TREN
Contact us

Deduction of a foreign branch loss from corporate income and valuation of head office–branch money movements

Corporate Income Tax · Foreign incomeDeduction of a foreign branch loss from corporate income and valuation of head office–branch money movementsPrivate ruling · 24 January 2024
Rast note

A corporation that opened a foreign branch for market research asked whether the loss from the branch's general expenses can be deducted from corporate income, how it is transferred to the general result accounts, and whether amounts sent by the head office to the branch for expenses must be valued.

The Administration's view:

  • Branch income is exempt if the CTL Art. 5/1-g conditions are met (at least 15% tax burden, transfer to Turkey by the return deadline); if not, the branch loss determined under the foreign legislation and transferred to the general result accounts can be deducted.
  • Deducting a foreign loss requires submitting the audit report and its translation under CTL Art. 9/1-b; if the report cannot be submitted within the return period the loss cannot be deducted, but it can be if submitted with an amended return and the other conditions are met.
  • Foreign-currency receivables and payables from supplies of goods and services between head office and branch are valued; current account balances from other money movements are not.

The ruling is relevant to corporations opening branches abroad.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether a foreign branch loss is deductible
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that a branch loss of … Euro arose in … at your branch opened at … on … for market research; that the loss resulted from expenditures for the branch's general expenses (rent, personnel wages etc.); that … Euro was sent by your head office to the branch to cover the loss; that the foreign branch's tax period is the calendar year and its filing period ends at the end of …; and that, although a report will be prepared on the loss by institutions authorized for audit in the relevant country, a return will not have been filed in that country within the corporate tax return filing period, our Administration's opinion is requested on whether the loss relating to earning and maintaining commercial income from non-exempt activities can be deducted from corporate income, whether the foreign branch loss is transferred to the general result accounts, and whether the amount sent by the head office to the foreign branch to cover expenses must be valued.

IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW

Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides: "Corporations listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal or business centre is in Turkey are taxed on all their income earned both in and outside Turkey."

Subparagraph (g) of Article 5/1 of that Law, titled "Exemptions", provides:

"Corporate income earned by corporations through their workplaces or permanent representatives abroad that meets the following conditions;
1) this income bears a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least 15% under the tax laws of the country where it arises,
2) it has been transferred to Turkey by the date the annual corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it was earned must be filed,
3) for corporations whose main activity is providing financing including financial leasing, insurance services or securities investment, this income bears a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax at least at the corporate tax rate applied in Turkey under the tax laws of the country where it arises.
Under this subparagraph, the total tax burden is determined according to the definition in subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph."

The third paragraph of the same article provides that, except for financing expenses relating to the acquisition of participation shares, expenses relating to corporations' exempt income or losses from exempt activities cannot be deducted from non-exempt corporate income.

Furthermore, Article 9 of the same Law, titled "Loss offset", provides:

"(1) In determining the corporate tax base, the following losses are deducted, provided the amounts for each year are shown separately in the corporate tax return:
...
b) Except for those relating to income exempt from corporate tax in Turkey, losses from foreign activities, provided they are not carried forward for more than five years, are deducted if:
1) the tax bases declared under the tax laws of the country of activity, including the loss, are reported each year by institutions authorized for audit under that country's legislation,
2) the original of this report and a translated copy are submitted to the relevant tax office in Turkey.
The tax returns, balance sheet and income statement annexed to the report to be prepared by audit institutions must be approved by the competent financial authorities in that country. If there is no audit institution in the country of activity, it is sufficient to have a copy of each year's tax return obtained from that country's competent authorities approved by the local Turkish embassy or consulate or, failing that, by representatives of the same nature of the country protecting Turkish interests there, and to submit the original and a translated copy to the relevant tax office.
Where a foreign loss deducted in Turkey is also offset or expensed in the relevant country, the foreign income to be included in the return in Turkey is the amount before the offset or expensing."

Section "5.8. Foreign branch income" and section "9.3. Offset of foreign losses" and subsequent sections of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 give the necessary explanations; section "9.3.5. Time of transferring activity results to general result accounts" states: "The explanations in section (5.9) of the Communiqué apply to the time of transferring foreign activity results to the general result accounts in Turkey. Losses must be transferred in the same currency in which profits from foreign activities were transferred to the general result accounts in Turkey."

Under these provisions and explanations, the income you earn from your branch in … can be exempt from corporate tax under CTL Article 5/1-g, provided it bears a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of 15% and is transferred to Turkey by the date the annual corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is earned must be filed. If the conditions are not met, this exemption cannot be used, and the branch loss determined under the relevant country's legislation as of the date the accounting period closes under that legislation and transferred to the general result accounts as of the same date can be deducted from corporate income.

On the other hand, since the filing period in … is …, if the report prepared by institutions authorized for audit in the country cannot be submitted within the corporate tax return filing period, the above conditions will not be met and the loss cannot be deducted. Naturally, if the report is submitted with an amended corporate tax return, the branch loss can be deducted in determining corporate income provided the other conditions are also met.

IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW

Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:

- in Article 258: "Valuation is the appraisal and determination of economic assets relevant to the calculation of tax bases.",
- in Article 259: "In valuation, the values that economic assets have on the days and times shown in the tax laws are taken as basis.",
- in Article 280: "Foreign currencies are valued at the stock exchange price. If it is understood that there was collusion in the formation of the stock exchange price, the purchase price is taken as basis instead.
If the foreign currency has no stock exchange price, the rate to be applied in valuation is determined by the Ministry of Finance.
This article also applies to receivables and payables in foreign currency, whether or not evidenced by bills. Among these, receivables and payables evidenced by bills not yet due can be reduced to their value on the valuation date under Articles 281 and 285 of this Law. However, where the interest rate is not written on the bill, the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) applicable on the valuation date is taken as basis."

Furthermore, section (5.9.2) of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:

"... Naturally, foreign-currency receivables and payables arising from goods exported by the head office to the foreign workplace by issuing invoices and from services rendered abroad by issuing invoices will be valued in the same way as receivables and payables arising from exports of goods or services, and valuation differences will be taken into account in determining the tax base.
It is clear that receivables and payables arising from other money movements between the head office in Turkey and the foreign workplace are not real receivables and payables. Therefore, there is no need to value current account balances based on such money movements."

In this context, since receivables and payables arising from money movements between you and your foreign branch other than purchases and sales of goods and services are not real receivables and payables, amounts in the current account based on these money movements need not be valued as receivables or payables.

Accordingly:

- foreign-currency receivables and payables arising from the supply of goods and/or services between you and your foreign branch must be valued in the same way as receivables and payables from exports/imports of goods or services, and the resulting exchange differences associated with income/expense accounts,
- the account balance based on other money movements between you and your foreign branch must not be valued, since the resulting receivables and payables are not real receivables and payables.

Kindly be informed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.