TREN
Contact us

A Simplified-Method Taxi Operator Building a Workplace in a Metropolitan Area Must Move to the Actual Method: Income Tax, VAT and Tax Procedure Obligations

Personal Income Tax · Tax residencyA Simplified-Method Taxi Operator Building a Workplace in a Metropolitan Area Must Move to the Actual Method: Income Tax, VAT and Tax Procedure ObligationsPrivate ruling · 7 August 2024
Rast note

A person taxed under the simplified method for taxi operation will build an additional workplace with an additional building permit on a workplace he bought, and asked whether he can stay in the simplified method, how sales of the new and existing workplaces are taxed, whether he can deduct VAT on the construction, and what his tax procedure obligations are.

The Administration's view:

  • Workplace construction is commercial activity regardless of personal need. Since construction activity in metropolitan areas within Council of Ministers Decision No. 95/6430 is subject to the actual method, actual-method taxation is required from the start of construction; the gain on selling the workplace built is commercial income. If construction is abandoned, return to the simplified method is possible if the conditions are met.
  • If the workplace bought already built is not recorded in the business assets, gain above the exemption on sale within five years is declared as capital gain and no VAT is calculated; if recorded, the gain is commercial income, the repeated Art. 80 exemption does not apply and VAT is calculated on the sale.
  • VAT registration is established; VAT on construction purchases is deductible and VAT is calculated on the sale of the workplace.
  • Books are kept on a business account basis (optionally balance sheet) until the end of the period of moving to the actual method; changes are notified within a month; documents are printed by contracted printers or notarised, and unused documents from the chamber are cancelled. The taxi and workplace are included in inventory net of depreciation under Provisional Art. 5, and the workplace built is capitalised at cost.

The ruling is relevant to tradespeople moving from the simplified to the actual method and building workplaces.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Taxation of additional private construction activity by a simplified-method taxpayer
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you have been a simplified-method commercial income taxpayer since 13/2/2017 due to your taxi passenger transport activity (excluding shared taxis), that you obtained a temporary contractor certificate to build an additional workplace, within the limits permitted by the floor area ratio in the zoning plan, by obtaining an additional building permit for the workplace you bought on 26/11/2020, and that you will start the construction work after your building permit is approved by the authorities competent to issue permits, you request an opinion on:

- whether your income will continue to be determined under the simplified method due to this workplace construction work,

- whether you can return to the simplified method if actual-method commercial income liability is established in your name,

- how you will be taxed if the workplace is sold after the completion date of the additional workplace construction work you will carry out,

- whether the value added tax (VAT) amounts you paid on services and materials obtained in the construction works can be offset against the taxes arising on the sale of the workplace,

- how you should be taxed if you sell the workplace completed on 26/4/2010 that you bought already built,

- whether there is any exemption because the property is located in an area designated as an industrial zone in the zoning plan,

and our Presidency's opinion is given below.

1- In Terms of the Income Tax Law

The first paragraph of Article 37 of Income Tax Law No. 193 states that earnings arising from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are commercial income, and subparagraph (4) of the second paragraph of that article provides that earnings obtained by those continuously engaged in buying, selling and constructing real estate from these activities are commercial income, and that commercial income is determined according to the Tax Procedure Law and the actual (balance sheet or business account basis) or simplified methods in this Law.

Article 46 of the same Law provides:

"The commercial income of those who meet all of the conditions in Articles 47 and 48 is determined under the simplified method.
...
Those who lose any of the conditions for the simplified method during the calendar year are taxed under the actual method from the beginning of the following calendar year. Those meeting the conditions of the simplified method who notify in writing that they do not wish to benefit from this method are taxed under the actual method from the date stated in their petition or from the beginning of the following calendar year, and those newly starting business from the start date. Actual-method taxpayers who meet the conditions in Article 47 and whose business volume for two consecutive accounting periods is below the limits in Article 48 may switch to the simplified method upon written request starting from the calendar year following fulfilment of this condition. In case of transfer of the business to the spouse and children, periods before the transfer are also taken into account in calculating business volume. The income of those found to have issued fake documents or documents misleading in content is in no case determined under the simplified method.
..."

