A real estate management cooperative with hobby gardens on its land, which covers expenses such as watchman, electricity and water from the dues it collects, stated it has no commercial activity and asked about its corporate tax and VAT position.
The Administration's view:
- Since its articles of association contain no provision limiting business to partners and its purposes include non-partner transactions such as sale, lease and revenue sharing, the cooperative does not meet the CTL Art. 4/1-k exemption conditions.
- Corporate tax registration must therefore be established in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.
- Dues collected from members to cover expenses are consideration for commercial deliveries and services and an element of corporate income, so they are subject to VAT and declared with VAT Return No. 1.
The ruling is relevant to cooperatives whose articles of association do not meet the exemption conditions.
Full text
Subject: Corporate tax and VAT treatment of a real estate management cooperative
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that there are hobby gardens on land belonging to your Cooperative, that expenses such as watchman, electricity and water are covered by the dues collected by your Cooperative, and that it has no commercial activity, you request our opinion on the treatment of your Cooperative in respect of value added tax (VAT) and corporate tax due to this activity.
I- CORPORATE TAX LAW
The second paragraph of Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate income consists of the income items within the scope of income tax; the first paragraph of Article 6 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned by taxpayers in an accounting period, and the second paragraph that the commercial income provisions of the Income Tax Law apply in determining net corporate income.
Subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the same Law, titled "Exemptions", lists among institutions exempt from corporate tax: "Excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions that no profit is distributed on capital, no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board of directors, reserves are not distributed to partners and business is done only with partners, and which actually comply with these provisions, and, in addition to these conditions, building cooperatives which, from their establishment until completion of construction, do not include on their management and audit boards individuals or representatives of legal entities undertaking the construction works in whole or in part, persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or those in an employer-employee relationship with them, and whose building permit and land title are registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity..."
On the other hand, section "4.13.1. Conditions for exemption" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"For cooperatives to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, their articles of association must contain provisions that:
- no profit is distributed on capital,
- no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board of directors,
- reserves are not distributed to partners,
- business is done only with partners,
and these conditions must actually be complied with.
Cooperatives that do not include these conditions in their articles of association, or include them but do not comply with them in practice, cannot benefit from the exemption."
Section "4.13.1.4. Doing business only with partners" states:
"Since cooperatives aim to provide and protect certain economic interests of their partners, and particularly their needs relating to their profession and livelihood, their activity should normally be limited to partners only. Therefore, for a cooperative to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, its articles of association must contain a provision that business is done only with partners, and this provision must actually be complied with.
Non-partner transactions cover not only transactions with non-partners but also transactions with partners on matters not included in the cooperative's articles of association."
And section "4.13.3. Taxation of non-partner transactions in cooperatives exempt from corporate tax" states:
"By the parenthetical provision added by Law No. 7061 to subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of Law No. 5520, effective from 1/1/2018, it is provided that a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to non-partner transactions of cooperatives exempt from corporate tax; that earning income from these economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another fully liable institution, and later distributing that income to partners, do not affect the exemption; and that the procedures and principles for taxing income from non-partner transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.
Thus, from 1/1/2018, cooperatives' exemption will not be affected by non-partner transactions; however, income from these transactions will be subject to corporate tax in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity. Therefore, income from non-partner transactions of cooperatives meeting the other exemption conditions will be subject to corporate tax in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity, while income from partner transactions will not be subject to corporate tax.
Corporate tax registration will be established in the name of the economic enterprise deemed to arise attached to the cooperative legal entity for non-partner transactions.
...
Cooperatives exempt from corporate tax will keep accounts and records of their non-partner transactions in separate books certified in the name of the economic enterprise, without associating them with the cooperative's accounts..."
For a transaction carried out by a cooperative to be considered a partner transaction, it must be within the purpose of activity, in other words, within the field of activity specified in the cooperative's articles of association, and the work within the purpose of activity must be carried out exclusively with a cooperative partner.
However, from the review of the cooperative's articles of association, it is understood that it is stated that your cooperative's purpose is to acquire movable and immovable property it deems appropriate to improve its partners' economies by purchase, lease and similar legal contracts, to have workplaces, housing, industrial and tourist facilities, hobby gardens and the like built on immovables at its disposal for their valuation and utilization, to sell them if necessary, and to develop income-generating economic models such as sale, lease and revenue sharing relating to immovables at its disposal, and that the articles of association do not contain provisions that business will be done only with partners.
Under these provisions and explanations, since it is understood that your cooperative's articles of association do not meet the conditions in subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Corporate Tax Law and that your cooperative will also carry out non-partner transactions, corporate tax registration must be established in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.
II- VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
Article 1/1 of VAT Law No. 3065 provides that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are subject to VAT.
Section "1.3.", titled "Dues", of VAT Circular No. 60 states:
"Dues collected from members or participants are outside the scope of VAT provided they do not constitute consideration for any delivery or service. For example, membership dues that are among the revenues specified in an association's statute will not be subject to VAT.
However, dues paid in return for commercial deliveries and services of a cooperative subject to corporate tax, and regarded as an element of corporate income, will be subject to VAT. For example, dues paid by members of cooperatives subject to corporate tax, such as consumer and transport cooperatives, that are regarded as an element of corporate income are subject to VAT. Dues collected by a cooperative not subject to corporate tax to cover common expenses (meeting members' needs such as security, gardening, maintenance of pools and social facilities, electricity and water) will not be subject to VAT since they are not commercial in nature."
Accordingly, the dues collected by your Cooperative from members to cover expenses such as watchman, electricity and water are subject to VAT since they are paid in return for commercial deliveries and services and are regarded as an element of corporate income, and the VAT calculated on these transactions must be declared by your Cooperative with VAT Return No. 1.
Kindly be informed.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.