TREN
Contact us

Documents Relating to the Price Difference Paid to the Owner in an Expropriation by Exchange in Favour of a Municipality Are Exempt From Stamp Duty

Stamp Duty · ExemptionsDocuments Relating to the Price Difference Paid to the Owner in an Expropriation by Exchange in Favour of a Municipality Are Exempt From Stamp DutyPrivate ruling · 9 August 2024
Rast note

A municipality stated that it will exchange a parcel to be expropriated for a national garden project with two municipal properties and pay the value difference to the owner, and asked on which amount stamp duty is calculated on the payment to the owner.

The Administration's view:

  • Under paragraph I/A-9 of table (2), documents issued in expropriations made in favour of official offices are exempt from stamp duty.
  • Under Art. 8 of Law No. 2942, property bought by negotiation or exchanged is deemed acquired by expropriation.
  • If the difference decided to be paid to the owner in the expropriation made in favour of the municipality is paid as expropriation compensation, documents relating to this payment are exempt from stamp duty.

The ruling is relevant to municipalities carrying out expropriations and to owners of expropriated property.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Stamp duty on payment in expropriation by exchange
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that your Municipality was notified by the Housing Development Administration (TOKİ) that the ownership of certain properties must be expropriated to start the construction phase of the … National Garden Project, that in this context the owner of block …, parcel no. …, …, requested a like-for-like exchange of this parcel for block …, parcel … in … Neighbourhood and block …, parcel … in … Neighbourhood owned by your municipality, that by decision of the … Municipal Council dated …/…/… numbered …/… the total value of the 2 properties belonging to … Municipality is TL … and the property registered in the name of … is TL …, and that it was decided to carry out the exchange on condition that the difference of TL … be paid in favour of that person, and that no separate agreement was made between … and your Municipality, an opinion is requested on which amount stamp duty is to be calculated on for the payment to be made to the expropriated party.

Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides in Article 1 that documents listed in table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; in Article 3 that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents and that stamp duty on documents relating to transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons; in Article 8 (as amended by Law No. 7338) that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, provincial special administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages, and that economic enterprises attached to these offices with separate legal personality are not deemed official offices; in Article 9 that documents listed in table (2) annexed to this Law are exempt from stamp duty; and in the second paragraph of Article 24 that those who sign documents signed by more than one person are jointly and severally liable for the whole of the tax and penalty, that the presence among them of those exempt from tax does not require the stamp duty to be paid short, that the whole of the tax on documents issued by stamp-duty-exempt institutions relating to persons' transactions in table (1) and bearing only the signature of these institutions is paid by the persons, but that if the tax on these documents is not paid or is paid short, the institutions are jointly and severally liable with the persons for the whole of the tax and penalty.

Paragraph A/9 of the section titled "I- Documents relating to official business" of table (2) annexed to that Law provides that "Documents issued in expropriations made in favour of official offices" are exempt from stamp duty.

On the other hand, Article 8 of Expropriation Law No. 2942 provides:

"In expropriations to be made by administrations under this Law concerning immovable property registered in the land registry, the principle is that they first apply the purchase procedure.
After the expropriation decision is taken, the administration that will carry out the expropriation appoints one or more valuation committees of at least three persons from within its own organisation to determine the estimated value of the property according to the principles in Article 11 of this Law, also obtaining reports from expert persons, institutions or organisations on the subject and, where necessary, using information obtained from Chambers of Industry and Commerce and local real estate agencies.
In addition, the administration appoints one or more conciliation committees of at least three persons from within its own organisation to conduct and conclude purchase by negotiation and exchange transactions on the estimated value.
The administration notifies the owner by official registered letter, without stating the estimated value determined by the valuation committee, that it wishes to buy by negotiation the property, resource or easement rights over them decided to be expropriated by paying the price in cash or, if made under the second paragraph of Article 3 of this Law, in instalments according to the procedures in that paragraph, or to take it over by exchange with another property of the administration.
If the owner or authorised representative applies to the administration within fifteen days from the notification date of this letter with a request to sell the property subject to expropriation by negotiation and agreement or to exchange it, negotiations are held on the date set by the committee, and if agreement is reached on price or exchange not exceeding the estimated value determined, a record of this agreement is drawn up and the record, which also contains all legal and actual characteristics of the property subject to agreement, the expropriation price, the owner's identity information and declarations of acceptance regarding registration or cancellation of the properties in the land registry, is signed by the owner or authorised representative and committee members. This record is deemed the owner's declaration of conveyance and the legal ground for registration in the land registry in the name of the administration.
Within at most forty-five days from the date the agreement record is drawn up, the price stated in the record is made ready by the administration and, based on the agreement record and the letter stating that the property has been cleared of all encumbrances and rights before expropriation, it is registered or cancelled ex officio in the land registry in the name of the administration. After ex officio registration or cancellation in the land registry, the expropriation price is paid to them.
Property, resources or easement rights bought or exchanged under this article are deemed taken from their owner by expropriation, and no objection actions can be brought against the expropriation so made or its price.
If there is no agreement or conveyance is not given, action is taken under Article 10 of this Law."

In this framework, from examination of the Municipal Council Decision dated …/…/… numbered …/… annexed to your ruling request form, it is understood that the total value of the two properties owned by your municipality is TL …, the value of the property belonging to … to be exchanged is TL …, and that it was decided to pay the difference of TL … to ….

Accordingly, if the TL … decided to be paid to … during the expropriation carried out in favour of your Municipality, which is an official office under the Stamp Duty Law, is paid as expropriation compensation, it is possible to exempt documents issued for this payment from stamp duty under paragraph I/A-9 of table (2) annexed to the same Law.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.