A company operating as a holding asked whether the CTL 5/1-e exemption is available on sales of participation shares in its own assets and in group companies' assets to related or unrelated persons, and whether other participation shares or real estate can be bought within five years.
The Administration's view:
- The exemption can apply to sales to third parties of group and non-group company shares in the holding's assets, converted to cash to strengthen the financial structure; it cannot apply to the holding's sales to intra-group companies.
- The exemption can apply to sales of shares in group companies' assets to other group companies and third parties, converted to cash to strengthen the financial structure.
- If sale proceeds are used to buy new participation shares for purposes other than economically beneficial ones such as a change of sector or obtaining a majority shareholding, the exemption is not available for that portion.
- In intra-group sales the price must be at arm's length under CTL 13.
The ruling is relevant to holding companies and entities selling shares within a group.
Full text
Subject: Corporate tax exemption on sale of participation shares held by a holding company
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company operates as a holding and participates in other businesses, that as a natural result of its participation activity there are participation shares of group companies in the company's assets, and that there are also participation shares of other group companies in group companies' assets, an opinion is requested on whether the exemption under subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law can be benefited from:
- where participation shares in your Company's assets belonging to group companies or non-group companies are sold to persons related or unrelated to your company,
- where participation shares in group companies' assets belonging to other group companies or non-group companies are sold to persons related or unrelated to the company,
and whether participation shares of a different non-group or intra-group company and real estate can be bought within five years.
Subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5, titled "Exemptions", of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
"75% of the gains of entities from the sale of participation shares held in their assets for at least two full years, and of founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emption rights held for the same period, and of participation units of investment funds giving rise to exempt gains under subparagraph (a) of this paragraph.
This exemption is applied in the period of sale, and the exempt portion of the sale gain is kept in a special fund account in liabilities until the end of the fifth year following the year of sale. However, the sale price must be collected by the end of the second calendar year following the year of sale. Taxes not assessed on time due to the exemption attributable to the sale price not collected within this period are deemed lost.
Taxes not assessed on time due to the exemption applied are deemed lost for the portion of the exempt gain transferred within five years to another account in any way other than addition to capital, withdrawn from the business, or transferred to the head office by limited taxpayer entities. This provision also applies in case of liquidation of the business within the same period (excluding transfers and demergers under this Law).
...
Gains of entities engaged in securities trading from the sale of values they hold for this purpose are outside the exemption."
On the other hand, under Presidential Decision No. 9160 published in Official Gazette No. 32735 of 27/11/2024, the exemption rate applicable under subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law has been set at 50%.
On this subject, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
- in the section titled "5.6.2.3.4.2. Status of holding companies":
"Under the Turkish Commercial Code, the exemption will not apply to gains from the sale of participation shares by holding companies whose purpose essentially consists of participating in other businesses (excluding participation shares proven and documented to have been acquired and held in their assets for participation purposes).
In this framework, companies must track shares or partnership interests of other companies they acquire in accounts in the "11-Marketable Securities" or "24-Financial Fixed Assets" groups under the Accounting System Application General Communiqué. Shares or partnership interests acquired to be held temporarily to make a profit from short-term price changes are tracked in accounts in the "11-Marketable Securities" group. Where holding companies have shares or partnership interests that must be tracked in that account, gains from their sale will not benefit from the exemption. However, it is natural that gains from the sale of participation shares that holding companies must track in accounts in the "24-Financial Fixed Assets" group can benefit from that exemption if the other conditions are also met.
...",
- in the section titled "5.6.2.4.1. Transfer and assignment without consideration in money, barter and expropriation of immovables and participation shares":
"For the exemption to apply, the immovables and participation shares must be sold, a gain must be obtained from this transaction, and there must be an improvement in the financial structure of the selling entity. Therefore, transactions such as transfer and assignment without consideration in money or barter of these asset items are not within the exemption.
As in the transfer of land in exchange for flats, the exemption provision will not apply in barter transactions, which mean the exchange of an asset or right for another asset or right.
Transfers of such assets voluntarily or through enforcement against existing debts, and expropriation transactions, must be considered within the exemption since they increase the financing possibilities of entities.
...",
- in the section titled "5.6.2.4.4. Status of transactions between group companies":
"Since the basic purpose of the exemption is to encourage strengthening the financial structures of entities, transactions that do not provide additional economic means to companies will be outside the exemption.
Since each group company has a separate legal personality, each company can benefit from the exemption.
However, where the sale transaction is carried out without cash entering the business, contrary to the purpose of the exemption, the exemption will not apply.
Also, where immovables or participation shares are transferred to a subsidiary as in-kind capital against a capital commitment arising from a capital increase by the subsidiary, the exemption cannot be used since the tied-up value will have turned into another tied-up value (participation share)."
The justification of the provision also states that the basic purpose of the exemption is to encourage strengthening the financial structures of entities, that transactions that do not provide additional economic means to firms will be outside the exemption, that the exemption will not apply to gains obtained fictitiously from sales of immovables and participation shares between related persons or entities, in a way affecting the management of entities, or between companies in the same group, and likewise that channelling the liquidity obtained from a disposed immovable or participation share into functionally similar fixed assets so that it becomes idle again will not be in line with the purpose of the exemption.
According to these provisions and explanations, gains can be subject to the exemption provided a cash inflow is obtained in return for the sale of participation shares and there is an improvement in the financial structure of the selling entity. Likewise, gains from the sale of participation shares that holding companies must track in accounts in the "24-Financial Fixed Assets" group can benefit from the exemption provided the other conditions are met. Each group company can also benefit from the exemption on participation share sale gains provided there is an improvement in the company's financial structure.
Gains from sales carried out without cash entering the business, from sales that do not economically strengthen companies' financial structures, from transfers of participation shares to a subsidiary as in-kind capital against a capital commitment arising from a capital increase by the subsidiary, and gains obtained fictitiously from participation share sales between companies in the same group cannot be subject to the exemption.
Also, the exemption cannot be used where the liquidity obtained from a disposed participation share is channelled into functionally similar fixed assets so that it becomes idle again. However, the exemption can be used where existing participation shares are sold and new participation shares purchased for economically beneficial purposes such as exiting one sector or field of activity and entering another, obtaining a majority shareholding in a company, and similar.
In this context:
- gains from the sale to third parties of participation shares, of both group companies and non-group companies, in the assets of your Company operating as a holding, for the purpose of strengthening the company's financial structure by converting them to cash, can be considered within the exemption, whereas gains from the sale of those shares by your Holding to intra-group companies cannot,
- gains from the sale to other group companies and third parties of participation shares, of both other group companies and non-group companies, in the assets of your group companies, for the purpose of strengthening the company's financial structure by converting them to cash, can be considered within the exemption,
- where the proceeds from the participation share sale are used to purchase new participation shares for purposes other than economically beneficial ones such as a change of sector or field of activity, obtaining a majority shareholding in a company, and similar, the exemption cannot be used for the portion of the proceeds used for that tied-up value, since one tied-up value is converted into another,
- also, it is natural that in sales within the same group the sale price must be at arm's length under Article 13 of the Corporate Tax Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.