TREN
Contact us

Bookkeeping, documentation, VAT, withholding and Ba-Bs obligations of the economic enterprise arising from a cooperative's non-partner transactions

Tax Procedure · DocumentationBookkeeping, documentation, VAT, withholding and Ba-Bs obligations of the economic enterprise arising from a cooperative's non-partner transactionsPrivate ruling · 30 April 2024
Rast note

A cooperative exempt from corporate tax asked whether the economic enterprise arising from its non-partner transactions will be a taxpayer only for corporate tax, or whether other obligations such as VAT, withholding returns and Ba-Bs forms must also be fulfilled in the enterprise's name.

The Administration's view:

  • The economic enterprise is deemed to arise only for corporate tax; no separate trade registry registration is needed. Revenue, costs and expenses of non-partner transactions are monitored separately in the cooperative's books; registration is based on the date of the non-partner transaction and must be notified.
  • Bookkeeping and documentation obligations continue to be fulfilled by the cooperative legal entity; purchase invoices for the non-partner activity are issued in the cooperative's name and the cooperative issues sales invoices.
  • Withholding and premium service returns and all VAT-able transactions (partner and non-partner) are declared under the cooperative's registration.
  • An exempt cooperative has no Ba-Bs obligation; but if corporate tax registration is established for the economic enterprise, the cooperative files Ba-Bs covering the enterprise's transactions.

The ruling is relevant to corporate-tax-exempt cooperatives carrying out non-partner transactions.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Bookkeeping and documentation where a cooperative's non-partner transactions create an economic enterprise
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that:

- by our Directorate's letter dated …, you were informed that an economic enterprise should be established for your non-partner transactions and that your cooperative's books and documents should be used,
- the letter … sent by the Ministry of Trade to … chambers of commerce and industry states: "From the statement that a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to cooperatives' non-partner transactions, it is understood that, for cooperatives' non-partner transactions to be made subject to corporate tax, they must be recorded in the books kept by the cooperative in a way that ensures this separation, and it is not possible to register a separate economic enterprise in the name of the cooperative legal entity."

and our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether your economic enterprise, a corporate taxpayer to be established attached to the cooperative legal entity, will be a taxpayer subject only to corporate tax, or whether its tax registration will also be established to cover all other returns such as VAT, withholding tax return and Form Ba-Bs.

I. Corporate Tax Law

Article 4 of the Corporate Tax Law provides:

"(1) The following institutions are exempt from corporate tax:
...
k) Excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions that no profit is distributed on capital, no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board of directors, reserves are not distributed to partners and business is done only with partners, and which actually comply with these provisions, and, in addition to these conditions, building cooperatives which, from their establishment until completion of construction, do not include on their management and audit boards individuals or representatives of legal entities undertaking the construction works in whole or in part, persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or those in an employer-employee relationship with them, and whose building permit and land title are registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity. (Parenthetical phrase added by Article 88 of Law No. 7061; in force: 01.01.2018) (Transactions of cooperatives with persons other than their partners and transactions with their partners on matters not included in the cooperative's articles of association are "non-partner" transactions. Disposals by cooperatives of fixtures, machinery, equipment, vehicles and similar depreciable assets allocated to their activities and having completed their economic life, and building cooperatives obtaining one workplace or dwelling per share by giving their own land in return for flats, are not non-partner transactions. A separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to cooperatives' non-partner transactions. Cooperatives earning income from their economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another fully liable institution, and later distributing that income to partners, do not affect the exemption. The procedures and principles for taxing income from non-partner transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.)"

Section "4.13.3. Taxation of non-partner transactions in cooperatives exempt from corporate tax" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:

