TREN
Contact us

Corporate tax exemption and VAT liability of a Village Service Union

Tax Procedure · DocumentationCorporate tax exemption and VAT liability of a Village Service UnionPrivate ruling · 4 January 2024
Rast note

A Village Service Union stated that it would carry passengers for a fee with electric service vehicles and bicycles acquired under a project, and asked whether a separate enterprise must be set up and whether a cash register must be used.

The Administration's view:

  • Continuous paid passenger transport creates an economic public establishment within the Union, with corporate tax liability separate from the legal entity.
  • As long as the activity stays within municipal borders and is not used for other purposes, that establishment is exempt from corporate tax under CTL Art. 4(1)(ı).
  • The activity is subject to VAT under VATL Art. 1/3-g; VAT liability is established for the economic enterprise.
  • The economic enterprise issues documents as a first-class merchant: an invoice, or a retail sales document where no invoice is required.
  • As the activity is not exempt from the cash register requirement, a new generation cash register must be used.

The ruling is relevant to passenger transport by village unions and municipal entities.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Corporate tax, VAT, documentation and cash register treatment of a Village Service Union's paid passenger transport within municipal borders
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, you stated that, under the … project, … electric service vehicles, … mountain bikes and … electric bicycles were acquired and that passenger transport services would be provided with these vehicles for a fee, and you requested our Office's opinion on whether a new commercial enterprise should be established within the Union for this activity or whether the activity could be carried on under the existing tax identification number, and whether a cash register (ÖKC) must be used for this activity.

CORPORATE TAX LAW:

Article 1(1)(c) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 brings economic public establishments within the scope of corporate tax liability, and Article 2 of the same Law provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or attached to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and institutions, whose activities are continuous and which fall outside the first and second paragraphs, are economic public establishments; their not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties assigned by law, their lack of legal personality, and their lack of separate accounting, allocated capital or premises do not affect their tax liability.

Article 4(ı) of the Law, titled "Exemptions", provides that the following, operated by special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages, the unions formed by them or entities attached to them, are exempt from corporate tax:

1) Water utilities distributing through canals, pipes and similar means,
2) Passenger transport enterprises operating within municipal borders,
3) Slaughterhouses, limited to slaughtering, transport and storage.

Under this provision, passenger transport carried out within municipal borders by villages, the unions formed by them or entities attached to them is exempt from corporate tax, without distinguishing between land and sea transport. However, if villages, their unions or attached entities carry out passenger transport on a continuous basis to places outside municipal borders as well, the exemption conditions are breached and corporate tax liability is established for them as an economic enterprise.

On this subject, section 4.10 of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, titled "Enterprises operated by special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages, the unions formed by them or entities attached to them", states:

"...
Where transport activities are carried out beyond municipal borders (in places with a metropolitan municipality, beyond metropolitan municipal borders), the exemption cannot be used. Whether a transport activity is within municipal borders will be assessed by reference to the points of departure and arrival; if either of these points lies outside municipal borders, the exemption cannot be used.
For example, while passenger transport carried out by Kırıkkale Municipality within its municipal borders falls within the exemption, its passenger transport between Kırıkkale and Ankara cannot be treated as exempt, and corporate tax liability will be established for that passenger transport enterprise in respect of this activity.
Where the transport activity consists of carrying goods and freight, the transport enterprise will be liable to corporate tax regardless of whether municipal borders are crossed."

Furthermore, the E-Inspection Report with unique code … dated … issued by the … Revenue Office established that the vehicles will be used solely within district borders for transport to and touring of the … Ancient City by visiting tourists, that there is no other vehicle within the district for transport to the Ancient City, that the vehicles were purchased for tourism purposes under the … Agency's project, and that the rental fee has not yet been determined.

Within the framework of these provisions and explanations, an economic public establishment will arise within your Union due to the passenger transport activity to be carried out continuously and for consideration within the borders of … Municipality by means of electric service vehicles, mountain bikes and electric bicycles, and corporate tax liability must be established for this economic public establishment separately from your legal entity. However, provided that this activity does not go beyond municipal borders and this system is not used for purposes other than this activity, the economic public establishment will be exempt from corporate tax under Article 4(1)(ı) of the Corporate Tax Law.

VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:

Article 1/3-g of VAT Law No. 3065 provides that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of establishments belonging or subject to, or set up or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and the unions formed by them, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations, as well as of revolving-fund entities or other establishments belonging or subject to them, are subject to VAT, and that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial and agricultural activity and of self-employment are to be determined under the Income Tax Law.

Accordingly, since an economic enterprise attached to your Union arises due to the passenger transport activity with electric service vehicles, mountain bikes and electric bicycles within the borders of … Municipality, it will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-g of the Law. Therefore, VAT liability must be established in the name of the economic enterprise formed within your Union for these activities, and the other obligations relating to that liability must be fulfilled.

