The ruling concerns whether the transfer of two properties, authorised by the court, from a shareholder who guaranteed the company's debts and also applied for concordat, to the company in concordat, is exempt from the title deed fee.
The Administration noted that the exemption in Article 308/g of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law applies only to the debtor and creditors for the transactions set out in the concordat project. Considering the preliminary projects and the court's interim decision together, it stated that no title deed fee should be charged on these property transfers between the debtors, provided they fall within the approved concordat project.
The ruling is relevant to companies in concordat proceedings and to shareholders who have guaranteed their debts.
Full text
Subject: Title deed fee exemption for real estate transferred to a company by its shareholder under a concordat project
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the examination of the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that the court has authorised and decided the transfer of two properties owned by …, a debtor under a concordat project, to your company, also a debtor under the concordat project, that these transfers will be carried out for the restructuring of debts envisaged in the concordat project and the successful implementation of the concordat, and that an opinion is requested on whether these transfers are exempt from the title deed fee.
Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to the Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; and paragraph 20/a of the section headed "I-Land registry transactions" of Tariff (4) provides that, on the transfer and acquisition of real estate for consideration, under a contract of maintenance until death or under barter provisions, a proportional fee is charged separately on the transferor and the transferee on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value of the real estate (on the sale price in cases of compulsory enforcement or dissolution of co-ownership, and on the assessed value in expropriations).
Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is charged on persons exempted from fees by special laws or on transactions so exempted.
Furthermore, Article 308/g headed "Fee and tax exemptions and incentive certificates in concordat" of Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 provides:
"Under an approved concordat project:
a) Transactions to be carried out are exempt from fees subject to Fees Law No. 492, and documents issued in respect of these transactions from stamp duty,
b) Amounts collected by creditors under any name whatsoever are exempt from banking and insurance transactions tax payable under Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802,
c) Loans extended to the debtor are exempt from the Resource Utilisation Support Fund.
These exemption provisions apply only to the debtor and the creditors within the project in respect of the transactions specified in the concordat project. Third parties cannot benefit from these exemption provisions."
Accordingly, the exemption provisions in Article 308/g of Law No. 2004 apply only to the debtor and the creditors within the project in respect of the transactions specified in the concordat project, and third parties cannot benefit from them.
From the examination of the documents obtained from your company by e-mail regarding your application and the annexes to your ruling request form, it is understood that:
- your company applied for concordat, and the Preliminary Concordat Project prepared accordingly states in item 5.4: "Debts under the concordat will be paid from cash inflows from main activities in accordance with the details explained in the cash flow statement. As explained in detail in the pro forma income statement and cash flow statement, our debts during the concordat process will be paid from cash inflows from main activities, collections of receivables accrued in past periods and the sale of real estate belonging to the Company's shareholder.", and in item 6.7: "The Company's shareholder has undertaken to sell real estate belonging to him in order to allocate resources to the company for the payment of debts during the concordat process, and promissory notes dated 30.06.2028 for TL 7,000,000 and 31.10.2028 for TL 7,000,000 have been received from him. These notes formally document the shareholder's undertaking and contribute to strengthening the financial structure within the concordat project.",
- in addition, because the company applied for concordat, the shareholders … and …, who personally guaranteed the company's debts with their assets, also applied for concordat and Preliminary Concordat Projects were prepared for them,
- in the interim decision of the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance dated … with docket no. …, in the Concordat (Arising from Ordinary Concordat) case brought by the claimants …, … and …, the claimants' attorney requested permission for the transfer of the real estate of the claimant individual to the claimant company; on assessing the file together with the preliminary project submitted by the claimants and the opinion report of the interim concordat commissioner, it was found that in the preliminary concordat project annexed to the statement of claim, the independent units nos. … and … registered on block …, parcel … in … Neighbourhood, … District, … Province, in the name of the claimant …, who is both a shareholder of the claimant company and a claimant, were shown as a resource for the company for the payment of its debts, that an undertaking was executed between the parties to this effect, and that the shareholder also issued a promissory note of TL 14,000,000 to the company; that the transfer of the two properties registered in the name of the claimant shareholder … to the claimant company would provide resources to the claimant company and also benefit the creditors of the claimant company, and that the transfer was therefore considered appropriate; and it was decided to permit the transfer of the two properties registered in the name of …, both a shareholder of the claimant company and a claimant, to the claimant company,
- in the hearing minutes of the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance dated … with docket no. …, it was assessed that the concordat could succeed and it was decided under Article 289/3 of Law No. 2004 to grant the debtor claimants …, … and … a definitive moratorium of 1 year from 9/1/2026.
Accordingly, considering that … and its shareholders … and … each applied for concordat; that, following the assessment of the Preliminary Concordat Projects prepared for them, the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance decided to grant the debtor claimants …, … and … a definitive moratorium of 1 year from 9/1/2026; that the Preliminary Concordat Project of … states that the debts during the concordat process will be paid from cash inflows from main activities, collections of receivables accrued in past periods and the sale of real estate belonging to the Company's shareholder, and that promissory notes were received because the shareholder undertook to sell his real estate to allocate resources to the company for the payment of debts during the concordat process; and that, by the interim decision of the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance dated …, the transfer of the two properties registered in the name of the claimant shareholder … to the claimant company was permitted on the view that it would provide resources to the claimant company and also benefit its creditors; no title deed fee should be charged under Article 308/g of Law No. 2004 on the real estate transfers to be carried out between the debtors in accordance with the Preliminary Concordat Projects and the court decision relating to them, provided that they fall within the approved concordat project.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.