A company that both sells its own vehicles and intermediates third parties' vehicle sales on its own online platform asked whether intermediary fees can be taxed at the vehicle's rate (1%), whether its platform sales methods are auctions, and about VAT liability, the taxable event and documentation.
The Administration's view:
- For vehicles in its assets, the company invoices the buyer; in intermediated sales only, a taxpayer seller issues an invoice, a taxpayer buyer from a non-taxpayer seller issues an expense voucher (or a qualifying bank/payment institution document), and the company invoices its commission.
- As no physical venue is required, virtual public auctions under the "Opening Price Threshold" and "Minimum Price Threshold" systems are sales at auction venues; the company as organizer calculates VAT on the final sale price on the sale date and declares it with VAT Return No. 1.
- For an authorized second-hand dealer, the Art. 23/f special base (purchase price deducted) at the general rate applies to vehicles bought from non-taxpayers; the vehicle's own rate applies to vehicles bought from taxpayers.
- Fixed-price sales under the "Negotiated Sales" and "Buy Now" methods are not auctions; occasional sales by non-taxpayers are not subject to VAT, while continuous sales and sales by taxpayers are declared by the sellers.
- Platform/site service and intermediary fees are not in the lists and are subject to VAT at the general rate (20% from 10/7/2023).
The ruling is relevant to online second-hand vehicle platforms and second-hand vehicle dealers.
Full text
Subject: VAT application for second-hand vehicles sold on an online platform
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the review of your ruling request form and supplementary petitions referred to above, it is understood that, stating that one of your Company's fields of activity is second-hand vehicle trading, that your second-hand vehicle sales are mainly sales of used vehicles you own through an online sales platform you developed, that over time you developed a business model on your platform for intermediating sales of vehicles belonging to third parties, and that you use several different online sales methods within this model, our Administration's opinion is requested on:
1- whether, where you pass the sale price of a vehicle sold through the online platform as is to the natural or legal person selling the vehicle on the platform and that price is subject to 1% VAT, the fees and commissions charged separately from the buyer can also be treated as part of the vehicle sale price and subjected to 1% VAT instead of the general rate; and whether, where your Company itself is the seller (both for used vehicles in inventory and vehicles bought second-hand by your Company to be sold on the platform), the VAT rate on the sale price collected from the buyer and on fees and commissions charged separately from the buyer under names such as "site service fee, intermediary service fee" can be equalized,
2- whether the methods you developed for intermediating sales of third parties' vehicles on the online platform (Opening Price Threshold Sales System, Minimum Price Threshold Sales System, Negotiated Sales, Buy Now Method) are considered sales at auction venues for VAT purposes; in this framework, how and by whom the VAT liability on these sales will be fulfilled, when the taxable event occurs for VAT, how documentation should be arranged for these transactions, and what document the vehicle seller will issue where the VAT liability lies with your Company.
I- IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in Article 227: "Unless otherwise provided in this law, records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties must be documented...",
- in Article 229: "An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling goods or performing work, showing the amount owed by the customer for the goods sold or work done.",
- in subparagraph (5) of Article 230/1: "5. The delivery date of goods sold and the waybill number (where goods are carried or caused to be carried by the seller for delivery to the buyer, the seller, and where delivered goods are carried or caused to be carried by the buyer, the buyer, must issue a dispatch note for the goods carried and keep it in the vehicle.) ...",
- in Article 231: "The following rules are observed in issuing invoices: ... The invoice is issued within at most seven days from the delivery of goods or performance of the service. The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorized, taking into account separately or together the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, field of activity, sector or type of liability, to reduce this period or require the invoice to be issued at the moment of delivery or performance. Invoices not issued within these periods are deemed not issued at all. ...",
- in Article 232: "First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged to give invoices for goods sold or work done to: 1. first and second class merchants; 2. self-employed professionals; 3. merchants whose income is determined under the simple method; 4. farmers obliged to keep books; 5. tax-exempt tradesmen; and these are obliged to request and receive invoices. ...",
- in Article 234: "First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and self-employed professionals and farmers obliged to keep books issue an expense voucher (gider pusulası), to be signed by the person doing the work or selling the goods, for work done by or goods purchased from those not obliged to issue documents under this Law (excluding goods purchased from farmers not taxed under the actual method). The expense voucher issued for tax-exempt tradesmen has the force of an invoice given by them.
The expense voucher contains the nature of the work, the kind and type of goods with their quantity and price, the labour fee, the names and surnames (titles for legal entities) and addresses of the person having the work done and the person doing it, or the buyer and seller of the goods, and the date; it is issued in two copies and one copy is given to the person doing the work or selling the goods.
