TREN
Contact us

For a Contract on Which Maximum Stamp Duty Was Paid, No New Stamp Duty Is Sought if Only the Price Rises Through Price Differences Without More Work

Stamp Duty · ContractsFor a Contract on Which Maximum Stamp Duty Was Paid, No New Stamp Duty Is Sought if Only the Price Rises Through Price Differences Without More WorkPrivate ruling · 24 September 2024
Rast note

A company that undertook a stripping construction work tendered by a public body and paid contract stamp duty at the maximum amount asked whether contract stamp duty will be sought again due to price differences in progress payments.

The Administration's view:

  • Under Article 14/2 of the Stamp Duty Law, for contracts taxed at the maximum amount, no new stamp duty is collected on the increased price if only the price increases without changes to other provisions; if elements such as additional work and quantity also change, tax is collected separately on the increase.
  • Provided it is documented by a letter from the contracting authority that the contract was taxed at the maximum amount (TRY 10,732,371.80 for 2023) and that the work quantity did not increase, contract stamp duty is not sought on amendment documents drawn up only for unit price increases.

The ruling is relevant to contractors receiving price differences under large public contracts.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Stamp duty on documents amending a contract on which stamp duty was paid at the maximum amount
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that the "… Stripping Construction Work" with tender registration number …/… tendered by … General Directorate was awarded to your company and that the stamp duty on the contract signed with the contracting authority for that work was paid at the maximum amount, an opinion is requested on whether contract stamp duty will be sought due to price differences during progress payments nos. 5 and 6 made to your company by the contracting authority.

Article 1 of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides that the documents listed in Table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty, and that the term documents in this Law means documents drawn up by being written and signed or by placing a mark replacing a signature that can be submitted to prove or indicate any matter, and documents created in magnetic media and as electronic data using an electronic signature; Article 2 provides that letters and annotations in the nature of or replacing taxable documents, and letters and annotations relating to the renewal, extension, amendment, transfer or termination of the provisions of these documents, are also subject to stamp duty; Article 3 provides that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents; Article 4 provides that the nature of a document is examined to determine the tax to which it is subject and the tax in the table is found accordingly, that in determining the nature of documents, for those whose form is specified in laws their names in the laws, and for others the provision and meaning contained in the text on them, are considered, and that if reference is made to another document, tax is collected according to the nature it acquires based on the provisions of the referenced document; the second paragraph of Article 6 provides that where contracts and transactions gathered in one document are interconnected and arise from one principal, stamp duty is collected on the contract or transaction requiring the highest tax; the first paragraph of Article 14 provides that stamp duty on documents is collected at the rates or amounts in Table (1) annexed to this Law, but that the tax amount to be calculated for each document cannot exceed 800 thousand Turkish lira (TRY 10,732,371.80 for 2023 under Stamp Duty Law General Communiqué Serial No. 68), subject to the limitations in Table (1); and the second paragraph provides that where contracts containing a certain amount of money are amended, the increased amount is subject to tax at the same rate, and that this provision does not apply to the increased price where contracts taxed at the maximum amount under the first paragraph only increase in price without change to their other provisions.

Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I - Documents related to contracts" of Table (1) annexed to that Law provides that contracts, undertakings and assignments containing a certain amount of money are subject to proportional stamp duty.

On the other hand, Article 5 titled "Application of collecting tax at the maximum amount" of Stamp Duty Law General Communiqué Serial No. 60, published in Official Gazette No. 29842 dated 29/9/2016 and entering into force, states:

"(1) By Article 25 of Law No. 6728, the sentence "This provision does not apply to the increased price where contracts taxed at the maximum amount under the first paragraph only increase in price without change to their other provisions." was added after the first sentence of the second paragraph of Article 14 of Law No. 488, and that paragraph reads as follows.
"Where contracts containing a certain amount of money are amended, the increased amount is subject to tax at the same rate. This provision does not apply to the increased price where contracts taxed at the maximum amount under the first paragraph only increase in price without change to their other provisions. In case of their transfer, one quarter of the tax collected on the original is collected."
(2) Accordingly, from 9/8/2016, the effective date of that provision, where a new document is drawn up relating to contracts taxed at the maximum amount only to increase the price without change to the other provisions of the contract, no stamp duty will be collected again on this amendment document due to the increased price.
(3) On the other hand, where elements of contracts other than price, such as additional work and quantity, are also changed, stamp duty will be collected separately on the increased amount relating to the amendment."

In this respect, where a new document drawn up only to increase the price, without change to the other provisions, of a document previously subjected to stamp duty at the maximum amount is drawn up from the effective date of Article 25 of Law No. 6728, no stamp duty will be collected again on this amendment document due to the increased price.

Accordingly, provided it is documented by a letter to be obtained from the contracting authority that the contract for TRY … relating to the "… Stripping Construction Work", understood to have been drawn up between … General Directorate and your company on …, was taxed at the maximum amount (TRY 10,732,371.80 for 2023) and that there is no increase in the work quantity specified in the contract, contract stamp duty must not be sought on documents drawn up for contract amendments solely for increases in unit prices.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.