TREN
Contact us

Customer Data Bought From a Dutch Firm and Used Abroad Is Outside VAT; Payment for a Confidential Customer List Is a Royalty Under the Tax Treaty

Corporate Income Tax · Foreign incomeCustomer Data Bought From a Dutch Firm and Used Abroad Is Outside VAT; Payment for a Confidential Customer List Is a Royalty Under the Tax TreatyPrivate ruling · 25 December 2024
Rast note

A company whose whole activity is selling energy to persons and firms in the Netherlands buys data (details of persons and firms to sell to) from a Netherlands-resident firm. It asked how VAT applies to the data invoice and whether it must withhold tax.

The Administration's view:

  • Under domestic law the payment is business profits; no withholding applies under CTL 30.
  • Under the tax treaty, payments for data on acquiring new customers are business profits under Article 7; if the Dutch firm has no permanent establishment in Türkiye, only the Netherlands may tax them.
  • However, if the payment is for a confidential customer list containing the customers of a particular product or service, it is a royalty under Article 12/4 of the treaty; Türkiye may tax it at a rate not exceeding 10% of the gross amount. A certificate of residence must be submitted to benefit from the treaty.
  • Since the data is supplied abroad and used abroad, it is outside the scope of VAT.

The ruling is relevant to companies buying data or customer lists from abroad.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Withholding on payment for data services from a Netherlands-resident firm
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company has made an agreement with a firm in the Netherlands and sells energy to persons and firms in the Netherlands, that as a Company it obtains data (details of the firms and persons to be sold to) from that country in order to sell to the Netherlands, that the firm in the Netherlands will issue you a data invoice for this data, that your Company's entire activity is directed at the Netherlands, and that the data obtained from abroad is used abroad again and not domestically, our Directorate's opinion is requested on how value added tax (VAT) should apply to the data invoice your Company receives from abroad and whether you will make a withholding payment.

CORPORATE TAX LAW ASPECT

The second paragraph of Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal and business centres are both not in Türkiye are taxed on a limited liability basis only on income earned in Türkiye; subparagraph (a) of the third paragraph provides that commercial income earned by foreign entities having a workplace or permanent representative in Türkiye in accordance with Tax Procedure Law No. 213 from work done in these places or through these representatives is taxed as corporate income within limited liability; and the fourth paragraph provides that the relevant provisions of the Income Tax Law apply regarding the earning in Türkiye of the income or revenue items specified in this article and having a permanent representative in Türkiye.

Article 22 of the same Law provides that, unless otherwise specified, the provisions applicable to fully taxable entities apply in determining the income of limited taxpayer entities earned through a workplace or permanent representative.

The first paragraph of Article 30, which regulates withholding in limited liability, provides that corporate tax withholding is made on the income and revenue of limited taxpayer entities listed in the article by those paying, in cash or on account, or accruing this income and revenue, including advances; subparagraph (c) of the same paragraph lists income from immovable property, with corporate tax withholding at 1% (under BKK No. 2009/14593) on income from immovable property derived from activities under Financial Leasing Law No. 3226 and at 20% (under BKK No. 2009/14593) on others; and the second paragraph provides that corporate tax withholding at 20% (under BKK No. 2009/14593) is made on amounts paid in cash or on account or accrued for the sale, transfer and assignment of intangible rights such as copyright, concession, invention, operation, trade name, trademark and similar, regardless of whether included in commercial or agricultural income.

However, there is no provision on withholding on payments within commercial income (excluding works within Article 42 of the Income Tax Law).

On the other hand, Article 7 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that, for commercial income, income and revenue are deemed earned in Türkiye for persons subject to limited liability where the income owner has a workplace or permanent representative in Türkiye and the income is obtained in these places or through these representatives.

According to these provisions and explanations, the data service obtained from the foreign-resident firm must be treated within commercial activity and no withholding must be made on those payments.

On the other hand, since there is a double taxation treaty in force between the Kingdom of the Netherlands and the Government of the Republic of Türkiye, it is natural that the provisions of that treaty must be considered first.

DOUBLE TAX TREATIES ASPECT

The "Agreement Between the Republic of Türkiye and the Kingdom of the Netherlands for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion With Respect to Taxes on Income" has been applied since 1/1/1989, and the first paragraph of Article 7 of that Agreement on "Business Profits" provides:

"1. The profits of an enterprise of one of the States shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other State through a permanent establishment situated therein. If the enterprise carries on business as aforesaid, the profits may be taxed in the other State but only so much of them as is attributable to that permanent establishment."

Article 5 of the Agreement, titled "Permanent Establishment", sets out in which cases a permanent establishment arises in the other State.