TAX PROCEDURE LAW:

Under Tax Procedure Law No. 213, taxpayers' obligations (notification, bookkeeping, documentation, etc.) are set out in Book Two of the Law, and the documents that must be issued/used under the Law are regulated in Article 229 et seq.

In addition, Article 227 of the Law, titled "Supporting documents", provides that "Unless otherwise provided in this Law, records kept under this Law relating to dealings and transactions with third parties must be supported by documents." Such records must, in principle, be supported by the documents regulated in Article 229 et seq. or those deemed appropriate under the authority granted to our Ministry.

In this context, the Law provides:

- Article 229: "An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or performing the work, showing the amount owed by the customer in return for the goods sold or the work performed."
- Article 232: first- and second-class merchants, those taxed under the simplified method and farmers required to keep books must issue invoices for goods sold or work performed to first- and second-class merchants, self-employed persons, merchants taxed under the simplified method, farmers required to keep books and tax-exempt artisans, and these must request and obtain invoices; for other buyers, an invoice must be issued where the price exceeds 50,000,000 lira (TL 4,400 for 2023) or, even if below that amount, where the buyer requests one.
- Article 233: sales and work for which first- and second-class merchants, those taxed under the simplified method and farmers required to keep books are not obliged to issue an invoice are documented by any of the following: 1. retail sales receipts; 2. cash register rolls; 3. admission and passenger tickets. ...
- Article 234: these taxpayers issue an expense voucher, signed by the seller or service provider, for work done by or goods bought from persons not required to issue documents under the Law; the expense voucher contains the required particulars and is issued in two copies; ... provided they contain the information in the second paragraph, (c) documents issued under their own legislation by public institutions not required to issue documents under this Law, for work done or goods sold, replace the expense voucher. ...

Furthermore:

- Article 13/e of the Regulation on the Printing and Distribution of Documents Used by Taxpayers under the Tax Procedure Law provides that establishments belonging or subject to, or set up or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and the unions formed by them, as well as the undertakings, organisations, institutions, establishments, subsidiaries, affiliates and enterprises defined in Article 2 of Decree-Law No. 233 on State Economic Enterprises, may have their documents printed by printers other than contracted printers, provided the documents carry the information required by the Tax Procedure Law; in that case the statement 'Not subject to the Tax Procedure Law Regulation provisions.' must be written on the document.
- Section III of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 164 states that these entities will issue the above documents under the Tax Procedure Law without being subject to the notarisation requirement, but must stamp or print on them the statement 'Not Subject to the Tax Procedure Law Regulation Provisions'.

As these explanations show, documents to be issued under the Tax Procedure Law by the taxpayers listed in Article 13/e of the Regulation need not be printed by contracted printers or notarised under the Communiqué, but must contain the mandatory minimum information. In addition, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 206 explains that enterprises using such documents under this permission which are exempt from corporate tax must add the annotation "Exempt from Corporate Tax" to their documents.

Therefore, where no economic public establishment (economic enterprise) arises within Village Service Unions in respect of their activities, there is no obligation to issue documents and fulfil other duties under the Tax Procedure Law; in that case, documents issued by the Unions under their own legislation for work done or goods sold (provided they contain the information in Article 234(2) of Law No. 213) may be used by taxpayers as supporting documents under Law No. 213. However, where corporate tax and/or VAT liability is established because an economic enterprise arises in respect of their activities, the economic enterprise must issue documents and fulfil other obligations under the Law as a first-class merchant, and the documents must be issued/used in accordance with the rules and procedures above.

Accordingly, since an economic public establishment arises within your Union and VAT liability is established due to this activity, the resulting economic enterprise is obliged to issue documents under the legislation above. In this context, the economic enterprise must issue invoices for the services provided with these vehicles, or a retail sales document where there is no obligation to issue an invoice.

LAW NO. 3100 ON THE OBLIGATION OF VAT TAXPAYERS TO USE CASH REGISTERS:

Article 1(1) of Law No. 3100 provides: "First- and second-class merchants who sell goods, as they are or after processing, to persons other than those who resell them, or who provide services to such persons, must use cash registers under this Law."

In addition, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 426 introduced an obligation for first- and second-class merchants making retail deliveries or providing services to use "New Generation Cash Registers" (instead of the cash registers required under Law No. 3100 dated 6.12.1984) to document sales and services for which they are not required to issue an invoice under the Tax Procedure Law.

Accordingly, since making the electric service vehicles, mountain bikes and electric bicycles available for a fee is not among the activities excluded from the cash register requirement in the General Communiqués published by our Ministry at various dates, there is an obligation, as of the dates specified in Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 466, to use new generation cash registers approved by our Ministry to document sales or services for which no invoice is required under the Tax Procedure Law.

Kindly be informed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.