A municipality asked whether inspection, examination and control services carried out by its building control and zoning directorates under a council-approved tariff pursuant to Municipal Revenues Law No. 2464 are subject to VAT, and at what rates.
The Administration stated that if these services are carried out solely by the municipality, without a commercial purpose and without creating unequal competition in the market, no public economic entity arises, no corporate tax liability arises and no VAT needs to be calculated. If the activities are carried out in a way that may cause unequal competition, corporate tax and VAT liability is established for the resulting public economic entity.
The ruling is relevant to fee-based services of municipalities.
Full text
Subject: VAT on inspection, examination and control services provided by a municipality
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: a) Your ruling request form dated … with incoming document number ….
b) Your ruling request form dated … with incoming document number ….
In your ruling request forms referred to in (a) and (b), stating that your Municipality has its revenue tariff approved by the Municipal Council and applied each year pursuant to Municipal Revenues Law No. 2464, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the fee tariff items, created by your Building Control Directorate and Zoning and Urban Planning Directorate for inspection, examination and control within your district solely by your Municipality having regard to local common needs and sent with your ruling request forms, are subject to value added tax (VAT), and on the VAT rates for those that are.
CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 1(1)(c) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 brings public economic entities within tax liability; Article 2(3) of the same Law provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or affiliated to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and bodies, whose activities are continuous and which fall outside paragraphs 1 and 2, are public economic entities; and Article 2(6) provides that public economic entities and economic enterprises belonging to associations or foundations not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties assigned by law, their lack of legal personality, independent accounts and allocated capital or workplaces do not affect their tax liability, and that the price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their economic nature.
Section (2.3.1.) of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains explanations on applying that Law, states that the explanations in section (2.4.) of the Communiqué must be considered as to whether a public economic entity forms a commercial, industrial or agricultural enterprise.
Section (2.4.) of that Communiqué explains that the distinctive features in identifying an economic enterprise are affiliation, continuity and the activity being commercial, industrial or agricultural in nature; in other words, the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as buying and selling, manufacturing goods or providing services for consideration within the market economy based on an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity; that rather than listing such cases one by one, the law covers all economic activities carried out by an association or foundation within the market economy; and that the price of goods or services sold being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their status as economic enterprises.
Furthermore, Article 97 of Municipal Revenues Law No. 2464, headed "Fee-based work", provides:
"Municipalities are authorised to charge fees, according to tariffs to be set by municipal councils, for all kinds of services not subject to fees or contribution shares under this Law that they will perform at the request of the parties concerned. Work granted to the municipality as a monopoly is subject to its own special provisions."
The section headed "Subject and scope of the fee" of Municipal Revenues Law General Communiqué Serial No. 31 states:
"Article 97 of Law No. 2464 states that municipalities are authorised to charge fees, according to tariffs to be set by municipal councils, for all kinds of services not subject to fees or contribution shares under this Law that they will perform at the request of the parties concerned, and provides that work granted to the municipality as a monopoly is subject to its own special provisions.
Under Article 59(e) of Municipal Law No. 272, fees for services to be collected according to tariffs set by the municipal council are among municipal revenues."
Under the above provisions and explanations, since the inspection, examination and control services carried out within municipal boundaries by your Municipality's Building Control Directorate and Zoning and Urban Planning Directorate under Municipal Revenues Law No. 2464 are services carried out solely by the municipality to fulfil municipal public services, without pursuing any commercial purpose and without creating unequal competition in the market economy, no public economic entity will arise within the Municipality due to these services and no corporate tax liability will be established.
However, where these activities are carried out in a manner that may cause unequal competition in the market economy, corporate tax liability will naturally be established for the public economic entity that arises within the Municipality.
VALUE ADDED TAX (VAT) LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT, and in Article 1(2), that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activity are determined under the Income Tax Law, and where the Income Tax Law is not clear, under the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional supplies and services of establishments belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and the unions they form, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations, and of revolving fund organisations or other establishments belonging or subject to them, are subject to VAT.
Within the framework of these explanations, where the inspection, examination and control services carried out by your Municipality within municipal boundaries under Municipal Revenues Law No. 2464 are performed to fulfil municipal public services, without pursuing any commercial purpose and without creating unequal competition in the market economy, there is no need to calculate VAT on the amounts in the fee tariff for these services.
However, where these activities are carried out in a manner that may cause unequal competition in the market economy, VAT liability must be established for the public economic entity that arises within your Municipality.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.