A company transferred two properties to a bank against its bank loan debt under a financial restructuring agreement; one produced a profit and the other a loss. The profitable property had earlier been subject to a sale-and-leaseback under Corporate Tax Law Article 5/1-j, and the resulting sale profit was held in a special fund on the liabilities side and adjusted for inflation. The company asked whether the two transfers are one transaction or separate, whether the loss is non-deductible or an expense, and how the special fund and its inflation differences are treated on transfer.
The Administration's view:
- Each of the two transfers made under the Article 5/1-f conditions is a separate sale.
- For the property sold at a profit, the full profit attributable to the part of the proceeds used to settle debt is exempt. For the property sold at a loss, the loss attributable to that part cannot be deducted from corporate profit and is treated as non-deductible.
- The Article 5/1-j special fund is subject to inflation adjustment. If the fund's adjustment differences are written off against the asset's depreciation, they do not count as withdrawal; but if they are closed through the sale of the property, they count as withdrawal and are taxed in that period, independently of period profit.
The ruling is relevant to companies transferring assets against bank debt.
Full text
Subject: Exemption and minimum corporate tax treatment of transferring company properties to a bank against debt
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: …
From the examination of the ruling request forms referred to above, it is understood that, stating that two properties in your company's assets were transferred to the creditor bank against bank loan debt under a Financial Restructuring Agreement, invoiced at separate prices; that 91.20% of the sale proceeds from this transfer was offset against your company's loan debts to the bank and the remaining 8.80% was used by the bank to pay public debts; that one of the two property transfers produced a sale loss and the other a sale profit; that the property sold at a profit had, in periods before these transactions, been subject to a sale-lease-buyback under Article 5/1-j of the Corporate Tax Law and the property was bought back at the end of the contract term; that the sale profit arising on the first sale in this transaction was taken to a special fund account on the liabilities side; that this fund was used only to write off depreciation set aside for that asset; and that it was adjusted for inflation in the 2023 and 2024 accounting periods, an opinion is requested on:
- whether, on the transfer of the properties to the bank, the special fund account on the liabilities side and the related inflation differences must be removed from the balance sheet and taken into account in calculating the sale profit; whether these inflation differences count as withdrawal from the business; and whether they are taxed independently of period profit,
- whether the transfer of the two properties to the bank under a single financial restructuring agreement is to be treated, for the exemption, as a single transaction or as two separate sales,
- since these transactions produced a profit on one property and a loss on the other, and a loss overall, whether the resulting loss is to be taken into account as a non-deductible expense (KKEG) or as an expense.
CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 5 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, headed "Exemptions", provides:
"1) The following profits are exempt from corporate tax:
...
f) the whole of the profits attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from transferring to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, against these debts, immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors; and 50% of the profits from the sale of immovables (including immovables subject to financial leasing whose every right of disposal the lessor has taken over by mutual agreement of the parties against financial leasing receivables under legal proceedings due to the lessee's default in financial leasing transactions under Law No. 6361), and 75% of the profits from the sale of the others, of such assets acquired in this way by banks, financial leasing or financing companies,
...
3) (Paragraph amended by Article 20 of Law No. 7440; in force 13.03.2023, applying to income and profits earned from 1/1/2023) Deduction from non-exempt corporate profit of expenses relating to entities' exempt profits or of losses from exempt activities is not accepted. However, financing expenses relating to the purchase of participation shares, including those relating to the period after transfer transactions under Article 19 of the Law, may be deducted from corporate profit."
Section "5.7.1. Exemption for entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the TMSF, and for their guarantors and mortgagors" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"By Article 5(1)(f) of the Corporate Tax Law, the whole of the profits attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from transferring to banks or to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, against these debts, immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks or indebted to the Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors, has been exempted from corporate tax.
Entities using this exemption must have been subject to legal proceedings under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 due to their debts to banks or be indebted to the TMSF.
The exemption may be used by entities subject to legal proceedings due to bank debts or indebted to the TMSF, and by their guarantors liable to corporate tax or corporate taxpayers giving mortgages on behalf of these entities.
The assets subject to the exemption are immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights.
On the other hand, the profit that may benefit from the exemption is limited to the amount attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from the sale or other transfer of those assets to banks or the TMSF against the debts.
...
In applying the exemption, there is no requirement that entities indebted to banks or the TMSF, and their guarantors and mortgagors, hold the assets transferred to banks or the Fund against these debts for at least two years, nor is there a requirement to hold the profit in a special fund account for a certain period.
