The Turkish branch of a foreign-headquartered company sells electronic journal and book subscriptions to universities and libraries and asked about VAT withholding, whether contracts and invoices may be in foreign currency, and whether amounts may be paid into the head office's account abroad.
The Administration's view:
- Under Decision No. 32 and its Communiqué, if the contract price cannot be set in foreign currency or indexed to it, the invoice cannot be issued in foreign currency; if it can, the invoice may be issued in foreign currency showing the TL equivalent.
- Per the General Directorate of Financial Markets and Foreign Exchange, where one party is a public institution, contracts other than real estate sales and leases may be set and paid in foreign currency or indexed to it; otherwise this is not possible except for contracts exempted in the Communiqué.
- A legal opinion should be obtained to determine the type of contract.
- For contracts payable in foreign currency, no foreign exchange rule prohibits payment into the head office's account abroad.
- For subscription services to institutions listed in section I/C-2.1.3.2.13 of the Communiqué, VAT withholding at (5/10) applies where the VAT-inclusive amount exceeds TL 2,000.
The ruling is relevant to taxpayers selling foreign-currency-based services to public institutions and universities.
Full text
Subject: Whether payments for e-journal and e-book subscriptions provided by a limited taxpayer may be made in foreign currency, and whether VAT withholding applies
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, you stated that:
- since …, as the … Branch of … Company headquartered abroad (…), you have been engaged at "…" in electronic journal and book subscription activities for universities and libraries, and all expenses of your branch are covered by the head office;
- within these activities, after determining the annual electronic journal and book needs of universities and libraries, annual subscriptions are arranged by liaising with the head office abroad;
- all the products you sell are foreign products and your branch acts as an intermediary without any physical product entering Turkey;
- the products sold are obtained from the head office, and both the purchase price and the sale price are paid in full into the head office's bank account abroad;
- the sale and subscription contracts with universities and other institutions provide that payment obligations are to be set in foreign currency or indexed to foreign currency;
- since purchases and sales are made from abroad, invoices are issued in foreign currency through the GİB Portal showing the TL equivalent under the Tax Procedure Law, but some universities have doubts about VAT withholding and about setting and paying these invoice amounts in foreign currency;
and our opinion is requested, regarding these electronic journal and book subscriptions, on:
- whether VAT withholding applies to invoices issued by your branch to public universities, foundation universities and public institutions and, if so, at what rate;
- whether payment obligations for service and product prices in contracts with these institutions may be set in foreign currency or indexed to foreign currency;
- whether it is appropriate under tax laws for the invoice amounts issued by your branch to be paid into the bank accounts abroad of your head office ….
A) ASSESSMENT UNDER THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Article 215(2) of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides: "a) Turkish currency is used in records and documents. Documents may also be issued in a foreign currency, provided the Turkish currency equivalent is shown. However, the requirement to show the Turkish currency equivalent does not apply to documents issued in the name of customers abroad. ...", and Article 229 provides: "An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or performing the work, showing the amount owed by the customer in return for the goods sold or the work performed."
In addition, subparagraph (g), added to Article 4 of Decision No. 32 on the Protection of the Value of Turkish Currency by Article 1 of Decision No. 85, provides: "Except in cases determined by the Ministry, the contract price and other payment obligations arising from contracts between persons resident in Turkey for the purchase and sale of movables and immovables, all kinds of leasing of movables and immovables including vehicle and financial leasing, and work, service and construction contracts cannot be set in foreign currency or indexed to foreign currency."
The scope of this provision was determined by re-regulating the repealed Article 8, "Contracts in foreign currency and indexed to foreign currency", of Communiqué No. 2008-32/34 on Decision No. 32 (Official Gazette No. 26801 of 28/2/2008) through Communiqué No. 2018-32/51 (Official Gazette No. 30557 of 6/10/2018).
