A company that added the TPL Repeated Art. 298/Ç revaluation fund to capital and, after the CMB did not accept this increase for an IPO, withdrew the fund from capital to account 522, asked whether this capital reduction is taxed under CTL 32/B.
The Administration's view:
- Under CTL 32/B, in a capital reduction within five years, reduction is deemed made first from taxable equity items; under TPL Repeated Art. 298/Ç, a revaluation fund transferred to another account other than capital is taxed.
- Provided the fund is removed from capital by necessity under CMB rules and continues to be tracked in account 522, equity items permitted by the CMB are added to capital simultaneously with the reduction and shown in capital sub-accounts, and the transaction complies with the Commercial Code, no taxation under CTL 32/B is made at this stage.
- If these conditions are not met or no simultaneous capital increase is made, the reduction is taxed under CTL 32/B.
The ruling is relevant to companies aligning their capital structure with CMB rules during an IPO.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of a capital reduction reversing a capital increase for an IPO not approved by the CMB
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that:
- you made a capital increase by adding to capital the revaluation fund arising from the revaluation of tangible fixed assets created under Repeated Article 298 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213,
- following the capital increase, an application was made to the Capital Markets Board (CMB) for the public offering of your Company's shares,
- under the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Share Communiqué regulating the procedures and principles for issuing shares under Law No. 6362, the CMB did not approve that capital increase, and therefore a capital reduction was made by withdrawing the revaluation funds added to capital and transferring them to the account "522 Revaluation Increases of Tangible Fixed Assets",
our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the capital reduction carried out to bring your Company into compliance with legislation so that it can apply for a public offering is subject to tax under Article 32/B of the Corporate Tax Law.
Article 32/B titled "Taxation on capital reduction" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
"(1) Where equity items added to capital by entities are subjected to capital reduction in any way after five full years from the date they were added to capital, the capital elements within the reduced amount are determined by proportioning cash or in-kind capital and other elements added to capital to total capital. In determining that ratio, the shares in total capital of:
a) equity items whose transfer to another account other than addition to capital, withdrawal from the business or transfer from the capital account to other accounts is subject to corporate tax and to withholding linked to profit distribution or the amount transferred to the head office,
b) equity items subject only to withholding linked to profit distribution or the amount transferred to the head office,
c) in-kind and cash capital not to be taxed if transferred to another account or withdrawn from the business
are taken into account.
(2) Where entities make a capital reduction before five full years have elapsed from the date they added equity items to capital, the reduction is deemed made from the capital elements in subparagraphs (a), (b) and (c) of the first paragraph respectively.
(3) In a capital reduction, among equity items added to capital, those whose date of addition to capital has not exceeded five full years are deemed withdrawn from the business first.
(4) Among capital elements determined by capital reduction under the first, second and third paragraphs of this article, those within subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph are subject to corporate tax and withholding, and those within subparagraph (b) only to withholding. For capital elements subject to corporate tax and withholding, the withholding base is the amount remaining after deducting the corporate tax calculated, and withholding is made on this amount under Articles 15 and 30 of the Law and Article 94 of Law No. 193.
..."
Under this provision, capital elements that can be subject to reduction under Article 32/B of the Corporate Tax Law can essentially be grouped in three classes:
I. Equity items whose transfer to another account other than addition to capital, withdrawal from the business or transfer from the capital account to other accounts is subject to corporate tax and to withholding linked to profit distribution/amount transferred to the head office,
II. Equity items subject only to withholding linked to profit distribution/amount transferred to the head office,
III. In-kind and cash capital not to be taxed if transferred to another account or withdrawn from the business.
Under that article, where a capital reduction is made before five full years have elapsed from the date equity items were added to capital, the reduction will be deemed made from the capital elements in classes (I), (II) and (III) above respectively. On the other hand, where these elements are subjected to capital reduction in any way after five full years from the date they were added to capital, the capital elements within the reduced amount will be determined by proportioning the capital elements in those classes to total capital.
On the other hand, paragraph Ç of Repeated Article 298 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
"Income or corporate taxpayers subject to full liability and keeping books on the balance sheet basis (including general, ordinary limited and ordinary partnerships, excluding those making inflation adjustment under subparagraph (9) of paragraph (A) regardless of the conditions in subparagraph (1) of that paragraph and those permitted to keep their records in a currency other than the Turkish currency) may revalue, as of the end of accounting periods in which the inflation adjustment conditions in paragraph (A) do not occur, the depreciable economic assets included in their balance sheets (excluding those subject to sale-lease-back transactions or lease certificate issuance as long as they retain this character) and the depreciation set aside on them and shown on the liabilities side of their balance sheets, under the following conditions.
...
4. The value increase arising in the value of economic assets as a result of revaluation is shown in a special fund account on the liabilities side of the balance sheet in a way that shows in detail the value increase corresponding to each revalued economic asset. The value increase is the difference between the net balance sheet asset values of economic assets after and before revaluation. Net balance sheet asset value means the value found by deducting the depreciation written on the liabilities side from the values of economic assets written on the assets side of the balance sheet. If depreciation was not made for economic assets in any year, that value is determined assuming these depreciations were fully set aside.
...
6. The part of the value increase shown in a special fund account on the liabilities side that is transferred to another account in any way other than addition to capital or withdrawn from the business is subject to income or corporate tax in the period in which this transaction is made, without being associated with that period's income. Value increases added to capital are accepted as values added to the business by the partners. These transactions are not deemed profit distribution.
..."
According to these provisions and explanations, provided that it is mandatory under capital markets legislation to remove from capital the revaluation increase fund added to capital in order to carry out the public offering, that this fund account is by necessity transferred to account "522" and continues to be tracked in this account, and that equity items permitted by capital markets legislation are added to capital simultaneously with the capital reduction and these items added to capital are shown in capital sub-accounts, and provided that the transaction also complies with the Turkish Commercial Code legislation, it is possible not to tax at this stage under Article 32/B of Law No. 5520.
On the other hand, if the above conditions cannot be met and/or no capital increase is made simultaneously with the capital reduction, that capital reduction must be taxed under Article 32/B of Law No. 5520.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.