The exemptions in Article 5(1)(e) and (f) of the Law cannot be used together. Entities may freely choose, provided they meet the conditions of the exemption provisions.
..."
Furthermore, Article 5(1)(j) of the same Law, headed "Exemptions", provides that profits from the sale by entities of all kinds of movable and immovable property to financial leasing companies, participation banks and development and investment banks for the purpose of leaseback under Law No. 6361 and on condition of buyback at the end of the contract, and profits from the transfer of these assets by these institutions to the entity from which they were acquired at the end of the lease term, are exempt from corporate tax; that the exempt sale profit is held by the lessee in a special fund account on the liabilities side; that this amount held in the special fund account is used only by the lessee to write off the depreciation to be set aside for these assets (excluding depreciation corresponding to the net balance sheet asset value at the lessee before these assets were transferred to the leasing institutions); and that taxes not accrued in time due to the exemption applied are deemed lost for the part of the exempt profit transferred in any way to another account, withdrawn from the business or transferred by limited liable entities to their head office.
Furthermore, section "5.15.3.3. Not withdrawing the profit held in the fund account from the business" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"The profit amount taken to the fund account may be used by the lessee only to write off the depreciation to be set aside for these assets both during the lease term and after the assets are bought back at the end of the lease term (excluding depreciation corresponding to the net balance sheet asset value at the lessee before these assets were transferred to the leasing institutions). However, where the profit amount taken to the fund account is otherwise transferred to another account, withdrawn from the business or transferred by limited liable entities to their head office, or the entity is liquidated (excluding transfers and divisions under this Law), taxes not accrued in time due to the exemption will be collected together with tax loss penalty and late payment interest.
..."
and section "5.15.4. Application of the exemption" states: "... The sale profit subject to the exemption will be held by the lessee in a special fund account on the liabilities side, and this amount held in the special fund account may be used only by the lessee to write off the depreciation to be set aside for these assets (excluding depreciation corresponding to the net balance sheet asset value at the lessee before these assets were transferred to the leasing institutions). ..."
Each of the transfers of the two properties in your company's assets to the bank against bank loan debts, under the conditions in Article 5/1-f of the Corporate Tax Law, must be treated as a separate sale.
Accordingly:
- the whole of the profit attributable to the part of the sale proceeds of the property sold at a profit used to settle the debts is exempt from corporate tax,
- the loss attributable to the part of the sale proceeds of the property sold at a loss used to settle the debts cannot be deducted from corporate profit. Therefore, the non-deductible loss arising under that article must be taken into account as a non-deductible expense (KKEG).
TAX PROCEDURE LAW
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298:
"A) Non-monetary items in financial statements are adjusted for inflation under the following provisions.
1. Income and corporate taxpayers determining their profits on the balance sheet basis adjust their financial statements for inflation where the increase in the price index exceeds 100% in the last three accounting periods including the current one and 10% in the current accounting period. Inflation adjustment ends where both conditions are not met together.
...
2. In applying this article:
a) Non-monetary items means items other than monetary items,
b) Monetary items means items whose nominal values remain the same against changes in the value of the Turkish lira but whose purchasing power changes inversely with price movements (foreign currencies are also treated as monetary items).
...
5. ...
Inflation difference accounts of liability items are taxed in the period in which they are transferred to another account in any way or withdrawn from the business, without being linked to the profit of the periods in which these transactions are made. However, inflation differences on equity items may be offset against prior-year losses arising from the adjustment or added to capital by corporate taxpayers; these transactions are not deemed profit distribution.
Where values adjusted for inflation are disposed of, the related inflation adjustment differences are deemed cost.
..."
- in Provisional Article 33: "... Financial statements dated 31/12/2023 are adjusted for inflation regardless of whether the inflation adjustment conditions are met. The profit/loss difference arising from the inflation adjustment is shown in the prior years' profit/loss account. Prior-year profit determined in this way is not taxed, and prior-year loss is not accepted as a loss. ..."
