A company that merged by takeover stated that it will purchase at actual value, under TCC Art. 140, and cancel the founder's usufruct certificates issued to third parties by the transferred company, and asked whether the amounts paid can be deducted from corporate income.
The Administration's view:
- Purchasing usufruct certificates at actual value in a merger amounts to a return to source; income from the destruction or redemption of these certificates, which represent no capital share, is treated as dividends and income tax is withheld.
- Such dividends earned by individuals are taxed under the declaration and offset principles of ITL Arts. 22/3 and 86.
- Payments of a dividend nature to usufruct certificate holders cannot be deducted in determining corporate income under ITL Art. 40 or CTL Art. 8.
The ruling is relevant to corporations purchasing usufruct certificates in a merger.
Full text
Subject: Whether amounts paid for usufruct certificates are deductible in determining corporate income
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above and the annexed petition, stating that your company merged by takeover with …, …, …, … under the conditions in Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 and Articles 19 and 20 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, and the merger was registered on …; that … (…), taken over with all its debts and receivables and dissolved through the merger, had founder's usufruct certificates (intifa senetleri) issued to third parties at its incorporation; that, because Article 140 of the Turkish Commercial Code obliges the acquiring company to grant equivalent rights to the holders of usufruct certificates of the transferred company or to purchase the certificates at their actual value at the date of the merger agreement, your company purchased the usufruct certificates issued to third parties by the transferred company … and paid the purchase price determined under … prepared within …; but that these certificates, whose price has been paid, will be cancelled under the legal obligation and the merger agreement, our Administration's opinion is requested on whether the amounts to be paid for these usufruct certificates can be deducted in determining your company's corporate income.
IN TERMS OF THE INCOME TAX LAW
Subparagraph (1) of the second paragraph of Article 75 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that dividends of all kinds of shares (including dividends paid to founder's shares and other usufruct shares, all payments made to shareholders as interest or under other names for the preparation period, dividends paid on participation certificates of investment funds established under the Capital Markets Law, and interest, dividends or similar income paid on mortgage-backed securities issued representing housing finance funds and asset-backed securities issued representing asset finance funds) are income from movable capital.
The third paragraph of Article 22 of the same Law, regulating the exemption for income from movable capital, provides that half of the dividends listed in subparagraphs (1), (2) and (3) of Article 75/2 obtained from full-liability corporations are exempt from income tax, that withholding is made under Article 94 on the exempt amount, and that the entire withheld tax is offset against the tax calculated on the annual return if the dividend is declared in the annual return.
Article 94 of that Law provides that the persons and institutions listed are obliged to withhold tax against the income tax of beneficiaries when making the payments listed (including advances) in cash or on account; sub-subparagraphs (6/b-i) and (6/b-ii) provide that withholding at 15% (10% under Presidential Decision No. 4936 published in the Official Gazette dated 22/12/2021 and numbered 31697) is made on dividends listed in Article 75/2-(1), (2) and (3) distributed by full-liability corporations to full-liability individuals, those not liable for income or corporate tax and those exempt from income tax, non-resident individuals and non-residents exempt from income tax (adding profit to capital is not deemed a distribution).
Furthermore, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 provides:
- regarding usufruct certificates:
"A) Issuance
ARTICLE 502- (1) The general assembly may, under or by amending the articles of association, decide to issue usufruct certificates in favour of holders of shares whose value has been destroyed in accordance with law, creditors, or those connected with the company for similar reasons. Article 348 applies to these certificates.
(2) Usufruct certificates, including those issued for founders, may be to order or bearer.
B) Provisions
ARTICLE 503- (1) Shareholder rights cannot be granted to usufruct certificate holders; however, they may be granted rights to participate in net profit or in the amount remaining on liquidation or to acquire newly issued shares."
- regarding protection of shares and rights in a merger:
"ARTICLE 140- (1) Shareholders of the transferred company have the right to claim shares and rights in the acquiring company of a value corresponding to their existing shares and rights. This claim is calculated taking into account the value of the assets of the merging companies, the distribution of voting rights and other significant matters.
...
(5) The acquiring company must grant equivalent rights to the holders of usufruct certificates of the transferred company or purchase the usufruct certificates at their actual value at the date of the merger agreement."
Under these provisions, if the amount of dividends earned by individuals remaining after the exemption exceeds the return filing threshold set for the relevant year (49,000 TL for 2020 income, 230,000 TL for 2024 income), it must be declared in the annual return, and the entire tax withheld at the distribution stage can be offset against the income tax calculated on the declared amount. Where the income earners have other income subject to declaration, their declaration position must be evaluated under Article 86 of the Income Tax Law.
Accordingly, where in a merger the acquiring company purchases the usufruct certificates at their actual value at the date of the merger agreement, the certificates return to their source; income from the destruction or redemption, upon return to the issuing company in the merger, of usufruct certificates that represent no capital share and give their holders no shareholder rights other than receiving a share of profit must be treated as dividends, income tax must be withheld, and such dividends earned by individuals must be taxed within the above provisions and explanations.
IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, titled "Net corporate income", provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 40 of the Income Tax Law lists the expenses deductible in determining commercial income, and Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law lists the expenses taxpayers may additionally deduct from revenue in determining corporate income calculated like commercial income.
Furthermore, Article 37 of the Income Tax Law states that income from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities is commercial income, and Article 38 of the same Law, titled "Determination of commercial income on the balance sheet basis", provides:
"Commercial income on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of the equity of the enterprise at the end and at the beginning of the accounting period. During this period, by the owner or owners:
1. Values added to the business are deducted from this difference;
2. Values withdrawn from the business are added to the difference.
In determining commercial income in this way, the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and the provisions of Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are observed."
Under these provisions and explanations, payments of a dividend nature made to the holders of usufruct certificates of the company transferred to your Company under the Turkish Commercial Code and Articles 19 and 20 of the Corporate Tax Law, for the purchase of the usufruct certificates under Article 140 of the Turkish Commercial Code, cannot be deducted in determining corporate income under Article 40 of the Income Tax Law or Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law.
Kindly be informed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.