Detailed explanations on switching from actual-method taxation to the simplified method are given in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 283 and Income Tax Circular No. 93 dated 18/12/2013.

Article 51 of that Law sets the limits of the simplified method, and by Council of Ministers Decision No. 95/6430 dated 12/01/1995 issued under the authority of that article, taxpayers engaged in all kinds of construction-related work within the boundaries of metropolitan municipalities, including adjacent area boundaries, in provinces with metropolitan municipalities (excluding Erzurum, Diyarbakır, Sakarya and places included within metropolitan municipality boundaries by Metropolitan Municipality Law No. 5216 whose population including newly attached neighbourhoods was less than 30,000 in the 2000 general census, and places where metropolitan municipalities were established and included within metropolitan municipality boundaries under Law No. 6360 dated 12/11/2012 on the Establishment of Metropolitan Municipalities in Fourteen Provinces and Twenty-Seven Districts and Amendment of Certain Laws and Decree Laws) have been brought within actual-method taxation from 01.01.1995.

On the other hand, repeated Article 80 titled "Capital Gains" of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

"Gains arising from the disposal of the following goods and rights are capital gains.
...
6. Gains arising from the disposal, within five years from the acquisition date, of goods (including real estate used in agricultural production by farmers taxed under the actual method) and rights listed in subparagraphs (1), (2), (4) and (7) of the first paragraph of Article 70, regardless of the manner of acquisition (excluding those acquired without consideration) (Real estate allocated by cooperatives to their members in that capacity is deemed bought by the member on the allocation date.).
The term "disposal" in this article means the sale, transfer and assignment for consideration, exchange, barter, expropriation, nationalisation or contribution as capital to commercial companies of the above goods and rights.
All gains from the disposal of commercial plates of taxis, shared taxis, minibuses and public service vehicles, and 6,000 (TL 87,000 for 2024) New Turkish Lira of capital gains obtained in a calendar year, excluding those from the disposal of securities and other capital market instruments, are exempt from income tax.
Gains arising from the partial or total sale of a commercial business continuing its activity or from the disposal of depreciable economic assets included in the commercial business and rights listed in the first paragraph are deemed commercial income and the provisions on commercial income apply to them."

In addition, repeated Article 81 titled "Net capital gain" of the same Law provides:

"In capital gains, the net gain is found by deducting from the amount of money and in-kind payments received and all kinds of benefits that can be represented in money obtained in return for the disposal, the cost of the goods and rights disposed of and the expenses incurred due to the disposal and borne by the seller, and the taxes and fees paid. The amount of the portion of the proceeds obtained in kind and as benefits is determined according to the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law.
...
In the disposal of goods and rights, the acquisition cost is determined by increasing it at the rate of increase in the wholesale price index determined by the State Institute of Statistics, excluding the month of disposal. However, for this indexation to be made, the rate of increase must be 10% or more."

On the other hand, commercial activity is based on a kind of labour-capital organisation, and whether or not there is an intention to earn profit does not affect the commercial nature of the activity carried out by such an organisation. However, although an intention to earn profit is not required for an activity to be deemed commercial, it emerges that the organisation carrying out the activity must have profit-earning potential when evaluated together with all its elements.

In the organisation called private construction, the activities of the person undertaking this organisation within the organisation consist of all kinds of work relating to the construction and the organisation (procuring workers and craftsmen, buying materials, all kinds of payments and collections, etc.).

In private construction, the real estate exceeding the scope and limits of personal need and the clear presence of the formal and material elements of a commercial organisation are sufficient for the activity to be deemed commercial. In this application, whether or not the workplace built is built for sale or is sold is of no importance, since it is clear that workplace construction is a commercial organisation carried out to earn income.

Accordingly, housing constructions not exceeding the scope and limits of personal need are not treated as commercial activity, while workplace construction and housing constructions exceeding the scope and limits of personal need are treated as commercial activity in all cases.

Within the above provisions and explanations, since you carry on the workplace construction activity, which you started while being a long-standing simplified-method commercial income taxpayer, in Eskişehir province, which is within Council of Ministers Decision No. 95/6430, you will be subject to income tax under the actual method, so it is not possible for you to benefit from the simplified method; you must be taxed under the actual method from the date you started the construction work, and the gain to arise from the sale of the workplace built by you must be included in commercial income and taxed. However, it is natural that if you abandon the workplace construction work, you can switch from the actual method to the simplified method if you meet the conditions within the explanations in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 283 and Income Tax Circular No. 93 dated 18/12/2013.