Expense vouchers are numbered consecutively within series and sequence numbers.
The expense voucher is issued within at most seven days from delivery of the goods or performance of the service. An expense voucher not issued within this period is deemed not issued at all.
Provided they contain the information in the second paragraph, the following replace the expense voucher:
a) where the price of the goods or service is paid to the seller within the period in the fourth paragraph through a bank defined in Banking Law No. 5411 dated 19/10/2005, payment institutions authorized under Law No. 6493 dated 20/6/2013, or the Post and Telegraph Organization Joint Stock Company established under Postal Services Law No. 6475 dated 9/5/2013, the documents issued by these institutions,
b) on return of goods purchased under Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 dated 7/11/2013 to those obliged to issue expense vouchers, where the amounts to be refunded under Law No. 6502 are refunded through the institutions in (a), the documents issued by these institutions,
c) documents issued, within their applicable legislation, by public institutions not obliged to issue documents under this Law for work they do or goods they sell.
The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorized to set the procedures for applying this article."
Accordingly:
a) where vehicles purchased by your Company and recorded in assets are sold through the online platform (whether or not by auction), your Company must issue an invoice in the buyer's name,
b) where vehicles to be sold through the online platform by various methods (whether or not by auction) are sold without being purchased by your Company (only intermediation):
- if the seller of the vehicle is a taxpayer, the seller must issue an invoice in the buyer's name under the general provisions,
- if the seller is not a taxpayer and the buyer is, the buyer must issue an expense voucher in the seller's name (subject to the fifth paragraph of Article 234 of Law No. 213),
- for commission income from the intermediation activity, your Company must issue an invoice in the name of the customer to whom you provide the service under the general provisions.
In addition, the invoice or expense voucher required in the above cases must be issued on the actual sale price (the final sale price for sales by auction).
Furthermore, for sales of third parties' vehicles intermediated by various methods, where the seller is not a taxpayer and the buyer is, the expense voucher is in principle issued by the buyer in the seller's name; however, from 1/11/2021, when the amendment to Article 234 of Law No. 213 by Law No. 7338 entered into force, if the sale price is paid within the period in that article through a bank, a payment institution authorized under Law No. 6493 or PTT A.Ş., the documents issued by these institutions (bank slip, receipt etc.) will also be accepted as documents replacing the expense voucher, provided they contain the information required in an expense voucher.
On the other hand, no document needs to be issued in vehicle purchases and sales between non-taxpayers.
II- IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities, and in Article 1/3-d, that sales at auction venues, are subject to VAT,
- in Article 8/1-a, that those performing deliveries of goods and services, and in Article 8/1-ç, that those making sales at auction venues, are the VAT taxpayers,
- in Article 10/a, that in deliveries of goods and performance of services the taxable event occurs at the moment of delivery or performance,
- in Article 23/d, that in sales at auction venues the base is the final sale price,
- in Article 23/f, that in deliveries by taxpayers trading in second-hand motor land vehicles or real estate of such vehicles or real estate purchased from non-VAT-taxpayers (including exempt purchases from taxpayers) and sold without substantial change in their nature, the base is the amount remaining after deducting the purchase price,
- in Article 30/b, that, except for those used for this purpose by persons whose activities partly or wholly consist of leasing or operating passenger cars, the VAT shown on purchase documents of businesses' passenger cars cannot be deducted from the VAT calculated on taxable transactions.
As is known, VAT rates on goods and services are determined, under the authority of Article 28 of Law No. 3065 and within its limits, by the Council of Ministers before the amendment by Decree-Law No. 700 and by the President thereafter.
In this context, VAT rates are applied at 1% for deliveries and services in list (I) annexed to Council of Ministers Decision No. 2007/13033, 8% for those in list (II) (10% from 10/7/2023 under Presidential Decision No. 7346 published in the Official Gazette dated 7/7/2023 and numbered 32241), and 18% for taxable transactions not in these lists (20% from 10/7/2023 under the same Decision).
