A university asked whether, when payments to jury members serving in faculty appointment processes are delayed within the year or into the next year, withholding is based on the base notified by the jury member or on the base in the month of payment.
The Administration's view:
- Wages are earned when paid in cash or on account; a payment is the wage of the month in which it is accrued and paid and is taxed using that period's tariff and cumulative base.
- If jury members are the university's own staff, the jury fee is taxed together with that month's salary on the cumulative base.
- If jury members work at other universities, the fee is wage from more than one employer and a base of "0" is initially used; however, cumulative withholding may be applied at the person's request with the university's agreement.
The ruling is relevant to universities and public bodies making jury and similar additional payments.
Full text
Subject: When tax is withheld on wage payments
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Examination of the ruling request form referred to above shows that, stating that under the "Procedures and Principles on the Fee to be Paid to Jury Members Serving in Associate Professorship Evaluation and Appointment to Faculty Membership Processes" published by the Council of Higher Education (YÖK), payments will be made to jury members serving in the appointment processes of faculty members to be appointed at your University, and that jury members notify your University of their income tax bases for the payment, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether, where the payment is delayed for several months within the same year or made in the following year for various reasons after the exam, taxation will be made on the base notified by the jury member or on the income tax base in the month of payment.
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 61 titled "Definition of wages":
"Wages are money and in-kind payments given, and benefits provided that can be represented in money, in return for service to those working dependent on an employer and attached to a specific workplace.
The fact that wages are paid under the names of allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial liability compensation), appropriation, raise, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense reimbursement or other names, or are determined as a certain percentage of profit provided this is not in the nature of a partnership relationship, does not change their nature.
..."
- in Article 62 titled "Definition of employer":
"Employers are natural and legal persons who hire employees and employ them under their orders and instructions..."
- in Article 94 titled "Tax withholding":
"Public administrations and institutions, public economic institutions, other entities, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed professionals obliged to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural income on the balance sheet or farm accounting basis are obliged, when making the payments listed in the subparagraphs below (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account, to withhold on account of the income tax of the beneficiaries.
1. From wages paid to employees and payments deemed wages listed in Article 61 (excluding those benefiting from exemption), according to Articles 103 and 104,
...
Article 96 is taken into account in making the tax withholding in the above subparagraphs."
- in Article 96 titled "Principles to be followed in tax withholding":
"Tax withholding applies to payments made in cash or on account within Article 94. The term payment on account in this article means all kinds of records and transactions showing those paying income and gains subject to tax withholding as indebted to the beneficiaries."
Accordingly, for income to reach the stage of taxation, it must have been obtained in the manner whose conditions are set in the tax laws. For wage income taxed on the actual basis, earning occurs when the income enters the person's legal and economic disposal. Legal disposal means the income becoming claimable by its owner; economic disposal means the time the income is placed at the owner's disposal. Therefore, for tax to be withheld on a wage payment, payment in cash or on account must have been made.
On the other hand, General Communiqué on Income Tax Serial No. 166 states that a wage payment is deemed the wage of the month in which it is accrued and paid, and tax must be withheld taking into account Articles 103 and 104 of the Income Tax Law.
General Communiqué on Income Tax Serial No. 311, as amended by General Communiqué Serial No. 321, states:
- in Article 20 titled "Treatment of general budget public administrations as a single employer":
"...
(6) Where personnel working in public administrations within the general budget also obtain wage income from another employer within the same year or leave their post and start working for that employer, the wage bases of that personnel will not be associated with each other and the wage obtained from each employer will be subjected to income tax withholding separately. In this case, if the total wages received from employers after the first exceed the amount in the second income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 of Law No. 193 (TL 49,000 for 2020), or, although not exceeding this amount, the total wage income received from both employers exceeds the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 of the same Law (TL 600,000 for 2020), the whole of the wage income must be declared.
..."
- in Article 21 titled "Situation of those working for more than one employer in private sector workplaces":
"...
5) An employee changing employer during the year may request that their wage be taxed cumulatively under the income tax tariff by notifying the new employer of the income tax base relating to their wage income. In this case the new employer withholds taking into account the cumulative base. Provided the employee requests and the employers accept, wage income received from more than one employer at the same time during the year may also be subjected to withholding taking into account the cumulative base. Where an employee whose wage income from more than one employer during the year is taxed taking into account the cumulative base is obliged to declare this income on the annual return, taxes paid by withholding taking into account the cumulative base may be offset against the income tax calculated on the base declared on the annual return."
According to the above provisions and explanations:
- If the jury members serving in associate professorship evaluation and appointment to faculty membership processes by your University consist of teaching staff working at your University, payments made to them due to jury membership, in addition to the salary paid in the relevant month, must be subjected to income tax under Articles 61, 63, 94 and 103 of the Income Tax Law based on the cumulative base,
- If the jury members serving at your University consist of teaching staff working at other universities, the wage the teaching staff obtain from their own universities and the wage obtained from jury membership at your university must be considered wages obtained from more than one employer, and the wage bases obtained from each employer must not be associated with each other. In other words, a base of "0" must initially be taken into account for the withholding taxation of wages those teaching staff will obtain from your University.
However, provided those teaching staff request and your University accepts, the wage income they receive from their own universities and your university may be subjected to withholding taking into account the cumulative base in the period in which payment is made in cash or on account. Where teaching staff whose wage income from more than one employer during the year is taxed taking into account the cumulative base are obliged to declare this income on the annual return, taxes paid by withholding taking into account the cumulative base may be offset against the income tax calculated on the base declared on the annual return.
On the other hand, wage payments made to jury members must be deemed the wage of the period in which they are accrued and paid, and subjected to income tax under Articles 61, 63, 94 and 103 of the Income Tax Law by applying the tax tariff valid in that period and taking into account the cumulative base for that period (month).
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.