A publicly traded company transferred participation shares held for more than two years through partial division under CTL 19/3-b, giving the acquiring company's shares directly to its shareholders; the difference between the capital reduction, set by fair value under CMB rules, and the book value of the shares was booked to a temporary equalisation account. It asked whether this account is subject to inflation adjustment.
The Administration's view:
- Where the acquiring company's shares are given to shareholders in a partial division, the divided company reduces capital; the exchange ratio may be set on the fair value of the shares.
- Article 25 of Communiqué No. 555 states that a merger premium, which is not an asset or liability item under the tax laws and is a temporary balancing account, is not taken into account in inflation adjustment.
- The temporary account used to balance the balance sheet due to the partial division and capital reduction is likewise not taken into account in inflation adjustment.
The ruling is relevant to companies transferring participation shares through partial division and applying inflation adjustment.
Full text
Subject: Whether a temporary asset-side account is subject to inflation adjustment
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Examination of your ruling request form referred to above shows that our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether, given that your company engaged in … activities transferred participation shares held in its balance sheet for more than 2 years to an existing company through partial division under Articles 19 and 20 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520; that the acquiring company's shares obtained in exchange for the participation shares transferred in the partial division did not remain with your company but were given directly to your shareholders; that, although the assets subject to division were transferred to the acquiring company at their recorded values, the capital amount to be reduced was determined taking into account the fair value of your company and of the participation shares subject to division so that the price per share of your publicly traded company would not change under the Capital Markets Law and regulations; and that the difference between the book value of the participation shares subject to division and the reduced capital was recorded in a temporary equalisation account that does not represent a real asset, in order to balance the assets and liabilities of the balance sheet, the said equalisation account in your company's balance sheet is to be subjected to inflation adjustment under Provisional Article 33 and paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
Article 19 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
- in subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph:
"Partial division: The transfer by a fully liable capital company, or by the place of business or permanent representative in Türkiye of a foreign entity in the nature of a capital company, of participation shares held for at least two full years in its balance sheet, or one or more of its production or service units, at their recorded values as in-kind capital to an existing or newly established fully liable capital company, is deemed a partial division in applying this Law. However, in the transfer of production or service units, all asset and liability items necessary for the continuation of the activity must be transferred so that the integrity of the business is preserved. The acquiring company's shares obtained in exchange for the assets transferred in a partial division may remain with the transferring company or may be given directly to the shareholders of this company. In the transfer of participation shares under this subparagraph, if the acquiring company's shares are given to the shareholders of the transferring company, the debts relating to the transferred participation shares must also be transferred."
- in the fourth paragraph:
"In divisions made under this article, contra accounts of assets and liabilities are transferred together with the asset or liability account to which they relate."
The third paragraph of Article 20 of the same Law provides that profits arising from the transactions in subparagraphs (b) and (c) of the third paragraph of Article 19 of this Law are not calculated and not taxed, and that in partial divisions under subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph of Article 19, entities acquiring the assets of the divided entity are jointly and severally liable, limited to the fair value of the assets they acquire, for the tax debts of the divided entity accrued and to accrue up to the division date.
In this regard, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
- in section "19.2.2.3. Giving participation shares to shareholders":
"The acquiring company's shares obtained in exchange for the assets transferred in a partial division may remain with the transferring company or may be given directly to the shareholders of this company. In the transfer of immovables and participation shares under subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph of Article 19 of the Corporate Tax Law, if the acquiring company's shares are given to the shareholders of the transferring company, the debts relating to the transferred immovables and participation shares must also be transferred.
..., where the acquiring company's shares obtained in exchange for the transferred assets are given to the shareholders, the divided company will naturally reduce its capital..."
- in section "19.3.1. Status of shares received":
"The transfer of assets subject to merger or division to other companies at their recorded values does not require giving shares equal to the recorded value of the assets to the shareholders of the merged or divided company or to the divided company. The divided and acquiring companies must mutually determine the values of the assets subject to transfer and set an exchange ratio that protects the rights of the shareholders of the merged or divided company. The exchange ratio may be determined on the basis of the fair value of the shares of the divided and acquiring companies.
However, for the transaction to be deemed a merger or division under the Corporate Tax Law, the shares acquired in exchange for the assets subject to merger or division must be distributed to the shareholders of the company transferring its assets in proportion to the net worth value corresponding to their shares in the transferring or divided company..."
On the other hand, subparagraph (2) of paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
"2. In applying this article;
a) Non-monetary items mean items other than monetary items,
b) Monetary items mean items whose nominal values remain the same against changes in the value of the Turkish Lira but whose purchasing power changes in the opposite direction according to price movements (foreign currencies are also considered monetary items),
c) Inflation adjustment means calculating the amounts of non-monetary items to be considered in inflation adjustment in terms of purchasing power at the date of the financial statement by multiplying them by the adjustment coefficient,
...
j) Carry-forward means calculating the new values at the end of the relevant period of monetary and non-monetary amounts in the financial statements using the carry-forward coefficient,
..."
Also, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 555 states:
- in Article 9 titled "Items to be adjusted in the balance sheet":
"(1) Considering the relationship between purchasing power and changes in the national currency value, items in the financial statements are divided into two groups:
a) Monetary Items: items whose nominal values remain the same against changes in the national currency value but whose purchasing power changes in the opposite direction according to price movements.
b) Non-Monetary Items: items other than monetary items, in other words, items whose purchasing power does not change despite changes in the national currency value.
...
Monetary items (monetary assets and monetary liabilities) are not subjected to inflation adjustment, because the value of a monetary item in the balance sheet also shows that item's purchasing power as of the balance sheet date. However, since the values of non-monetary items (non-monetary assets and non-monetary liabilities) in the balance sheet are not values showing their purchasing power as of the balance sheet date, non-monetary items are subjected to inflation adjustment to purge the balance sheet of the effects of inflation.
(2) Monetary and non-monetary items among the items included in economic enterprises by type are in the lists annexed to this Communiqué (ANNEX 1 and ANNEX 2). Although equity items are not included in those lists, provided there is no provision to the contrary and no determination is made in the Communiqué, equity items are deemed "non-monetary items" in applying this Communiqué."
- in Article 25 titled "Merger premium (positive or negative differences arising from tax-free acquisition of entities in a shareholding relationship)":
"Section "19.1. Merger" of Corporate Tax Law General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states that where an entity acquires as a whole another entity in which it holds a participation or which holds a participation in it, the capital increase it makes being less than the amount corresponding to those participation shares does not mean a breach of the conditions in the first paragraph of Article 19 of the Corporate Tax Law; that if the value in the participations account is not equal to the nominal value of the participation shares, the positive or negative difference may be tracked in temporary accounts without being associated with the determination of the entity's taxable income; and that these temporary accounts may also be closed in the entity's records without being associated with the determination of taxable corporate income.
In this framework, a merger premium, which is not an asset or liability item under the tax laws, is a temporary account balancing assets and liabilities, and this character will not change regardless of the account in which it is tracked. Therefore, a merger premium arising from mergers under the first paragraph of Article 19 of the Corporate Tax Law must not be taken into account in inflation adjustment."
Accordingly, the temporary account used to equalise the assets and liabilities of the balance sheet due to the capital reduction made by giving the acquiring company's shares to your company's shareholders upon the transfer, through partial division under Article 19 of the Corporate Tax Law, of participation shares held in your company's balance sheet for more than two (2) years must not be taken into account in inflation adjustment.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.