Item 9 of section (B) of list (I) annexed to that Decision reads:
"Of the motor vehicles defined below, only "used" ones: Turkish Customs Tariff Schedule 8701.90.50.00.00 used ones and passenger cars and other motor vehicles principally designed for the transport of persons in heading 87.03 (other than those of heading 87.02) (including station wagons and racing cars). [(Only passenger cars, station wagons, racing cars, off-road vehicles, jeeps etc., motor caravans, electric, gas, solar-powered etc. motor vehicles, "8703.10.11.00.00 vehicles specially designed for travelling on snow with compression-ignition internal combustion piston engines (diesel or semi-diesel) or spark-ignition internal combustion piston engines", "8703.10.18.00.00 others"] [Excluding special-purpose motor vehicles such as ambulances, prisoner transport vehicles, cash transport vehicles, hearses and fire pilot vehicles.] (In deliveries of these vehicles by taxpayers having the right to deduct the VAT incurred on purchasing passenger cars under Article 30/b of the VAT Law, the tax rate provided in Article 1(a) of this Decision applies. In deliveries by taxpayers trading in second-hand motor land vehicles of vehicles purchased with the rate in Article 1/1(a) of this Decision applied, and in deliveries made applying the special base, the rate in Article 1/1(a) of this Decision applies."
The fifth paragraph of Article 1 of the Decision annexed to that Decision states that the term "used" in item 9 of section "B) OTHER GOODS AND SERVICES" of list (I) refers to vehicles not subject to special consumption tax under SCT Law No. 4760.
The VAT General Application Communiqué states:
- in section (I/A-1.3.): "... d) Under Article 1/3-d of Law No. 3065, sales at auction venues and customs warehouses are taxable. Whether the place where the auction is held is exclusively allocated to auctions does not change this. In such sales, tax is calculated on the final sale price.",
- in section (I/B-6.1.): "Under Article 1/3-d of Law No. 3065, all kinds of sales at auction venues, including public auction, negotiation and other forms of sale made for reasons such as compulsory enforcement, dissolution of co-ownership, foreclosure of mortgage and liquidation, are subject to VAT. The Law's provisions on exemptions and tax rates also apply to these sales.
In these sales, the taxable event occurs on the date of sale. Under Article 8/ç of Law No. 3065, the taxpayers are the private or official persons and/or organizations organizing the sales, and under Article 23/d the VAT base is the final sale price of the goods sold. However, in sales within dissolution of co-ownership, where the buyer is one of the co-owners, his share is deducted from the base as there is no transfer of ownership for that share.
Taxes paid on expenses in these sales cannot be deducted from the tax calculated on the final sale price of the goods, but can be deducted from the VAT calculated on the auction organizer's commission. If there is no commission, the taxes incurred are treated as expense or cost.
Declaration and payment obligations for these sales are fulfilled under general principles. VAT so collected by official organizations not obliged to file returns continuously due to other activities (excluding enforcement offices) is paid to the tax office within whose jurisdiction they are located within 7 (seven) days at the latest. However, if the collection exceeds 50,000 TL, it must be paid by the end of working hours the next day without waiting for this period.
In sales by auction, what matters is the organization of the event; the fact that only one person participates in the auction does not change the nature of the transaction.",
- in section (III/C-2.5.): "By Presidential Decision No. 845 dated 21/3/2019 published in the Official Gazette dated 22/3/2019 and numbered 30722, it was decided that the VAT rate be applied as 18% in deliveries of passenger cars purchased with 18% VAT by taxpayers trading in second-hand motor land vehicles.
Accordingly, from 22/3/2019, the effective date of the Decision, taxpayers trading in second-hand motor land vehicles will apply:
- 1% in deliveries of passenger cars purchased with 1% VAT,
- 18% in deliveries of passenger cars purchased with 18% VAT.
Furthermore, by Presidential Decision No. 5359 dated 28/3/2022, it was decided that the VAT rate be applied as 18% in passenger car deliveries by taxpayers trading in second-hand motor land vehicles applying the special base. Since passenger cars purchased by such taxpayers from another authorized dealer applying the special base cannot be considered passenger cars purchased with 18% VAT, 1% VAT is calculated on the entire sale price in delivering these vehicles."
Furthermore, section (III/A-4.9.) of the Communiqué, titled "Second-Hand Vehicle and Real Estate Trading", contains explanations and examples on Article 23/f of Law No. 3065.
Section "5.10. Rate Application in Vehicle Deliveries" of VAT Circular No. 60 explains which VAT rates apply according to the characteristics of vehicles.
Accordingly, since a physical venue is not required for an auction to exist, sales by public auction in a virtual environment are also considered sales at auction venues where the necessary conditions are met. Therefore, whether the website is exclusively allocated to auctions, and whether the sales by public auction there are commercial in nature or continuous, does not affect taxation.
