A REIT whose shares are traded on Borsa Istanbul and which uses the CTL 5/1-d-4 exemption asked whether withholding under ITL 94 applies to its own shares bought back in 2020 under a buyback programme and not disposed of after two years.
The Administration's view:
- From 17/11/2020, no taxation arises at acquisition for fully liable capital companies acquiring their own shares.
- Under ITL 94/4-iii, if the shares are not redeemed or disposed of within two full years, the difference between acquisition cost and nominal value is deemed distributed dividend as of the last day of the two-year period.
- Since the Presidential Decisions providing a 0% rate entered into force later, for shares bought in 2020, 15% withholding applies on the difference, considering the effective dates and without regard to the CTL exemption.
The ruling is relevant to REITs and other capital companies buying back their own shares and using exemptions.
Full text
Subject: Whether own shares repurchased by a REIT under a buyback programme are deemed dividend distribution subject to withholding
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that:
- your Company is a real estate investment trust whose shares are traded on Borsa Istanbul,
- in 2020 your own company shares were purchased under a share buyback programme and these shares were not disposed of by the end of the second year,
- the exemption under sub-subparagraph (4) of subparagraph (d) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law is used and the internal withholding rate for your company is applied as 0% under the Council of Ministers Decision,
our Presidency's opinion is asked on whether withholding under Article 94 of the Income Tax Law applies to the purchase and holding of your own company shares.
Sub-subparagraph (4) of subparagraph (d) of the first paragraph of Article 5 titled "Exemptions" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that the income of real estate investment funds or trusts (excluding income of those other than those established to operate a portfolio consisting, as their main field of activity, of real estate, real estate projects and real estate-based rights) is exempt from corporate tax.
Under the third paragraph of Article 15 titled "Tax withholding" of the same Law, tax at 15% is withheld within the entity from the income listed in subparagraph (d) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Law, whether distributed or not, and that rate was set at 0% by Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14594.
The fourth paragraph added to Article 94 of the Income Tax Law by Article 17 of Law No. 7256 dated 11/11/2020 provides:
"Where fully liable capital companies, with respect to their own shares or partnership interests that they have acquired,
i) redeem them through capital reduction, the difference between the acquisition cost and the nominal value of the shares or partnership interests as of the date the capital reduction resolution is registered with the trade registry,
ii) dispose of them for a price below the acquisition cost, the difference between the acquisition cost and the disposal price as of the disposal date,
iii) do not redeem them through capital reduction or dispose of them within two full years from the acquisition date, the difference between the acquisition cost and the nominal value of the shares or partnership interests as of the last day of the two-full-year period from the acquisition date,
is deemed distributed dividend, and tax is withheld at 15% on these amounts. Taxes withheld under this paragraph cannot be offset against any tax. The President is authorised to re-determine this rate by reducing it to zero or increasing it up to double, separately or together, according to whether the shares of the fully liable capital company are traded on Borsa Istanbul, the ratio of traded shares to total shares, whether the repurchased shares are among those traded on Borsa Istanbul, whether they are repurchased from fully liable entities, and the total annual sales revenue and other income of the fully liable capital company."
and this provision entered into force upon publication in Official Gazette No. 31307 dated 17/11/2020.
Therefore, from 17/11/2020 (inclusive), where fully liable capital companies acquire their own shares and partnership interests, no taxation will be made due to the acquisition. These companies will record the purchase of their own shares or partnership interests on the acquisition date, but apart from this no tax withholding will be made under Article 94 of the Income Tax Law by companies purchasing their own shares or partnership interests.
Section "15.6.7.5. Non-redemption through capital reduction or non-disposal of acquired shares or partnership interests" of Corporate Tax Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"Where fully liable capital companies do not redeem through capital reduction or dispose of their own acquired shares or partnership interests within two full years from the acquisition date, tax will be withheld at 15% under the fourth paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law on the difference between the acquisition cost and the nominal value of the shares or partnership interests as of the last day of the two-full-year period from the acquisition date.
Example 1: The nominal value of the shares of (G) A.Ş. is TL 20 per share. 1,000 shares recorded in the assets of (H) Ltd. Şti. at a total of TL 30,000 were purchased by (G) A.Ş. on 13/2/2021 for a total of TL 35,000.
No tax will be withheld under the fourth paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law as of 13/2/2021, the date (G) A.Ş. acquired the shares.
(H) Ltd. Şti. will subject the TL 5,000 gain (TL 35,000 - TL 30,000) from selling the (G) A.Ş. shares to corporate tax under general provisions and, if it meets the conditions, may benefit from the participation share sale gain exemption in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Law.
(G) A.Ş. has not redeemed through capital reduction or disposed of its own shares acquired for TL 35,000 as of 13/2/2023.
Accordingly, as of 13/2/2023 (G) A.Ş. will withhold tax at 15% on TL 15,000 [35,000 - (1,000 x 20)], the difference between the acquisition cost and the nominal value of its own shares, and will declare and pay the TL 2,250 tax calculated (TL 15,000 x 15%) on the February 2023 withholding and premium service return.
The TL 2,250 tax paid by (G) A.Ş. because it did not redeem through capital reduction or dispose of its own shares within two years from acquisition cannot be offset against any tax or refunded. Also, this TL 2,250 tax will not be taken into account as an expense by (G) A.Ş. in determining the corporate tax base.
..."
In the Decision annexed to Presidential Decision No. 6791 published in repeated Official Gazette No. 32104 dated 14.02.2023 and in force from that date, it is stated: "Under the fourth paragraph of Article 94 of Law No. 193, withholding at 0% is applied on amounts deemed distributed dividend relating to their own shares acquired by fully liable capital companies."
The Decision annexed to Presidential Decision No. 7343 published in Official Gazette No. 32241 dated 07.07.2023 and in force to apply to shares acquired from that date provides: "Under the fourth paragraph of Article 94 of Law No. 193, withholding at 0% is applied on amounts deemed distributed dividend relating to their own shares acquired by fully liable capital companies whose shares are traded on Borsa Istanbul."
Accordingly, where your own company shares purchased in 2020 are not disposed of at the end of two years, 15% withholding must be applied on the difference between the acquisition cost and the nominal value of the shares, taking into account the effective dates of the legislation, without associating it with the exemption provision of the Corporate Tax Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.