TREN
Contact us

Land registry fee on the return of an immovable transferred with a repurchase right under financial restructuring to a non-debtor company

Fees · Title deed feesLand registry fee on the return of an immovable transferred with a repurchase right under financial restructuring to a non-debtor companyPrivate ruling · 29 March 2024
Rast note

A company that transferred its immovable to a creditor institution with a repurchase right under the additional collateral clause of a financial restructuring agreement asked whether the transfer back to it is exempt from land registry fees under Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411.

The Administration's view:

  • Provisional Article 32 exempts transactions under the framework agreements and contracts from fees; but disposals by creditor institutions of assets acquired in this context are excluded, except transfers among creditors or to the debtor.
  • The company is not among the debtors in the restructuring agreement.
  • Therefore the transfer of the immovable acquired by the creditor to the non-debtor company cannot be exempted from fees under Provisional Article 32.

The ruling is relevant to third parties providing immovables as collateral in financial restructurings.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Transfer of an immovable under a repurchase (vefa) agreement made pursuant to a Financial Restructuring Agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From the review of the ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that a "Financial Restructuring Agreement" was signed on … under Provisional Article 32 of Banking Law No. 5411 regarding unpaid loans between the creditors (… A.Ş., … Bank A.Ş., … Financial Leasing A.Ş., several banks and leasing companies) and the debtors … A.Ş., … A.Ş. and … Ticaret A.Ş.; and that, under the additional collateral clause of the agreement, the immovable in … District, … Neighbourhood, block …, parcel … was transferred as collateral to … A.Ş. by establishing a repurchase (vefa) right with the transaction dated … and journal number …, within the "Repurchase (Vefa) Right Agreement" signed between your company and … A.Ş. on …, an opinion is requested on whether the land registry transaction for the transfer of this immovable by … A.Ş. to your company is exempt from land registry fees under Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411.

Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to the Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; the second paragraph of Article 63 provides that in transfers and acquisitions of immovables the fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value; and paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) provides that in transfers and acquisitions of immovables against consideration, under a life-care contract or by exchange, a proportional fee is charged separately for the transferor and the transferee.

Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is charged from persons exempted by special laws or for exempted transactions.

On the other hand, the first paragraph of Provisional Article 32, added to Banking Law No. 5411 by Article 17 of Law No. 7186 effective from 19/7/2019, provides that debtors having a credit relationship with banks, financial leasing, factoring and finance companies operating in Turkey and other financial institutions defined in the article, and determined in Framework Agreements prepared under the regulation issued by the Agency, may be subjected to restructuring as a whole or partially together with other debtors in their risk group, with measures relating to loans extended by these institutions, to enable them to fulfil their repayment obligations and continue contributing to employment; that the procedures and principles of financial restructurings under this article will be determined by Framework Agreements prepared under the regulation issued by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency; that the provisions of this article apply for two years from its publication; and that the President is authorized to extend this period by two more years. The seventh paragraph provides that transactions carried out under the principles set in the Framework Agreements and the Contracts drawn up under them are exempt from fees under Fees Law No. 492 (including judicial fees), and that the exemptions in this paragraph do not apply where creditor institutions dispose of assets and collateral acquired directly or indirectly through transactions under the Framework Agreements and Contracts, except transfers among creditor institutions or to the debtor.

Paragraph (1.1) of Article 1, titled "Parties", of the "Financial Restructuring Agreement" annexed to the ruling request form lists the creditor institutions and paragraph (1.2) the debtors, but your company is not among the debtors; paragraph (4.2) of Article 4, titled "Provisions on Determination of Receivables and Debts", states: "Within and as part of this financial restructuring agreement, through Repurchase (Vefa) Right Agreements concluded/to be concluded between … A.Ş. and … A.Ş. and between … A.Ş. and … A.Ş., the immovables named … with the status of parcel … in block … of … Neighbourhood, … District, … Province, and … in parcel … of block … of … Neighbourhood, … District, … Province, held as collateral for loans previously extended by DFHG, will pass to the ownership of … A.Ş. with a repurchase right against the Debtors' debt to DFHG."

On the other hand, Article 3 of the "Repurchase (Vefa) Right Agreement" dated … sets out under which conditions and for how long the repurchase right will be extended, Article 4 how the repurchase price will be calculated, and Article 5, titled "Provisions on Exercising the Repurchase Right", states that for … (… A.Ş.) to exercise the repurchase right, it must be exercised within the period in Article 3 and the repurchase price calculated under Article 4 must be paid in full to … A.Ş., and that … may request, upon exercising the right, that ownership be transferred to itself or to a third party it designates.

In addition, from the review of the letter dated … and numbered … and its annexes obtained from the … Land Registry Directorate, it is understood that the immovable in … District, … Neighbourhood, block …, parcel …, registered in your company's name, was transferred by sale to … A.Ş. on …, that on the same date a repurchase right valid until … was established on the immovable in your company's favour for TL …, and that on … the term of this right was extended by 2 years.

Accordingly, considering that the seventh paragraph of Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411 provides that its exemptions do not apply where creditor institutions dispose of assets and collateral acquired directly or indirectly through transactions under the Framework Agreements and Contracts, except transfers among creditor institutions or to the debtor, and that your company is not among the debtors in the "Financial Restructuring Agreement" dated …, the transfer to your company, which is not among the debtors, of the immovable in … District, … Neighbourhood, block …, parcel … acquired by … A.Ş. on … under that agreement cannot be exempted from fees under Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411.

Kindly be informed.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.