Furthermore, from your ruling request form, petitions and annexes, it is understood that, of the methods you developed for sales of second-hand vehicles (belonging to third parties or your Company) on the online platform:
- in the "Opening Price Threshold Sales System", vehicles are offered for sale with a set starting price and a countdown timer; when the timer reaches zero, the three highest bids exceeding the opening price are sent to the vehicle owner, and the sale takes place when the owner approves one of the bids and the selected prospective buyer also approves,
- in the "Minimum Price Threshold Sales System", if the minimum price set by the vehicle owner of his own will is exceeded within the period indicated by a countdown timer on the platform, the three highest bids are sent to the owner, and the sale takes place when the owner approves one of the bids and the selected prospective buyer also approves,
- in the "Negotiated Sales Method", where the minimum price set by the seller is not exceeded, the vehicle is withdrawn for any reason, none of the bids received under the opening price threshold system is approved by the seller, or the buyer whose bid the seller approved withdraws by not giving final approval, the platform sale having failed, the vehicle is removed from the platform and transferred to your Company's off-platform second-hand sales department, after which customers who previously bid unsuccessfully on that or similar vehicles on the platform are contacted and offered the vehicle, and the sale takes place by sending the purchase offers received to the vehicle owner,
- in the "Buy Now Method", vehicles are offered on the platform at a fixed price set by the seller, and the sale takes place by selling to the first buyer accepting the fixed price within the defined period.
Within these provisions and explanations:
1- Sales made through the "Opening Price Threshold Sales System" and "Minimum Price Threshold Sales System" you developed for second-hand vehicle sales on the online platform are sales by public auction in a virtual environment and are therefore considered sales at auction venues. In this case:
- the sale at an auction venue of second-hand vehicles not purchased by your Company will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-d of Law No. 3065. Since the taxable event occurs on the date of sale, you must calculate VAT as of that date on the final sale price at the rate applicable to the vehicle. The VAT calculated for this transaction will be declared and paid by your Company with VAT Return No. 1.
On the invoice to be issued in the buyer's name by a liable seller whose vehicle is sold by auction, and on the expense voucher to be issued by the buyer where the seller has no liability, the VAT calculated on the final sale price must be shown together with a statement that the sale is a sale at an auction venue and that the VAT on the sale will be declared and paid by the auction organizer.
- if your Company trades in second-hand motor land vehicles and holds an authorization certificate under the Regulation on Trade in Second-Hand Motor Land Vehicles, the sale at an auction venue of second-hand vehicles purchased by your Company from non-VAT-taxpayers (including exempt purchases from taxpayers) without substantial change in their nature is subject to VAT under Article 1/3-d, and the VAT calculated at the general rate [18% until 9/7/2023 (inclusive), 20% from 10/7/2023] on the amount remaining after deducting the purchase price under Article 23/f must be declared by your Company with VAT Return No. 1.
- the sale at an auction venue of second-hand vehicles purchased by your Company from VAT taxpayers is subject to VAT under Article 1/3-d, and VAT must be calculated on the final sale price at the rate applicable to the vehicle and declared and paid by your Company with VAT Return No. 1.
2- Where sales under the "Negotiated Sales" and "Buy Now" methods you developed are made at a fixed price (without public auction):
- occasional sales of vehicles through your website by sellers without VAT liability will not be subject to VAT since they are not made by public auction and are not commercial in nature.
However, sales that are continuous and of a scale giving the sellers merchant status will be subject to VAT. The VAT on these sales will be declared by the sellers under general principles.
On the other hand, sales by VAT taxpayers through your website will be subject to VAT, and the calculated VAT will be declared by these taxpayers.
- if your Company trades in second-hand motor land vehicles and holds an authorization certificate under the Regulation on Trade in Second-Hand Motor Land Vehicles, in sales of vehicles purchased from non-VAT-taxpayers (including exempt purchases from taxpayers) and registered in the business's name, the VAT calculated at the general rate [18% until 9/7/2023 (inclusive), 20% from 10/7/2023] on the amount remaining after deducting the purchase price under Article 23/f must be declared by your Company with VAT Return No. 1.
In sales of vehicles purchased by your Company from VAT taxpayers, VAT must be calculated on the sale price at the rate applicable to the vehicle and declared by your Company with VAT Return No. 1.
Furthermore, since it is not included in the lists annexed to Decision No. 2007/13033, the intermediary service for vehicle sales through the website (platform/system usage fee, site service fee, intermediary service fee, service fee) is subject to VAT at the general rate [18% until 9/7/2023 (inclusive), 20% from 10/7/2023].
Also, naturally, in these sales, whether the vehicle owner has the right to deduct the VAT incurred on purchasing passenger cars under Article 30/b of Law No. 3065 and whether it is a taxpayer trading in second-hand motor land vehicles must also be taken into account within the above explanations.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.