Furthermore, the reply received from our Ministry's General Directorate of Financial Markets and Foreign Exchange, whose opinion was sought, states in summary:
- Article 4(g) of Decision No. 32 prohibits contracts between residents from being set in foreign currency or indexed to it, except in cases determined by the Ministry;
- under the ninth paragraph of Article 8 of Communiqué No. 2008-32/34, as amended by Communiqué No. 2022-32/66 (Official Gazette No. 31814 of 19.04.2022), residents may set the price in movable sales contracts other than vehicle sales in foreign currency or indexed to it, but payment obligations must be performed and accepted in Turkish currency;
- under the seventh paragraph of Article 8, residents cannot set prices in service contracts, including consultancy, intermediary and transport, in foreign currency or indexed to it, except for: a) service contracts to which persons who are not Turkish citizens are party; b) service contracts within exports, transit trade, sales and deliveries deemed exports and foreign-exchange-earning services and activities; c) service contracts for activities residents will carry out abroad; ç) service contracts between residents starting in Turkey and ending abroad, starting abroad and ending in Turkey, or starting and ending abroad...;
- under the fifteenth paragraph, subject to the sixteenth paragraph, in contracts other than real estate sales and leases to which public institutions or Turkish Armed Forces Foundation companies are party, the price and other payment obligations may be set, paid and accepted in foreign currency or indexed to it;
- "public institutions" in that paragraph means the general government public administrations under Public Financial Management and Control Law No. 5018, i.e. the institutions, administrations and local administrations in Schedules I, II, III and IV of that Law, and companies at least 50% owned directly or indirectly by them;
- since giving legal opinions on the type of contract is outside the Ministry's remit, the company must first obtain a legal opinion to determine the types of contracts signed;
- where one party is a public institution, contracts other than those outside the fifteenth-paragraph exception (real estate sales and leases) may be set in foreign currency or indexed to it, and payment obligations may be paid and accepted in foreign currency or indexed to it;
- where no party is a public institution, contracts other than those exempted in the Communiqué cannot be set, paid or accepted in foreign currency or indexed to it;
- for contracts that may be paid and accepted in foreign currency or indexed to it, the foreign exchange legislation contains no provision prohibiting the invoice amounts from being paid into the head office's bank accounts abroad.
Accordingly, where under the Decision and Communiqué the contract price and other payment obligations cannot be set in foreign currency or indexed to it, invoices for the transactions under those contracts cannot be issued in foreign currency.
However, where under these rules the contract price and other payment obligations may be set in foreign currency or indexed to it, it is natural that the invoice may be issued in foreign currency, provided the Turkish currency equivalent is shown (without the Turkish currency equivalent for invoices issued to customers abroad).
B) ASSESSMENT UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
Article 9/1 of VAT Law No. 3065 provides that where the taxpayer has no residence, place of business, legal seat or business centre in Turkey, and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold the parties to taxable transactions liable for payment of the tax to secure the tax receivable.
The VAT General Implementation Communiqué sets out the nature of partial withholding and the buyers who must apply it in section I/C-2.1.3.1, the services subject to partial withholding in section I/C-2.1.3.2 and the deliveries in section I/C-2.1.3.3; and it states:
- in section I/C-2.1.3.2.13, "Other services": "For all other services not specifically determined in the Communiqué, rendered by VAT taxpayers to administrations, institutions and organisations in the schedules attached to Law No. 5018, public institutions established by law or Presidential Decree, revolving-fund entities, professional organisations with public institution status, banks, insurance, reinsurance and pension companies, pension and aid funds established by law or having legal personality, and development agencies (excluding health services provided by health service providers and invoiced to the Social Security Institution), VAT withholding at the rate of (5/10) is applied by these buyers."
- in section I/C-2.1.3.4.1, "Withholding threshold": that where the VAT-inclusive price of each transaction subject to partial withholding does not exceed TL 2,000, the VAT is not withheld, and where the threshold is exceeded, withholding applies to the full amount; that the price cannot be split to avoid withholding, and the total for the same transaction is considered; and that where the price is found to have been split across several invoices to avoid withholding, tax offices will check whether the total of purchases forming a whole exceeds the threshold and take the necessary action.
Accordingly, where the VAT-inclusive amount of an invoice issued by your Company for electronic journal and electronic book subscription services to the institutions listed in section I/C-2.1.3.2.13 of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué exceeds TL 2,000, VAT withholding at the rate of (5/10) must be applied under that section.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.