"By the parenthetical provision added by Law No. 7061 to subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of Law No. 5520, effective from 1/1/2018, it is provided that a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to non-partner transactions of cooperatives exempt from corporate tax; that earning income from these economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another fully liable institution, and later distributing that income to partners, do not affect the exemption; and that the procedures and principles for taxing income from non-partner transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.
Thus, from 1/1/2018, cooperatives' exemption will not be affected by non-partner transactions; however, income from these transactions will be subject to corporate tax in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity. Therefore, income from non-partner transactions of cooperatives meeting the other exemption conditions will be subject to corporate tax in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity, while income from partner transactions will not be subject to corporate tax.
The necessary corporate tax registration will be established in the name of the economic enterprise deemed to arise attached to the cooperative legal entity for non-partner transactions.
On the other hand, the corporate tax registrations of cooperatives registered for corporate tax before 1/1/2018 due to non-partner transactions will be terminated as of 1/1/2018, provided they meet the other exemption conditions. The income of these cooperatives from non-partner transactions carried out from 1/1/2018 will be taxed by establishing corporate tax registration in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.
(Amended by Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 17. Amended paragraph: OG-15/02/2019-30687) For determining the income from non-partner transactions and the corporate tax base, cooperatives exempt from corporate tax must monitor separately the revenue, cost and expense items within and outside the scope of non-partner transactions, must not associate the revenue, cost and expense items of non-partner transactions with other transactions, and must record them in the books kept by the cooperative in a way that ensures this separation."

In this context, cooperatives exempt from corporate tax need not register separately in the trade registry, as an enterprise, the economic enterprise deemed to arise attached to the cooperative legal entity for tax purposes due to their non-partner transactions.

It is also natural that the withholding tax and premium service return must be filed by your cooperative covering the activities and transactions of the economic enterprise.

II. Tax Procedure Law

Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:

- in Article 158,

"Among taxpayers who have notified commencement of business, those whose business changes in a way requiring:
a) becoming subject to a new tax;
b) a change in the form of tax liability;
c) moving from liability to exemption;
must notify these changes to the tax office."

- in Article 168,

"Notifications are made within the following periods:
1. ...Notifications other than commencement notifications of companies, and cessation and change notifications, are made by the taxpayer to the tax office within one month from the date of the event to be notified..."

- in Article 172,

"The following individuals and legal entities must keep books in accordance with this law:
1. Merchants and craftsmen;
2. Commercial companies;
3. State economic enterprises;
4. Economic enterprises of associations and foundations;
5. Self-employed professionals;
6. Farmers.
State economic enterprises and economic enterprises of associations and foundations are subject to the provisions applicable to merchants in terms of bookkeeping."

- in Article 173,

"The bookkeeping obligation does not apply to the following individuals and legal entities:
1. Tradesmen exempt from income tax and farmers not taxed on the actual basis;
2. Those whose income is determined on the simple basis under the Income Tax Law,
3. Those exempt from corporate tax:
a) State economic enterprises;
b) Economic enterprises of associations and foundations
The above exemption provisions do not extend to the books to be kept, for the taxes from which they are not exempt, by taxpayers who, though exempt from income or corporate tax, are subject to one of the other taxes not determined on a lump-sum basis."

- in Article 176,

"Merchants are divided into two classes for bookkeeping:
First-class merchants keep books on the balance sheet basis;
Second-class merchants keep books on the business account basis."

- in Article 177,

"The following merchants are first class:
...
4. All kinds of commercial companies (ordinary partnerships are subject to whichever of the above subparagraphs their field of activity falls under);
5. Other legal entities subject to Corporate Tax (those among them for which bookkeeping on the balance sheet basis is not possible or necessary due to the nature of their business are permitted by the Ministry of Finance to keep books on the business account basis);
6. Those who voluntarily choose to keep books on the balance sheet basis."

In addition, the first paragraph of Article 227 of the said Law provides: "Unless otherwise provided in this law, records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties must be documented." These records must be documented by the obligated parties with the documents regulated in Articles 229 et seq. of the Law or made mandatory under the authority granted to our Ministry.

Article 231 of the said Law, titled "Invoice Rules", provides: "The following rules are observed in issuing invoices: 1. Invoices are issued in sequential number order. Where separate invoices each starting with the same number are used in various branches and sections of the same establishment, the names of the branch or section must be written on these invoices or the series must be distinguished by a special mark..."

Further, Article 124 of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 lists cooperatives among commercial companies; and Article 89 of Cooperatives Law No. 1163 provides that the provisions of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 apply to the accounting methods and mandatory books of cooperatives, cooperative unions, cooperative central unions and the National Cooperatives Union of Turkey, that the procedures and principles for applying this article are determined by a communiqué of the Ministry of Trade, and that the related provisions of the Tax Procedure Law are reserved.

