A company that signed a subcontract with a joint venture (Supplier) to which the Union Contractor, the Ministry of National Education, tendered a work under IPA II asked whether the subcontract is exempt from stamp duty under the IPA II Framework Agreement.
The Administration's view:
- Union Contracts and goods, services and works contracts signed between Union Contractors and their Suppliers are exempt from stamp duty.
- As the Agreement provides no exemption for contracts between Suppliers and their own suppliers/subcontractors, the contract between the supplier joint venture and its subcontractor cannot benefit from the exemption and is subject to proportional stamp duty under Table (1) I/A-1 of the Stamp Duty Law.
The ruling is relevant to firms working as subcontractors on EU-funded projects.
Full text
Subject: Whether a subcontract signed between a supplier and a subcontractor is exempt from stamp duty under the IPA II Framework Agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that a "Subcontract" dated … was drawn up between your Company and … Joint Venture (Supplier) regarding the "…" tendered by the Ministry of National Education to that Joint Venture under the contract concluded between the contracting authority … Development Bank and the Union Contractor, the Ministry of National Education, for the project named "…" under the Turkey-European Union (EU) Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance (IPA II) Framework Agreement, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether that contract is exempt from stamp duty under the IPA II Framework Agreement.
Article 1 of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides that the documents listed in Table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; Article 3 provides that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents; Article 4 provides that the nature of a document is examined to determine the tax to which it is subject and the tax in the table is found accordingly, that in determining the nature of documents, for those whose form is specified in laws their names in the laws, and for others the provision and meaning contained in the text on them, are considered, and that if reference is made to another document on the document whose nature is to be determined, tax is collected according to the nature it acquires based on the provisions of the referenced document; Article 10 provides that stamp duty is collected as proportional or fixed, that in proportional tax the certain amount of money written in these documents according to their type and nature, and in fixed tax the nature of the documents, is the basis, and that the term certain amount of money means the money contained in the documents or resulting from the figures written in them.
Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I. Documents related to contracts" of Table (1) annexed to the Law provides that contracts, undertakings and assignments containing a certain amount of money are subject to proportional stamp duty.
On the other hand, the IPA II Framework Agreement was signed between Turkey and the EU on 11/2/2015, its approval was found appropriate by Law No. 6647, and it entered into force from 22/6/2015 upon publication in Official Gazette No. 29393 dated 21/6/2015. The implementation procedures and principles regarding the tax exemptions of that Agreement were regulated by IPA II Framework Agreement General Communiqué Serial No. 1 published in Official Gazette No. 29623 dated 13/2/2016.
Article 28(2)(h) of that Agreement provides:
"Union contracts, contracts signed by Union contractors and by partners of a consortium or joint ventures or co-beneficiaries in grants (as defined under Article 122 of the Financial Regulation) shall not be subject to stamp duty or registration fee or any other fee having equivalent effect in the Republic of Turkey. This exemption shall also apply to contracts between grant beneficiaries (including their partners, affiliates and/or sub-grant beneficiaries) and their contractors (including their staff and contracted experts), as well as, where such payments are directly related to the Union contracts, contracts for incidental and temporary expenditures under service contracts and works contracts respectively, to transactions under Union contracts (including assignment of rights) and to the related payment orders to Union contractors."
Regarding the matter, the section titled "4.7.2.1. Application of the Stamp Duty Exemption" of that Communiqué states:
"The following contracts and documents issued for payments made exclusively under these contracts will be exempted from stamp duty:
- Union Contracts financed by the EU or by the joint contribution of Turkey and the EU, signed between the Contracting Authority and the Union Contractor and defined in section 3.5 of this Communiqué,
- where Union Contracts are signed jointly in forms such as joint venture, co-beneficiary or consortium, contracts signed between each partner or co-beneficiary and contracts concluded with them by related persons defined in Article 122 of the Financial Regulation (Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25/10/2012 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union and repealing Council Regulation No 1605/2002),
- goods, service procurement or works contracts signed between Union Contractors and their Suppliers under Union Contracts (including contracts signed between the Union Contractor and directly the Supplier's staff or contracted experts),
- contracts signed between the Union Contractor and its employees or contracted experts to provide a service under the Union Contract."
As understood from these provisions, goods, service procurement or works contracts signed with Union Contractors by natural or legal person Suppliers that supply goods, provide services or do works for Union Contractors under the Union Contract (including contracts signed between the Union Contractor and directly the Supplier's staff or contracted experts) are within the stamp duty exemption.
However, since that Agreement contains no provision that contracts drawn up between Suppliers and their Suppliers/Subcontractors will be exempted from stamp duty, it is natural that the stamp duty exemption will not apply to contracts drawn up between Suppliers and their Suppliers/Subcontractors and to documents issued for payments made under these contracts.
Accordingly, since it is not possible to exempt from stamp duty under the IPA II Framework Agreement the "Subcontract" dated … drawn up between … Joint Venture, in the position of Supplier, and your Company, in the position of Subcontractor of …, that contract must be subjected to proportional stamp duty under paragraph I/A-1 of Table (1) annexed to Law No. 488.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.