A manufacturer of cable connectors obtained a certificate for its products from a US laboratory firm. Staff of the firm's Turkish representative office come for inspections four times a year, while invoices are issued in euros by the firm's Netherlands representative. The company asked whether corporate tax withholding and VAT withholding apply to these payments.
The Administration's view:
- Since the inspection services are provided through the staff of the representative in Turkey, the US-resident firm has a permanent establishment in Turkey; the income is commercial income declared on a corporate tax return, and no withholding is made on the payments.
- Under Art. 14 of the Turkey-USA DTT, Turkey has a taxing right limited to the amount attributable to the PE; taxation follows domestic law, and a residence certificate is needed to benefit from the treaty.
- The inspection service rendered and used in Turkey is subject to VAT; as a PE exists, VAT is shown on the invoice and declared by the firm on VAT Return No. 1, and the buyer does not apply withholding.
The ruling is relevant to companies obtaining services from foreign certification and inspection bodies.
Full text
Subject: Payments for inspection of certified products by a non-resident firm
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above and your additional petition, stating that the cable connectors produced by your Company are sold both domestically and abroad, that a … certificate was given to your Company for certain products tested by the US-origin firm …, which provides laboratory services and has representative offices in many countries, that for the certified products staff working at the firm's Turkish Representative … A.Ş. are sent to your Company for inspection 4 times a year, and that the invoice for this is issued separately for each inspection in euros by the firm's Netherlands Representative …, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether corporate tax withholding and value added tax (VAT) withholding apply to payments made against invoices to the bank accounts of the relevant firm.
In Terms of the Corporate Tax Law
Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
"(1) Full liability: Entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal or business centre is in Turkey are taxed on all of their earnings obtained both in Turkey and outside Turkey.
(2) Limited liability: Entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal and business centres are both not in Turkey are taxed only on their earnings obtained in Turkey.
(3) Corporate income under limited liability consists of the following earnings and income:
a) Commercial earnings obtained by foreign entities having a place of business or permanent representative in Turkey in accordance with Tax Procedure Law No. 213 dated 4/1/1961 from works carried out in these places or through these representatives (Even if they meet these conditions, earnings arising from entities sending goods they bought in Turkey for export to foreign countries without selling them in Turkey are not deemed obtained in Turkey. Selling in Turkey means that the buyer or seller or both are in Turkey or that the sales contract is made in Turkey.)
..."
- Article 22:
"(1) In determining the earnings of limited liability entities obtained through a place of business or permanent representative, the provisions applicable to fully liable entities apply unless otherwise stated.
(2) For earnings and income of limited liability entities other than commercial or agricultural earnings, the provisions of the Income Tax Law on determining such earnings and income apply. However, if such earnings and income are obtained within commercial or agricultural activity being carried out in Turkey, corporate income is determined under the first paragraph of this article.
..."
- the fourth paragraph of Article 25: "The annual corporate tax return is filed with the tax office of the place where the entity's place of business or permanent representative in Turkey is located; if it has no place of business or permanent representative in Turkey, with the tax office to which those providing earnings to the foreign entity are attached."
- the first paragraph of Article 28: "The tax of foreign entities subject to limited liability is assessed on their behalf in the name of their managers or representatives in Turkey; if there are no managers or representatives, in the name of those providing earnings and income to the foreign entity."
The first paragraph of Article 30 of the same Law provides that corporate tax withholding is made by those paying in cash or on account, including advances, or accruing the earnings and income of limited liability entities listed in subparagraphs in that paragraph; by Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 the corporate tax withholding rate on self-employment earnings has been set at 5% for earnings from petroleum exploration activities and 20% for other self-employment earnings, and commercial earnings are not listed within withholding.
On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 6 of that Law provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period, and the second paragraph provides that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
According to these provisions and explanations, since the inspection services are provided through the staff of the representative … A.Ş. in Turkey, it must be accepted that the US-resident firm has a place of business in Turkey, and the earnings obtained must be treated as commercial income and declared on a corporate tax return.
In this context, it is natural that no withholding will be made on these payments made by your Company.
In Terms of Double Taxation Treaties
Paragraph 2 of Article 14 titled "Independent Personal Services" of the "Convention between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Government of the United States of America for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on Income (Convention)", applied from 1/1/1998, provides:
"2. Income derived by an enterprise of one of the Contracting States from the performance of professional services or other activities of a similar character shall be taxable only in that State. However, if those services or activities are performed in the other State, and if:
a) the enterprise has a permanent establishment in that other State through which the services or activities are performed; or
b) the period or periods during which the services or activities are performed exceed in the aggregate 183 days in any continuous 12-month period,
such income may also be taxed in that other Contracting State.
In such case, as the case may be, either only so much of the income as is attributable to the permanent establishment or only so much of the income as is attributable to services or activities performed in that other State may be taxed in that other State. In either case the Republic of Turkey may impose tax on such income by way of withholding. However, the beneficiary of such income may, after being subject to such tax, elect to be taxed on a net basis in respect of such income under the provisions of Article 7 of the Convention as if the income were attributable to a permanent establishment in that other State."
In this context, payments made by your firm to the US-resident firm in return for inspection services relating to certified products must be evaluated under Article 14 titled "Independent Personal Services" of the Convention.
Where the US-resident firm performs these services through a permanent establishment in Turkey, or the period or periods during which these services are performed in Turkey exceed 183 days in any continuous 12-month period, the income from these services may also be taxed in Turkey.
Article 5 titled "Permanent Establishment" of the Convention, whose text is annexed, defines permanent establishment and explains in which cases a permanent establishment arises in the other State.
Accordingly, since your petition containing additional explanations states that the inspection services are provided by the staff of … A.Ş., the Turkish representative office of the US-resident firm, that representative office must be treated as the US-resident firm's permanent establishment in Turkey. In this context, as also stated in the ruling request form, Turkey also has a taxing right over payments made to the US-resident firm in return for inspection services performed in Turkey, limited to the amount attributable to the permanent establishment in Turkey. Taxation will be carried out under domestic law provisions.
On the other hand, detailed explanations on the taxation of income obtained by resident individuals or entities of other contracting countries from independent personal services or other activities of a similar character performed in Turkey under the double taxation treaties concluded by our country are given in Double Taxation Treaties General Communiqué Serial No. 4 published in Official Gazette No. 30192 dated 26/9/2017.
Any double taxation that may arise in this case will be avoided under the provisions of Article 23 titled "Relief from Double Taxation" of the Convention.
For earnings or income obtained in Turkey by residents of other contracting countries to be taxed under the relevant double taxation treaty, they must obtain a residence certificate from the competent authorities of their country of residence and submit the original and a copy of its Turkish translation certified by a notary or the Turkish consulates in that country to the relevant tax office or tax withholders, as the case may be. If the residence certificate cannot be submitted, domestic law provisions will be applied instead of the relevant treaty provisions.
In Terms of the Value Added Tax Law
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 6, that a transaction being performed in Turkey means the service being performed in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey,
- in Article 9/1, that where the taxpayer has no domicile, place of business, legal seat or business centre in Turkey and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold those who are parties to taxable transactions liable for payment of the tax in order to secure the tax receivable.
Accordingly, the inspection services provided to your Company in Turkey and benefited from in Turkey at certain intervals by employees of … A.Ş., the Turkish Representative of firm …, for your Company's … certified products are subject to VAT under Article 1/1 of Law No. 3065.
In this context, since firm … has a place of business in Turkey due to these activities, the VAT calculated on the fee for the inspection service provided to your Company must be shown on the related invoice and declared and paid by that firm on VAT Return No. 1, and your Company will not apply VAT withholding to this transaction.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.