In this context, payments to be made to the Netherlands-resident firm in return for the data on acquiring new customers your company obtained from it must be treated as business profits under Article 7 of the Agreement, and as long as the Netherlands-resident firm has no permanent establishment in Türkiye under Article 5 of the Agreement, the right to tax its income will belong only to the Netherlands.

However, where that income is earned through a permanent establishment in Türkiye, Türkiye will also have a taxing right limited to the income attributable to that permanent establishment, and taxation will be made under our domestic legislation.

On the other hand, the first four paragraphs of Article 12 of the Agreement, titled "Royalties", are as follows:

"1. Royalties arising in one of the States and paid to a resident of the other State may be taxed in that other State.
2. However, such royalties may also be taxed in the State in which they arise, and according to the laws of that State, but the tax so charged shall not exceed 10 per cent of the gross amount of the royalties.
3. The competent authorities of the States shall by mutual agreement settle the mode of application of paragraph 2.
4. The term "royalties" as used in this Article means payments of any kind received as a consideration for the use of, or the right to use, or the sale of any copyright of literary, artistic or scientific work including cinematograph films, and films or tapes for radio or television broadcasting, any patent, trade mark, design or model, plan, secret formula or process, or for information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience, and for the use of, or the right to use, industrial, commercial or scientific equipment."

Accordingly, where your company makes a payment to the Netherlands-resident firm for a customer list that must remain confidential and contains the customers to whom a certain product or service is provided, such payments must be treated as royalties under Article 12(4) of the Agreement.

In this context, where your company makes a royalty payment to the Netherlands-resident firm in return for that service, although the right to tax this income belongs to the Netherlands under Article 12(1) of that Agreement, Türkiye also has the right to tax those payments under paragraph 2 of the same article. In such a case, Türkiye will have the right to tax at a rate not exceeding 10% of the gross amount of the payment.

Where the Netherlands-resident company pays tax in Türkiye, that tax will be credited or exempted in the Netherlands depending on the type of income, under Article 23 of the Agreement on the "Elimination of Double Taxation".

Where the Agreement provisions change the outcome under domestic law, to benefit from the Agreement provisions it must be proven by a document (certificate of residence) obtained from the Dutch competent authorities that the Netherlands-resident firm is a full taxpayer in the Netherlands and taxed in that country on its worldwide income, and a copy of the original of this document together with its Turkish translation certified by a Notary or by Turkish Consulates in the Netherlands must be submitted to the tax withholders or the relevant tax office. It is natural that where the certificate of residence cannot be submitted, our domestic legislation will apply instead of the Agreement provisions.

VALUE ADDED TAX LAW ASPECT

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the framework of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,

- in Article 4, that a service is any transaction other than supplies, cases deemed supplies and importation of goods, and that such transactions may take forms such as doing, processing, creating, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, storing, preparing, evaluating, leasing something or undertaking not to do something,

- in subparagraph (a) of Article 6, that transactions are made in Türkiye where goods are in Türkiye at the time of supply, and in subparagraph (b), where the service is performed in Türkiye or benefited from in Türkiye.

Section (I/C-2.1.2.1.) of the VAT General Application Communiqué, titled "Transactions Made by Those Whose Domicile, Workplace, Legal Head Office and Business Centre Are Not in Türkiye", states:

"Under Article 1 of Law No. 3065, for a service to fall within the scope of VAT it must be performed in Türkiye. Article (6/b) of the same Law provides that services performed or benefited from in Türkiye are deemed performed in Türkiye.
Accordingly, services performed in Türkiye by those whose domicile, workplace, legal head office and business centre are not in Türkiye, and services they perform abroad but which are benefited from in Türkiye, will be subject to VAT.
In such services, although the taxpayer is essentially the service provider, since it has no domicile, workplace, legal head office or business centre in Türkiye, the whole VAT will be declared and paid by the domestic counterparty benefiting from the service as a responsible party.
Where the service is exempt from tax, or the service is performed abroad and benefited from abroad, VAT will not be declared as taxpayer or responsible party.
For VAT to be declared as a responsible party, the counterparty benefiting from the service in Türkiye need not be a VAT taxpayer. Those without VAT liability are also obliged to withhold VAT for these services and declare and pay it with VAT Return No. 2..."

Section (1.1.1.), titled "Transactions Abroad", of VAT Circular No. 60 also contains explanations on the subject.

Accordingly, since the data purchase/sale activity obtained from abroad from foreign-resident firms and benefited from abroad is performed abroad and the service is benefited from abroad, that data purchase does not fall within the scope of VAT and is therefore not subject to VAT.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.