On the other hand, if the workplace you bought already built has not been recorded in your assets, and the amount remaining after deducting from the proceeds obtained from selling that workplace within less than five years the cost of the workplace disposed of, the expenses incurred due to the disposal and borne by you, and the taxes and fees paid exceeds the exemption amount set for the year of sale, the excess must be declared as capital gain.

However, since you are a commercial income taxpayer, if the workplace you bought has been recorded in your assets, the gain obtained from the sale of this workplace must be taxed by including it in the annual income tax return within the commercial income provisions in Article 37 of the Income Tax Law, and it is not possible to apply the exemption in repeated Article 80 of the same Law to that gain.

2- In Terms of the Value Added Tax (VAT) Law

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT, and that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are determined according to the provisions of the Income Tax Law and, where the Income Tax Law is not clear, the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation,

- in Article 29/1-a, that, unless otherwise provided in this Law, taxpayers may deduct from the VAT calculated on their taxable transactions the VAT shown in invoices and similar documents issued for deliveries and services made to them relating to their activities.

Accordingly, since the additional workplace construction you will carry out on your own land while being a taxpayer whose income is determined under the simplified method is treated as commercial activity, your VAT registration must be established, and it is possible for you to deduct the VAT you paid on purchases of goods and services for that additional workplace construction. If that workplace is sold by you, VAT must be calculated on the sale price under Article 1/1 of Law No. 3065.

On the other hand, if the workplace you bought already built is recorded in your assets and sold, VAT must be calculated on this sale under Article 1/1 of Law No. 3065, and it is natural that if that workplace is sold without being recorded in your assets, the gain obtained will be treated as "capital gain" and no VAT will be calculated on this sale.

3- In Terms of the Tax Procedure Law

(1) Article 176 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides that merchants are divided into two classes for bookkeeping, first-class merchants keeping books on a balance sheet basis and second-class merchants on a business account basis.

The same Law provides:

- in Article 177: "The following merchants are in the first class:
1. Those who sell goods they buy as they are or after processing and whose annual purchases exceed 7,200,000,000 (TL 1,400,000 from 1.1.2024) or sales exceed 8,640,000,000 lira (TL 2,000,000 from 1.1.2024);
2. Those engaged in work other than that in the first subparagraph whose gross business revenue in a year exceeds 3,600,000,000 lira (TL 690,000 from 1.1.2024);
3. Where the work in subparagraphs 1 and 2 is carried out together, those for whom five times the business revenue in subparagraph 2 plus the annual sales amount exceeds 7,200,000,000 lira (TL 1,400,000 from 1.1.2024);
...
6. Those who optionally choose to keep books on a balance sheet basis.",
- in Article 178: "The following merchants are in the second class:
1. Those other than those listed in Article 177;
2. Corporate taxpayers permitted by the Ministry of Finance to keep books on a business account basis.
Newly starting merchants may act as second-class merchants until classified according to their annual business volume."

In addition, Article 179 of that Law sets the conditions for moving from the first class to the second class, and Article 180 for moving from the second class to the first class; under Article 180, second-class merchants whose situation meets the conditions in that article move to the first class starting from the accounting period following the realisation of these conditions. Article 181 of the Law also provides that second-class merchants may keep books on a balance sheet basis if they wish, and the provisions of Article 180 apply to those thereby included in the first class.

Accordingly, in the concrete case, if actual-method taxation (being subject to income tax) begins from the date the construction work started due to the workplace construction activity started while being a long-standing simplified-method commercial income taxpayer for the commercial taxi operation, books must be kept on a business account basis until the end of the accounting period in which actual-method taxation begins, and it is also possible to optionally keep books on a balance sheet basis instead in that period. In subsequent accounting periods, it is natural that the conditions in Articles 179 and 180 of that Law must be met to return to the business account basis after moving to the balance sheet basis or to move from the business account basis to the balance sheet basis.