Furthermore, explanations/provisions on the financial statements to be adjusted for inflation for the 2023 accounting period and, depending on the adjustment conditions being met, subsequent accounting periods (including provisional tax periods), and on the procedures and principles for inflation adjustment under paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298 and Provisional Article 33 of Law No. 213, have been made in Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Nos. 555, 560, 563 and 582, and additional explanations and example applications have been given in Tax Procedure Law Circulars Nos. 165, 170, 175, 176, 181, 187, 191 and 192; in this context, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 555 states:
- in Article 9:
"(1) Considering the relationship between purchasing power and changes in the value of the national currency, items in financial statements are divided into two groups:
a) Monetary Items: items whose nominal values remain the same against changes in the value of the national currency but whose purchasing power changes inversely with price movements.
b) Non-Monetary Items: items other than monetary items, in other words items whose purchasing power does not change despite changes in the value of the national currency.
...
Monetary items (monetary assets and monetary sources) are not adjusted for inflation, since the value of a monetary item in the balance sheet also shows its purchasing power at the balance sheet date. However, since the values of non-monetary items (non-monetary assets and non-monetary sources) in the balance sheet do not show their purchasing power at the balance sheet date, non-monetary items are adjusted for inflation to remove the effects of inflation from the balance sheet.
(2) Monetary and non-monetary items among items included in economic enterprises by type are in the lists annexed to this Communiqué (ANNEX 1 and ANNEX 2). Although equity items are not included in those lists, equity items are deemed "non-monetary items" in applying this Communiqué, unless otherwise provided and provided no determination is made in the Communiqué."
- in Article 15(1):
"(1) Capital increases arising from adding to capital funds such as revaluation surplus funds set aside before 1/1/2024 and added to capital will not be taken into account as increases when adjusting the balance sheet dated 31/12/2023 and will not be adjusted for inflation.
In addition, whether certain funds in the equity group of the balance sheet are adjusted for inflation will be determined according to whether the economic assets giving rise to these funds are monetary or non-monetary items.
In this framework, capital increases arising from adding to capital funds of a monetary nature will also not be taken into account as increases when adjusting the balance sheet dated 31/12/2023 and will not be adjusted for inflation."
- in Article 16(1): "(1) Among equity items; ... g) Special Funds (such as the fixed asset renewal fund created under Articles 328 and 329 of Law No. 213 and the venture capital fund set aside under Article 325/A of the same Law; funds created under paragraphs 5/1-e, j and k of Law No. 5520; provision accounts created under Laws Nos. 6111, 6736, 7143, 7326 and 7440 for recording goods existing in the business but not in the records; and fund accounts created under Additional Article 3 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 dated 26/6/2001 and Article 3 of Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities dated 28/2/2008) appear in the balance sheet at their adjusted values. ...",
- in Article 24(1): "... When adjusting the balance sheet at the end of the 2023 accounting period, funds such as the revaluation surplus fund among capital reserves will be reset to zero; share premiums, share cancellation profits, profit reserves and special funds (funds accepted as non-monetary items, such as the fixed asset renewal fund) will be adjusted. ...",
- in Article 31: "(1) On the authority given by paragraph (A)(8) of Repeated Article 298 of Law No. 213, the procedures and principles of inflation adjustment for the 2024 accounting period (for those assigned a special accounting period, the accounting period ending in 2025), including provisional tax periods, depending on the conditions being met, and for subsequent periods (provisional tax periods and accounting periods) depending on the conditions continuing, are determined in this section of the Communiqué.",
- in Article 54(1): "(1) Inflation difference accounts of liability items will be taxed in the period in which they are transferred to another account in any way or withdrawn from the business, without being linked to the profit of the periods in which these transactions are made. However, where accounts that by their operation can be closed by transfer to the accounts to which they relate, such as advances, deposits, progress payments and the fixed asset renewal fund, are closed, their inflation difference accounts are not deemed withdrawn from the business. ..."
Accordingly, whether special funds are adjusted for inflation is determined according to whether the economic assets giving rise to them are monetary or non-monetary items, and the fund account created on the liabilities side of the balance sheet under Article 5(1/j) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 must, as also stated in Article 16(1) of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 555, be adjusted for inflation and appear in the balance sheet at its adjusted value.
In this vein, where the adjustment differences arising from adjusting for inflation the special fund account on the liabilities side under Article 5(1/j) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, relating to your property transferred to the bank by sale-lease-buyback and later re-entering your assets at the end of the lease term, are written off against the depreciation to be set aside for that asset, the differences arising from the adjustment will not be deemed withdrawn from the business.
However, where the adjustment differences arising from adjusting that special fund account on the liabilities side for inflation are closed by the property being sold, those differences will be deemed withdrawn from the business and will be taxed in that period, without being linked to the profit of the periods in which these transactions are made.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.