A company whose debtor was declared bankrupt by a final judgment, and which could not collect part of its receivable after the bankruptcy estate's liquidation, asked whether it could write off that part as a worthless receivable under Article 322 of the Tax Procedure Law.
The Administration stated that the opening of bankruptcy alone is not sufficient. If an uncollectible amount remains at the end of the liquidation, that balance can be written off as worthless, in the year the document or decision is obtained, on the basis of the court's decision closing the bankruptcy or documents from the bankruptcy administration. As there was no court decision closing the bankruptcy in this case, the amount cannot be written off.
The ruling is relevant to businesses with receivables from bankrupt debtors.
Full text
Subject: Recording uncollectible receivables as worthless receivables
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that a bankruptcy decision was issued and became final against a taxpayer from whom your company has a trade receivable, and that part of your receivable could not be collected after the liquidation carried out by the bankruptcy estate, you request our Directorate's opinion on whether the uncollected part of your receivable can be treated as a worthless receivable under Article 322 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 on the basis of the final bankruptcy decision.
Article 322 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
"Receivables that can no longer be collected according to a judicial decision or a convincing document are worthless receivables.
Worthless receivables lose their value on the date they acquire this nature and are eliminated by being written off as a loss at their recorded values.
Worthless receivables of taxpayers keeping books on the business account basis that fall within this article are eliminated by being recorded as an expense."
In this context, for a receivable to be treated as worthless, it must be proven, according to a judicial decision or a convincing document, that it can no longer be collected; in applying that article, receivables that have been lost, can no longer be collected and whose value has fallen to zero are essentially treated as worthless. Since demonstrating the difficulty of collection with objective and convincing documents is important for the worthless receivable rules, the legislator requires efforts showing that the receivable claimed to have become worthless was seriously pursued to be documented by a judicial decision or a convincing document. A judicial decision means that legal remedies were sought for collection, enforcement proceedings were carried out and, at the end of these applications and proceedings, a judge ruled that the receivable will not be paid. A convincing document means documents arising from circumstances and causes that have made payment impossible; for tax law purposes, examples of convincing documents include:
- the debtor's death without leaving any assets, or a declaration of absence issued by the courts in respect of the debtor under Article 32 et seq. of Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, and a decision of the civil court of peace that the heirs have renounced the inheritance,
- a court decision that the debtor has won a case brought against him by the creditor,
- documents drawn up before the court on the waiver of the receivable,
- a concordat agreement waiving the receivable,
- official documents showing that the debtor has been convicted of fraud and has no assets,
- a letter from the enforcement office showing that the enforcement file was closed because the debtor's address could not be determined and no renewal was requested within the legal period,
- agreements showing that the receivable was waived, provided there are specific and convincing reasons both for its origin and for the waiver (receivables waived by the creditor's unilateral declaration cannot be written off as worthless),
- documents relating to the decision closing the bankruptcy issued after the receivables have been liquidated by the relevant estate following a bankruptcy decision issued against the debtor by the commercial court.
Furthermore, a receivable must be written off as a loss by charging it to the expense accounts of the year to which the convincing documents or court decision on which it becomes worthless under the Tax Procedure Law relate; it cannot be written off in years before or after the year in which it should be written off.
On the other hand, proceedings by way of bankruptcy are collective proceedings against persons subject to bankruptcy, and bankruptcy is opened as of the day and time of the bankruptcy decision issued by the competent court. The person subject to bankruptcy thereby acquires the status of bankrupt. In bankruptcy, except in exceptional cases, proceedings by attachment against the debtor and proceedings for the provision of security are essentially stayed. The creditor cannot legally sue the debtor or pursue him by enforcement. Furthermore, in bankruptcy these remedies are closed and only the right to register with the bankruptcy estate is granted; in bankruptcy, which is a form of compulsory enforcement and collective liquidation, all creditors are treated equally and individual enforcement proceedings are therefore not permitted.
Accordingly, in applying Article 322 of Law No. 213, the opening of bankruptcy by a court bankruptcy decision against the debtor company is not sufficient for receivables from the debtor to be accepted as worthless and recorded in the accounts; where, as a result of the liquidation to be carried out by the bankruptcy administration/office formed on the opening of bankruptcy under the court decision, an amount of your receivables remains that is understood to be uncollectible, this remaining receivable may be recorded as a worthless receivable in the accounts of the year in which the documents/decision are obtained, on the basis of the court's decision closing the bankruptcy or documents obtained from the bankruptcy administration/office on the closing of the bankruptcy.
However, in the present case, since there is no existing court decision closing the bankruptcy, the amount stated to be uncollectible cannot be recorded in the accounts as a worthless receivable.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.