In addition, under Article 158 of the same Law, those who are already taxpayers must notify the tax office of changes in their existing situation (in relation to their business) (becoming subject to a new tax, changes in form of liability and moving to exemption); under Article 159, increases and decreases in their workplaces; and under Article 166, buildings they newly have built in cities and towns and parts used before construction is completed; and in this context the notification obligation must be fulfilled by taxpayers within one month from the date of the event to be notified.

(2) Article 227 of that Law provides:

"Unless otherwise provided in this law, it is mandatory to document records kept under this law relating to relationships and transactions with third parties.
Taxpayers not obliged to keep books are obliged to document their expenses relating to the determination of their tax base. (Excluding expenses determined on a lump-sum basis.)
If documents used under this Law or made mandatory under the authority granted by this Law to the Ministry of Finance and Customs, including those required to be issued as electronic documents, do not contain the required information, these documents are deemed not issued at all for tax law purposes."

and provisions on the documents to be issued by taxpayers for deliveries of goods and supplies of services according to their tax status are given in Articles 229 to repeated 242 of the same Law.

In addition, the form, conditions, procedures and principles for printing and distributing documents required to be issued under Law No. 213, and the penalties to be applied in case of non-compliance, are regulated by the Regulation on Printing and Distribution of Documents Used by Taxpayers Under the Tax Procedure Law.

Therefore, taxpayers can use documents they may issue on paper under the Tax Procedure Law and related secondary legislation by having them printed under that Regulation or by having documents obtained from places other than contracted printing houses certified by notaries as provided in the relevant General Communiqués, and for taxpayers using documents not printed by contracted printing houses or certified by a notary, penal action is taken under the relevant provisions of the Tax Procedure Law by accepting that these documents were not issued at all.

On the other hand:

- the section titled "3.2. Obtaining Documents" of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 215 states that simplified-method taxpayers will obtain the documents and envelopes they will use from the chambers or unions to which they are attached; that, under the authority granted to our Ministry by repeated Article 257 of the Tax Procedure Law, it was deemed appropriate for the printing, distribution, monitoring and record-keeping of documents and envelopes to be carried out by the relevant professional organisations; that professional organisations will show in their records by taxpayer to whom they gave which documents and which documents were returned to them; that taxpayers need no permission from tax offices to print documents; that documents to be printed will bear the minimum information in the Tax Procedure Law and related legislation and the special mark (emblem); and that the relevant professional organisations having documents printed will have their name, address or information on the printing house printed as a footnote at the bottom of the documents,

- Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 230 states that simplified-method taxpayers who abandon their business will submit unused documents in their possession to the chambers or union from which they received them; that these documents will be cancelled by the relevant chambers or unions as specified in the Communiqué; that the situation of taxpayers abandoning their business who do not submit these documents, submit them incompletely or report losing them will be established by a record; that a copy of the record will be sent to the relevant tax office; and that tax offices will apply to these taxpayers the provisions applicable to second-class taxpayers.

Accordingly, a taxpayer moving from the simplified method to the actual method must use the documents to be used under Tax Procedure Law No. 213 (invoices, retail sales documents and other documents) by having them printed at contracted printing houses under that Regulation or certified by notaries, and must have the documents obtained from the professional chamber to which it was attached during its simplified-method liability and held unused cancelled by submitting them to the chamber that issued them.

(3) Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:

