A company whose main activities do not include real estate trading asked whether the CTL Art. 5/1-e and VATL Art. 17/4-r exemptions apply to the sale of its building converted into a business building through a change of type.
The Administration's view:
- Gains from the sale of real estate held for trading purposes by corporations engaged in real estate trading are outside the exemption; where the commercial organization is not clearly evident, the multiplicity of transactions is considered.
- System records show the company made many property purchases and sales in different years, which is a presumption of real estate trading; the sale gain cannot be exempted under CTL Art. 5/1-e.
- For the same reason the sale is considered real estate trading and the VATL Art. 17/4-r exemption cannot be used.
The ruling is relevant to corporations frequently buying and selling real estate outside their main activity.
Full text
Subject: VAT and CT exemption on the sale of real estate registered in a company's assets
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the review of your ruling request form and its annexes referred to above, stating that your company's main fields of activity are "…", "…" and "…", that … is not among your main activities, that … acquired by your Company in … was sold, that your … land acquired in … was disposed of in … under an expropriation decision, and that … was converted into a business building through a change of type and this building is planned to be sold …, our Administration's opinion is requested on whether the sale can be considered within the exemptions under Article 5/1-e of the Corporate Tax Law and Article 17/4-r of the VAT Law.
I- In terms of the Corporate Tax Law
Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
- in subparagraph (e) of Article 5/1, before the amendment by Law No. 7456, that 75% of gains from the sale of participation shares held in assets for at least two full years, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights held for the same period, and participation shares of investment funds generating exempt income under subparagraph (a), and 50% of gains from the sale of real estate held in assets for the same period, are exempt,
- in Article 6, that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of Income Tax Law No. 193 on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
Furthermore, Provisional Article 16, added to the Corporate Tax Law by Article 22 of Law No. 7456, provides: "For real estate in corporations' assets before the effective date of this article, the provisions of subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 before the amendment by the Law introducing this article apply. However, the 50% rate in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of this Law is applied as 25% for real estate sale gains made after the effective date of this article."
In this regard, section "5.6.2.3.4. Not engaging in securities or real estate trading" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"Gains from the sale of exempt assets held for this purpose by corporations engaged in trading and leasing securities or real estate are outside the exemption.
The exemption applies in principle to all corporations. However, corporations whose activity is trading and leasing securities or real estate cannot benefit from the exemption for gains from the sale of assets acquired and held for this purpose.
The fact that the assets sold were registered in the corporation's assets for two full years does not change this. The same applies to taxpayers engaged in constructing real estate for sale. ..."
Furthermore, where real estate is bought and sold within a commercial organization, the purchase and sale is deemed an element of commercial activity; but where the commercial organization is not clearly evident from its form and material elements, the objective criterion showing that the activity is carried out with the intention of continuity is whether there is a multiplicity of transactions.
Accordingly, although … is not among your company's main activities, inquiries on system records show that your company has bought and sold many properties in different years; since these sales constitute a presumption of engaging in real estate trading, gains from the sale of the said real estate cannot be exempted from corporate tax under Article 5/1-e of the Corporate Tax Law.
II- Evaluation in terms of the Value Added Tax Law:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/4-r, before the amendment by Law No. 7456, that transfers and deliveries by sale of participation shares and real estate held in corporations' assets for at least two full years, and transfers and deliveries of real estate and participation shares (including sales at auction venues) to banks, financial leasing and financing companies by those indebted to them and their guarantors against their debts, and transfers and deliveries of such assets by financial leasing and financing companies, are exempt, and that deliveries of real estate and participation shares held for this purpose by corporations trading in exempt assets are outside the exemption,
- in Provisional Article 43, added by Article 8 of Law No. 7456, that for real estate in corporations' assets before the effective date of this article, the provisions before the amendment of Article 17/4-r by the Law introducing this article apply.
Under these provisions, although … is not among your company's main activities, since many real estate purchases and sales have actually been made, the sale of the said real estate must be considered within real estate trading, and the sale cannot be exempted from VAT under Article 17/4-r of the VAT Law.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.