A company whose passenger car's engine burned out, and which expensed the engine replacement invoice as maintenance and repair with VAT deducted at 70% under the expense limitation, asked whether VAT on engine renewal expenses (labour + engine price) is deducted under the expense limitation or in full by adding it to the asset's cost.
The Administration's view:
- Tax Procedure Law: Engine replacement is an expense extending the car's life; the total including labour is added to cost and depreciated from the accounting period of acquisition over the period and at the rate set for the car.
- Corporate tax: For a company whose activity is not leasing or operating passenger cars, the depreciation is deducted in determining corporate income taking into account the expense limit in ITL 40/1-7.
- VAT: Since the engine renewal expense is included in the passenger car's cost and treated like its initial acquisition, VAT on labour and the engine price cannot be deducted under VAT Law 30/b.
The ruling is relevant to businesses with passenger cars in their assets that undertake major repairs on them.
Full text
Subject: Whether expenses incurred because the engine of a company passenger car burned out are deductible
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that the engine of the passenger car registered in your Company's assets burned out, that payment for the engine replacement was made on … and the invoice issued on that date, and that the maintenance and repair expenses on the invoice were expensed with value added tax (VAT) deducted at 70% under the expense limitation, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether VAT on the expenses incurred to renew the passenger car's engine (labour + engine price) will be deducted under the expense limitation or in full by adding it to the cost of the fixed asset.
CORPORATE TAX LAW ASPECT
The first paragraph of Article 6, titled "Net Corporate Income", of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period, and the second paragraph that the provisions of Income Tax Law No. 193 on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
The first paragraph of Article 40, titled "Deductible Expenses", of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
"The following expenses are accepted as deductions to determine net income:
7. Depreciation set aside under the provisions of the Tax Procedure Law. (Expenditure on heat insulation and energy saving that increases the economic value of real estate included in the business may be expensed directly in the year incurred.) (Excluding those used for this purpose by persons whose activities partly or wholly consist of leasing or otherwise operating passenger cars, for each passenger car whose initial acquisition cost excluding special consumption tax and value added tax exceeds TRY 135,000 (TRY 790,000), or, where those taxes are added to cost or the passenger car is acquired second-hand, whose depreciable amount exceeds TRY 250,000 (TRY 1,500,000), at most the portion of the depreciation corresponding to these amounts may be expensed. In applying this provision, the amount in force on the date the passenger car was acquired is taken into account.)"
On the other hand, the fifth section, titled "Deduction of Expenses and Depreciation of Passenger Cars From the Tax Base", of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 311 contains explanations and examples on the subject.
Accordingly, since the expenses incurred to renew the engine of the passenger car belonging to your Company (labour + engine price), whose main activity is not partly or wholly leasing or otherwise operating passenger cars, will be included in the passenger car's cost under the Tax Procedure Law, the depreciation set aside for that vehicle can be taken into account in determining your corporate income taking into account the expense limitation under item (7) of the first paragraph of Article 40 of the Income Tax Law.
TAX PROCEDURE LAW ASPECT
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in Article 262:
"Cost price means the total of payments made in connection with acquiring an economic asset or increasing its value and all expenses incidental thereto.
The following expenses are also included in cost:
a) customs duties, customs commissions, loading, unloading, transport and installation expenses directly related to acquiring the economic asset or increasing its value,
b) duties and fees, notary, land registry, court, valuation, consultancy, commission and advertising expenses directly related to acquiring the economic asset or increasing its value,
c) the portion of interest expenses on loans used to finance the economic asset and related exchange differences up to the date the goods enter inventory for merchandise and up to the end of the accounting period in which the asset is entered in the inventory for other economic assets, and expenses relating to those loans (Taxpayers are free to add the other portions of interest expenses and exchange differences to cost or show them among general expenses.),
ç) storage and insurance expenses up to the date the economic asset is entered in stock or inventory,
d) expenses arising from purchasing and demolishing an existing building and levelling its land for real estate.
Grants received until the end of the accounting period in which real estate is entered in the inventory are deducted from cost, provided they are directly related to the real estate.
Taxpayers are free to add to cost or show among general expenses special consumption tax, non-deductible value added tax, banking and insurance transactions tax and the resource utilisation support fund relating to acquiring an economic asset (excluding merchandise) or increasing its value.
The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this article.",
- in Article 269:
"All real estate included in economic enterprises is valued at cost. Under this law, the following assets are valued like real estate:
1. Integral parts and accessories of real estate;
2. Installations and machinery;
3. Ships and other vehicles;
4. Intangible rights.",
- in Article 272:
"Apart from normal maintenance, repair and cleaning expenses, expenses made to enlarge real estate or electricity generation and distribution assets or to permanently increase their economic value are added to the cost of the real estate or the electricity generation and distribution assets.
