essentially belongs, subject to the conditions, to the intermediary exporter in the position of creditor making the foreign sale; however, if it is possible for your company to bring lawsuits and enforcement proceedings in its own name against the foreign-resident firm to collect the receivable, and depending on your starting the necessary lawsuit and enforcement proceedings against the foreign-resident firm, your company can set aside a provision for these receivables under that article. In that case, it is natural that the intermediary exporter cannot also set aside a provision under that article for the same receivables.
If it is not possible for your company to bring lawsuits and enforcement proceedings in its own name against the foreign-resident firm, your company cannot set aside a provision under that article for receivables arising from sales abroad made by the foreign trade firm. However, it is natural that if your receivable for the sale of these goods to the foreign trade firm cannot be collected from the foreign trade firm, you can set aside a provision for these receivables depending on starting the necessary lawsuit and enforcement proceedings against the foreign trade firm.
In addition, the provision must be set aside in the year litigation or enforcement begins, and a provision cannot be set aside in later periods for receivables for which no provision was set aside in the accounting period in which they became doubtful.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.