The revolving fund enterprise of a provincial directorate of agriculture and forestry, which produces colostrum powder from colostrum bought from farmers to reduce calf deaths, asked which document is issued when buying from producers who cannot invoice, the withholding rate, and the VAT rate applicable on delivering colostrum powder.
The Administration's view:
- The revolving fund enterprise is treated like a public institution for Income Tax General Communiqué No. 164; on colostrum purchases from farmers, 2% is withheld under Article 94/1-11 of the Income Tax Law, or 1% if purchased with registration at a commodity exchange.
- For purchases from farmers not taxed on the actual basis, a producer receipt is issued under Article 235 of the Tax Procedure Law when paying the price.
- As colostrum and colostrum-based products are also used for human consumption, delivery of colostrum powder does not fall within the feed exemption in Article 13/ı of the VAT Law; the applicable rate can be assessed once the product's customs tariff position is determined and submitted.
The ruling is relevant to public enterprises that buy and process animal products from farmers and to feed/food producers.
Full text
Subject: Withholding rate on purchase and VAT rate on delivery of colostrum powder (calf feed)
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Letter dated 18.08.2023 and numbered E.10943981 and the annexed ruling request form.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Directorate's Revolving Fund Enterprise produces colostrum powder (calf feed) by obtaining the milk (colostrum) of large cattle that have newly given birth and subjecting it to certain processes in order to reduce calf deaths, our Directorate's opinion is requested on which documents will be required when buying colostrum from producers who cannot issue invoices, the withholdings to be made on the documents and the withholding rate, and the value added tax (VAT) rate to be applied on delivery of the colostrum powder converted from milk into a product.
I. IN TERMS OF THE INCOME TAX LAW:
Article 52 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that income from agricultural activity is agricultural income, and that agricultural activity means producing, hunting, preserving by hunters and growers, transporting, selling or otherwise benefiting from plants, forests, animals, fish and their products, on land, at sea, in lakes and rivers, by sowing, planting, care, breeding, raising and improvement, or by directly benefiting from nature.
The first paragraph of Article 94 regulating "Tax Withholding" of the same Law specifies who is obliged to withhold income tax, and subparagraph (11) provides that withholding is made from payments for agricultural products and services purchased from farmers; the rates are 1% for animals and their products and land and water hunting products purchased with registration at commodity exchanges and 2% for others, and 2% for other agricultural products purchased with registration at commodity exchanges and 4% for others.
On the other hand, Article 11 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 introduced joint and several liability for taxes paid by withholding: where those obliged to withhold tax and pay it to the tax office due to purchase and sale of goods fail to do so, all parties to the purchase and sale are jointly and severally liable for the tax together with them.
Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 164 gives the necessary explanations on income tax withholding on purchases of agricultural products and joint and several liability.
The first section of that Communiqué states that public institutions and organisations making support purchases (including Agricultural Sales Cooperatives Unions and similar) will withhold income tax on the purchase prices of all agricultural products they buy, whether from farmers or others, whether or not within the scope of support; and the second section states that public institutions not making support purchases but manufacturing by processing agricultural products, and public institutions trading agricultural products by virtue of their field of activity, are obliged to withhold income tax on their agricultural product purchases.
Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, since Uşak Provincial Directorate of Agriculture and Forestry Revolving Fund Enterprise is treated like public institutions for the application of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 164, income tax must be withheld at 2% under subparagraph (11) of the first paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law on payments to farmers for purchasing the colostrum of newly calved large cattle to obtain colostrum powder (calf feed), and at 1% if purchased with registration at commodity exchanges.
II. IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Article 227 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides that, unless otherwise provided, documentation of records kept under this Law and relating to relations and transactions with third parties is mandatory, and these records must essentially be documented with the documents in Article 229 and following articles or made mandatory under the authority granted to our Ministry.
In this context, Article 235 of that Law provides:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined on the simple basis, and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged, when paying the price of goods purchased from farmers not taxed on the actual basis, to draw up a receipt in two copies, sign one and give it to the selling farmer, and have the other signed by him and take it. Where the goods are purchased on behalf of the merchant or farmer by an employee or intermediary, the receipt is drawn up and signed by them.
In purchases from farmers on advance, the receipt is given at the time of delivery of the goods.
The copy of the producer receipt remaining with the merchant or buying farmer replaces the invoice.
..."
Accordingly, the producer receipt must be drawn up within that article by first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined on the simple basis and farmers obliged to keep books when paying the price of goods purchased from farmers not taxed on the actual basis.
Therefore, you must issue a producer receipt in the name of farmers not taxed on the actual basis when paying for your purchases of colostrum from them to obtain colostrum powder (calf feed).
III. IN TERMS OF VALUE ADDED TAX:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 13/ı, that deliveries of fertilisers registered by the Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock and their raw materials to fertiliser producers, and of oilseed cake (excluding starch residues classified under 2303.10 and brewing and distilling dregs under 2303.30.00.00.00), full-fat soya, bran, middlings, fish meal, meat meal, bone meal, blood meal, tapioca (cassava), sorghum and all kinds of compound feeds (excluding cat and dog food), straw, fodder turnip, fodder beet, root fodder, hay, alfalfa, vetch, sainfoin, green and silage maize, clover, fodder cabbage, fodder peas and similar animal feeds (including green and dry roughage and those processed in pellet form or with or without a binder), are exempt from VAT.
Section (II/B-11.3.) titled "Feed Deliveries" of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:
"Deliveries of goods listed in subparagraph (ı) of the first paragraph of Article 13 of Law No. 3065 and used as animal feed are exempt from VAT. Goods not within this article cannot be treated within the exemption even if used in feeding animals.
In applying this exemption, compound feed means feeds that can be used as complete or complementary feed for oral feeding of animals as a result of subjecting more than one item to industrial processes.
Pulps remaining from extraction of soya beans, sunflower seeds, olives, sugar beet, cotton seed and fruits and used as animal feed are treated within the exemption."
The letter dated ….. and numbered …. obtained from the General Directorate of Food and Control of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry shows that "colostrum powder" is addressed under both feed and food legislation, that the Food Supplements Commission permitted its use without limit for adults from 8/3/2016 and for the 4-10 age group from 1/11/2017, and that consequently colostrum and colostrum-based products are used in human consumption.
Accordingly, it is not possible to apply the exemption under Article 13/ı of Law No. 3065 to the delivery of colostrum powder obtained by your Directorate's Revolving Fund Enterprise from the milk of newly calved large cattle through certain processes to reduce calf deaths.
On the other hand, VAT rates are determined, based on the authority in Article 28 of Law No. 3065 and within its limits, by the Council of Ministers before the amendment by Decree Law No. 700 and by the President after it.
In this context, VAT rates were 1% for items in list (I) annexed to Council of Ministers Decision (BKK) No. 2007/13033, 8% for those in list (II) and 18% for others; by Presidential Decision No. 7346 published in Official Gazette No. 32241 dated 7/7/2023 and effective 10/7/2023, the rate was set at 10% for list (II) and 20% for transactions not in the lists, with no change for list (I).
Section (A) of list (I) annexed to that BKK includes "FOODSTUFFS", listed by statistical positions in the Turkish Customs Tariff Schedule. In addition, item 17 of list (II) includes "Baby foods used as human food, antisera, immunoglobulins, blood and blood components and blood products, and vaccines used for human and animal health".
On the other hand, to determine the VAT rate for colostrum powder, its statistical position in the Turkish Customs Tariff Schedule must be known; if your Directorate applies to customs regional directorates and determines and submits its tariff information, it will be possible to assess the applicable VAT rate.
Respectfully submitted for your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.