- in Article 187: "In sole proprietorships, the following principles apply to buildings and land owned by the taxpayer:
1. Factories, warehouses, workshops, shops, stores and land, whether used partly or entirely in the business, are included in the inventory at their full value.
2. Buildings usable room by room or part by part such as commercial buildings, and houses and apartments, are included in the inventory if more than half is used in the business.
3. Later changes in the manner of use of real estate included in the inventory are not taken into account within the accounting year.",
- in Article 262: "Cost means the total of payments made in connection with acquiring an economic asset or increasing its value and all related expenses.
The following expenses are also included in cost:
a) customs duties, customs commissions, loading, unloading, transport and installation expenses directly related to acquiring the economic asset or increasing its value,
b) duties and fees, notary, land registry, court, valuation, consultancy, commission and advertising expenses directly related to acquiring the economic asset or increasing its value,
c) the portion of interest expenses on loans used to finance the economic asset and related exchange differences up to the date the goods enter inventory for goods, and up to the end of the accounting period in which the asset is included in inventory for other assets, and expenses relating to such loans (taxpayers are free to include other portions of interest expenses and exchange differences in cost or show them among general expenses),
ç) storage and insurance expenses up to the date the economic asset is included in stock or inventory,
d) for real estate, expenses arising from buying and demolishing an existing building and levelling its land.
Provided they are directly related to real estate, grants received up to the end of the accounting period in which they are included in inventory are deducted from cost.
Taxpayers are free to include in cost or show among general expenses special consumption tax, non-deductible value added tax, banking and insurance transactions tax and resource utilisation support fund relating to acquiring the economic asset (excluding goods) or increasing its value.
...",
- in Article 269: "All real estate included in economic enterprises is valued at cost. Under this law, the following assets are valued like real estate:
1. integral parts and accessories of real estate;
2. installations and machinery;
3. ships and other vehicles;
4. intangible rights.",
- in Article 271: "For buildings and ships constructed and machinery and installations manufactured, their construction and manufacturing expenses replace the purchase price.",
- in Article 313: "The elimination under this Law of the value determined according to the principles in the first part of real estate used in the business for more than one year and subject to wear, tear or decline in value, and economic assets valued like real estate under Article 269, tools, equipment, furnishings, fixtures and cinema films, constitutes the subject of depreciation.
...",
- in Article 320: "The depreciation period starts from the year the assets enter the assets. To calculate this period in years, the number (1) is divided by the rate applied by the taxpayer.
...
Each year's depreciation can only be taken into account in that year's valuation.
The depreciation period cannot be extended because depreciation was not taken in any year or was taken at a rate lower than the rate first applied.
...",
- in Article 328: "In case of sale of depreciable economic assets, the difference between the price received and their recorded value in the inventory book is transferred to the profit and loss account. Taxpayers keeping books on a business account basis and those keeping a self-employment income book record this difference as revenue or expense in their books.
The value of those for which depreciation has been taken is the amount remaining after deducting the depreciation taken.
...",
- in Provisional Article 5: "Depreciable economic assets of taxpayers newly becoming subject to Income Tax due to their commercial, agricultural or professional income on the date this law enters into force or in subsequent years, or moving from the simplified method to the actual method, and of long-standing self-employed persons, are valued at cost or, if cost is unknown, at the value they themselves estimate according to the market price on the purchase date. However, depreciation for the years between the purchase dates of these assets and the date of becoming liable or moving to the actual method is deducted from this value and depreciation of the remainder continues.
..."

In addition, Article 315 of that Law provides that taxpayers will depreciate their depreciable economic assets at rates to be determined and announced by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance and that the useful lives of economic assets will be taken into account in determining the rates to be announced, and under the authority granted to our Ministry by that article, "Useful Lives and Depreciation Rates" for depreciable economic assets have been determined and announced in the list (Depreciation List) annexed to Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 333 as amended by Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Nos. 339, 365, 389, 399, 406, 418, 439, 458 and 506.

Accordingly, if you own the taxi you operate, following the start of actual-method taxation that taxi must be included in the inventory at the amount calculated by deducting from its cost or, if cost is unknown, from the value estimated according to the market price on the purchase date, the depreciation that should have been taken from its acquisition date to the date of inclusion in inventory, and after this, if the depreciation period according to the useful life determined by our Ministry has not ended, it is possible to take depreciation for the remaining period. It is also possible to include in inventory in this way the workplace stated to have been bought in November 2020.

In addition, if these assets included in inventory are sold, the difference between the price received for the sale and the asset's recorded value in the inventory book (the amount remaining after deducting depreciation taken) must be transferred to the profit and loss account under Article 328 of Law No. 213. It is natural that if books are kept on a business account basis, this difference will be recorded in the book as revenue or expense.

In addition, in the concrete case, all revenues and expenses relating to the construction must be recorded in the book based on documents mandatory under that Law issued in the taxpayer's name, the workplace must be included in inventory/the relevant account at cost as of the date construction is completed, and an invoice must be issued on the arm's-length value if the workplace is withdrawn from the business/removed from the business inventory by the business owner, and on the actual sale price if sold to third parties.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.