TREN
Contact us

Renting ATM space from public legal entities is not an operating right lease and is exempt under VATL Art. 17/4-d

VAT · ExemptionsRenting ATM space from public legal entities is not an operating right lease and is exempt under VATL Art. 17/4-dPrivate ruling · 11 January 2024
Rast note

A bank asked whether ATM spaces and service buildings rented directly from public universities, hospitals, municipalities and other public legal entities, outside their economic enterprises, are operating right leases and whether they are exempt from VAT.

The Administration's view:

  • Leaving real estate to a tenant allocated to an economic activity or made ready for operation is leasing an operating right and is subject to VAT.
  • Public bodies leasing to a bank, as ATM space or a service building, real estate not included in their economic enterprises is real estate leasing and exempt under VATL Art. 17/4-d.
  • If the real estate is included in an economic enterprise, the leasing is subject to VAT under VATL Art. 1.

The ruling is relevant to banks renting space from public institutions.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether renting ATM space from public legal entities is leasing of an operating right
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that your bank makes ATM space or service building rental agreements with public universities, public hospitals, municipalities or other public legal entities; that in these direct rentals there is no public equipment within the rented real estate, which is rented as an empty building, empty area or ATM space; that some public legal entities designate an area on a concrete base as ATM space, line up aluminium-sheet ATM cabins side by side in it, prepare sidewalks and railings, and rent it to several banks; but that your bank's rentals are made directly from the public legal entities rather than their economic enterprises, our Administration's opinion is requested on whether rental tenders by public legal entities for real estate not included in their economic enterprises constitute operating rights and, if not, whether the rentals are exempt under VAT Law No. 3065.

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 1/3-f, that leasing of goods and rights specified in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of institutions belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and unions formed by them, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organizations, and of revolving fund institutions or other institutions belonging or subject to them, are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/4-d, that leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises is exempt from VAT.

The VAT General Application Communiqué states:

- in subsection (I/B-2.1.), titled "General", of section (I/B-2.), titled "Taxation of Public Institutions, Associations and Foundations and Professional Organizations":
"Deliveries and services, in line with their founding purposes and not within commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activity, of general budget administrations, special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and unions formed by them, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organizations listed in Article 1/3-g of Law No. 3065 are not subject to tax.
Leasing of goods and rights within Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under Article 1/3-f of the Law. However, leasing of real estate of the above organizations not included in their economic enterprises is exempt from tax under Article 17/4-d of the Law.
Furthermore, institutions belonging or subject to, or established and operated by, the above organizations and revolving fund institutions are regarded as economic enterprises. Their commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are taxed. In this framework, bus, gas, water, electricity, slaughterhouse, cold storage and similar enterprises attached to municipalities and revolving fund institutions are taxed for their non-exempt activities.",
- in section (II/F-4.4.), titled "Leasing of Real Estate Not Included in Economic Enterprises": "Article 1/3-f of Law No. 3065 subjects to tax the leasing of goods and rights specified in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law. Conversely, Article 17/4-d exempts from tax the leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises.
Only real estate falls within this exemption, and leasing of other goods and rights listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under the general provisions.
...
Leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises (land, buildings and integral parts and accessories leased with them, fishing grounds and weirs, and rights registered as real estate in the land registry) is not subject to VAT; only leasing of real estate included in an economic enterprise is subject to VAT.
Leasing of other goods and rights listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law other than the above real estate (exploration, operating and concession rights and licences and other rights) is subject to VAT regardless of whether they are included in an economic enterprise.
..."

Furthermore, section (1.4), titled "Leasing Transactions", of VAT Circular No. 60 states:

"Article 1/1 of the VAT Law provides that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities, and Article 1/3-f that leasing of goods and rights specified in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law, are within the scope of VAT.
...
Accordingly, all kinds of leasing by economic enterprises are subject to VAT under Article 1/1 of the VAT Law.
...
Although leasing of goods and rights listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under Article 1/3-f of the VAT Law, leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises is exempt from VAT.
In this framework, leasing of an operating right in the form of leaving a business or establishment to another's use for a certain price and period will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-f of the Law, even if defined as income from immovable property for income tax purposes.
Accordingly:
- leasing by a municipality or state university of its real estate not included in its economic enterprise to banks for placing ATMs or use as a bank branch is exempt from VAT under Article 17/4-d of the Law. However, if the real estate is included in the economic enterprise of the municipality or university, this leasing will be subject to VAT under Article 1 of the Law."

Workplace rental services cover the leasing of the bare ownership of real estate used as workplaces, such as buildings, offices and shops, by lease contract. However, where real estate is allocated to carrying out an economic activity and/or made ready for operation and left to the tenants' use, such leasing has the nature of leasing an operating right attached to the real estate, and cannot be considered a workplace rental service.

Accordingly, the leasing by public administrations, public hospitals, associations, foundations, municipalities and universities to your bank, for use as ATM space or a service building, of their real estate not included in their economic enterprises will be considered real estate leasing rather than leasing of an operating right and will be exempt from VAT under Article 17/4-d of the Law.

On the other hand, if the real estate is included in the economic enterprise of the public administrations, public hospitals, associations, foundations, municipalities and universities, this leasing will be subject to VAT under Article 1 of the Law.

Kindly be informed.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.