A company that signed a software contract with a foreign company, had the software developed by another firm in Turkey and exported it to the foreign customer asked whether it can benefit from the CTL 10/1-ğ deduction on this income.
The Administration's view:
- The CTL 10/1-ğ deduction requires the service to be actually provided by the company; assistance, consultancy and intermediation services in these fields are excluded.
- Having the software made by another company breaches the condition of actually providing the service; the deduction cannot be applied to this income.
- For VAT, if the software service is benefited from abroad and the other conditions are met, the export of services exemption under VATL 11/1-a applies; refunds require the fee to arrive in Turkey. If benefited from in Turkey, VAT applies under general rules.
The ruling is relevant to companies sourcing software for foreign customers through subcontractors.
Full text
Subject: Whether income from selling to a non-resident software commissioned from another firm is exempt
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company signed a contract with a company operating in … to produce a computer program and that the computer program software, which was commissioned from another firm resident in Turkey, was exported by your Company to the firm resident in that country, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the tax deduction under subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of the Corporate Tax Law can be benefited from for the income obtained in this context.
UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income. The expenses in Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law and Article 40 of the Income Tax Law may be deducted from corporate income determined under this provision.
Article 10 of the same law provides:
"(1) In determining the corporate tax base, provided they are shown separately on the corporate tax return, the following deductions are made from corporate income in order:
...
ğ) 80% of the earnings obtained exclusively from these activities by service businesses engaged in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance after obtaining the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and to those whose workplace, legal and business centre is abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Turkey, provided the whole of the earnings is transferred to Turkey by the due date of the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is obtained.
To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the customer abroad.
..."
Explanations on the matter are given in the section titled "10.5. Services provided from Turkey to non-resident persons and entities" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, and the conditions for benefiting from the deduction are explained in the sub-sections under the main heading "10.5.2. Conditions for benefiting from the deduction".
The section titled "10.5.2.1. Main activity written in the articles of association of companies that can benefit from the deduction" of that Communiqué states:
"The main activities written in the articles of association of the companies concerned must include providing architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis, vocational training, education and health services. Only one of these services may be provided within the company, or more than one, provided they are included in the articles of association.
..."
and the section titled "10.5.2.2. The service being performed from Turkey exclusively for non-resident persons and/or entities" states:
"Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training services determined by the Ministry of Finance after obtaining the opinion of the relevant ministries must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre is abroad; and education or health services must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey.
The above services must actually be provided, and services such as assistance, consultancy and intermediation offered in these fields cannot be considered within this scope.
..."
According to these provisions and explanations, since having the software made by another company will be deemed a breach of the condition that the service is actually provided, it is not possible to take into account as a deduction in determining the corporate tax base under subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of the Corporate Tax Law the income obtained from the software exported to the firm resident in ….
UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 6/b, that a transaction made in Turkey means the service being performed in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey,
- in Article 11/1-a, that services rendered to customers abroad are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that for a service to be deemed rendered to customers abroad, it must be rendered for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad.
The section titled "II/A-2. Export of Services" of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:
"For a service to be exempt from VAT under Article (11/1-a) of Law No. 3065, under Article (12/2) of the same Law:
- the service must be rendered for a customer abroad,
- the service must be benefited from abroad.
That the service was rendered for a customer abroad is documented by an invoice and similar document issued in the name of the customer abroad.
Benefiting from the service abroad means that the service rendered in Turkey for the customer abroad relates to the customer's business, transactions and activities abroad and has no connection with its activities in Turkey.
Since goods and services that foreign firms will send to Turkey are consumed in Turkey, services such as consultancy, brokerage, supervision, finding customers, market research etc. provided in Turkey to these firms for such goods and services are not within the export of services exemption and are subject to VAT. In this case, in determining the benefit criterion, the service rendered must be directly related to the imported goods..."
and the section titled "II/A-2.2. Documentation and Declaration of the Exemption" states:
"The export of services exemption is documented by the service invoice issued to the customer abroad. Photocopies of service invoices certified by company officials or a list showing their details are submitted. These documents must be submitted attached to a petition within the return filing period in the period in which the exemption is declared. For declaring the exemption, it is not mandatory to have obtained the payment document for the service (a document showing the currency was brought into Turkey, bank receipt etc.).
...
Refund of VAT borne relating to transactions so declared and that cannot be offset by deduction is not made before the service fee arrives in Turkey in foreign currency. However, for service exports where the TL equivalent is shown on the invoice, refunds can also be made based on documents showing the fee was brought into Turkey in Turkish Lira."
Accordingly, if the software service provided to customers resident abroad is benefited from abroad and the other conditions listed above are also met together, it is possible to exempt that service from VAT within the export of services.
However, although it is not mandatory to have obtained the payment document (a document showing the fee was brought into Turkey, bank receipt etc.) for declaring the export of services exemption, it is not possible to refund VAT borne relating to transactions so declared and that cannot be offset by deduction before the service fee arrives in Turkey in foreign currency or, for service exports where the TL equivalent is shown on the invoice, in Turkish Lira.
In addition, if customers abroad benefit in Turkey from the software service provided by your company to customers resident abroad, the service will be subject to VAT under the general provisions.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.