(Expenses that permanently increase a ship's economic value by increasing its speed at the date of acquisition or enlarging or changing its passenger and cargo loading and accommodation arrangements, and expenses for replacing the body or engine of a motor land vehicle with a new one or adding a new arrangement not present when purchased, are among the expenses that must be added to cost.)
...
Where expenses for real estate or electricity generation and distribution assets consist of both repair and value-increasing expenses, the taxpayer is obliged to show separately the part of these expenses to be added to cost.",
- in Article 313:
"The elimination under the provisions of this Law of the value, determined under the principles in the first part, of real estate used in the business for more than one year and subject to wear, tear or loss of value, of economic assets valued like real estate under Article 269, and of tools, equipment, furnishings, fixtures and cinema films, constitutes the subject of depreciation.
...
(Added: 30/12/1980 - 2365/54) (Amount determined by Article 414 as amended by Article 19 of Law No. 4369, in force: 29.7.1998) Key money not exceeding 50,000,000 lira (TRY 6,900 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 556) and tools, equipment, furnishings and fixtures used in the business with a value not exceeding 50,000,000 lira (TRY 6,900 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 556) may be expensed directly without being depreciated. For those forming an economic and technical whole, this limit is considered collectively.",
- in Article 315: "Taxpayers amortise their depreciable economic assets, subject to the fourth paragraph of Article 320, at the rates to be determined and announced by the Ministry of Finance. The useful lives of economic assets are taken into account in determining the rates to be announced."
In this context, for an economic asset to be depreciated, it must be registered in the business's inventory, be ready for use, be used in the business for more than one year and be subject to wear, tear or loss of value; key money and tools, equipment, furnishings and fixtures having these qualities but whose value does not exceed the limit (applicable in the relevant period) set in the third paragraph of Article 313 of that Law may be expensed directly without being depreciated.
Also, under the authority granted to our Ministry by Article 315 of Law No. 213, the "Useful Lives and Depreciation Rates" applicable to depreciable economic assets have been determined and announced by the Depreciation List annexed to Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 333 published in Official Gazette No. 25446 of 28/4/2004, as amended by Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Serial Nos. 339, 365, 389, 399, 406, 418, 439, 458 and 506. In this context, for item "6.1. Cars and taxis (including jeeps and off-road vehicles)" of the "6. Transport Vehicles" section of that list, a useful life of 5 years and a normal depreciation rate of 20% are set.
In addition, expenses made after real estate and economic assets valued like real estate are entered in the assets are, depending on their nature, included in cost or recorded as general expenses; in this context:
- expenses made to give the economic asset features not present at initial acquisition or to improve features present at initial acquisition are deemed value-increasing expenses, and their depreciation periods are determined according to the remaining life of the economic asset,
- expenses made to extend the expected life of the economic asset at initial acquisition are depreciated, starting from the year they are capitalised, according to the rate and period set for the economic asset,
- normal maintenance, repair and cleaning expenses for the economic asset are not accepted as cost and must be recorded directly as expenses,
- after the economic asset has been fully amortised by completing its depreciation period, all expenses that increase its economic life and value are capitalised and amortised from the capitalisation date at the depreciation rate and period of the economic asset.
In this case, where the engine present at initial acquisition of the passenger car registered in the company's assets is replaced, since the new engine is an expense made to extend the car's life, the new engine price is depreciated from the accounting period in which it is acquired over the period and at the rate set for that passenger car.
Accordingly, where the vehicle's engine is renewed, since the expenses for installing the engine, in addition to the engine price, are incidental expenses for the engine, depreciation must be set aside on the total value (on labour + engine price).
VAT LAW ASPECT
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the framework of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 29/1-a, that taxpayers may deduct, from the VAT calculated on their taxable transactions, unless otherwise provided in this Law, the VAT shown on invoices and similar documents paid for supplies and services made to them in connection with their activities,
- in Article 30/b, that excluding those used for this purpose by persons whose activities partly or wholly consist of leasing or otherwise operating passenger cars, VAT shown on purchase documents of passenger cars belonging to businesses cannot be deducted,
- in Article 30/d, that VAT paid on expenses not accepted as deductions in determining income under the Income and Corporate Tax Laws cannot be deducted (excluding VAT paid on importation or as a responsible party relating to income distributed covertly through transfer pricing under Article 13 of Law No. 5520 and differences arising against the business under item (5) of the first paragraph of Article 41 of the Income Tax Law, and VAT declared and paid in the relevant tax period by taxpayers making supplies of goods or services in domestic transactions).
Accordingly, since replacing the engine present at initial acquisition of the passenger car belonging to your Company, whose activity is not partly or wholly leasing or otherwise operating passenger cars, and fitting a new engine is an expense made to extend the car's life, will be included in the passenger car's cost under the Tax Procedure Law and is treated like the initial acquisition of the passenger car, it is not possible to deduct VAT relating to the expenses incurred to renew its engine (labour + engine price).
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.