On the other hand, according to the explanations in section "4.13.3" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, under the amendment made by Communiqué Serial No. 17, from 15/2/2019, cooperatives exempt from corporate tax must, for determining income from non-partner transactions and the corporate tax base, monitor separately the revenue, cost and expense items within and outside the scope of non-partner transactions, not associate those of non-partner transactions with other transactions, and record them in the books kept by the cooperative in a way that ensures this separation.

In this context, for a cooperative that is a first-class merchant under the Tax Procedure Law, must keep books on the balance sheet basis and must comply with the documentation provisions of the same Law, the arising of a separate economic enterprise attached to its legal entity for its non-partner transactions is regarded as a change in its business by becoming subject to a new tax under Article 158 of the Law, and action is taken accordingly. Therefore, even where a separate economic enterprise attached to your legal entity arises for corporate tax purposes in respect of your non-partner transactions, these statutory obligations must continue to be fulfilled by your legal entity.

Accordingly, invoices for your purchases of goods and services, including those relating to your non-partner activity, must be issued in the name of your cooperative legal entity; and for your sales of goods and services, your legal entity must issue invoices under the general provisions or, where there is no obligation to issue an invoice, documents replacing an invoice.

On the other hand, in establishing corporate tax registration due to the arising of a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity for its non-partner transactions, the date of the non-partner transaction must be taken into account and the notification obligation must be fulfilled.

III. VAT Law

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services performed in Turkey within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are subject to VAT, and in the second paragraph that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activity are determined under the Income Tax Law and, where the Income Tax Law is not clear, under the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of establishments belonging to or affiliated with, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and their unions, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organizations, and of revolving fund institutions or other establishments belonging to or affiliated with them, are subject to VAT.

On the other hand, with the amendment made by Law No. 7061 to subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Corporate Tax Law, the corporate tax registrations of cooperatives registered for corporate tax before 1/1/2018 due to non-partner transactions will be terminated as of 1/1/2018, provided they meet the other exemption conditions, and their income from non-partner transactions carried out from 1/1/2018 will be taxed by establishing corporate tax registration in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.

Accordingly, this regulation concerns corporate tax and has no effect on your cooperative's VAT registration. Therefore, all transactions subject to VAT (partner and non-partner) must continue to be declared under your cooperative's VAT registration.

IV. Ba-Bs Forms

Based on the authority granted to our Ministry by Articles 148, 149 and Repeated Article 257 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213, the procedures and principles for the obligation of taxpayers keeping books on the balance sheet basis to report purchases of goods and services above a certain threshold on Form Ba and sales on Form Bs were announced by Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Nos. 350, 362, 381 and 396, respectively.

The procedures, principles and reporting thresholds for fulfilling this obligation in the monthly periods of … and subsequent years are explained in General Communiqué No. 396, which states:

- in item 1.1.1, "Taxpayers moving from the balance sheet basis to the business account basis will not report from the accounting period in which they move to the business account basis."
- in item 1.1.2, "Taxpayers exempt from corporate tax will not file Ba-Bs forms from the accounting period in which they benefit from the exemption."
- in item 1.1.8 (added by Communiqué No. 523), "Documents issued as electronic documents under the Tax Procedure Law will not be included in Form Ba and Form Bs notifications from the period for July 2021."
- in item 1.2.2, "The threshold applicable to purchases and sales of goods and/or services for the monthly periods of 2010 and subsequent years has been redetermined as TL 5,000. Accordingly, purchases of TL 5,000 or more excluding VAT from one person or institution will be reported on Form Ba, and sales of TL 5,000 or more excluding VAT to one person or institution in Table II of Form Bs. (Paragraph added by Communiqué No. 523) In determining the TL 5,000 threshold, all documents issued electronically and on paper must be assessed together. If the threshold is exceeded, only documents issued on paper will be included in the notifications."
- in item 3.2.4 (amended by Communiqué No. 543), "Taxpayers obliged to report but all of whose purchases and/or sales are below the threshold or consist of electronic documents need not file Form Ba and/or Form Bs for the relevant period."
- in item 4.1, "Penal action will be applied under Repeated Article 355 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 to taxpayers who do not file the notification forms within the periods set in this Communiqué or make incomplete or misleading notifications."

According to the above explanations, if your cooperative is exempt from corporate tax, it has no obligation to file Form Ba and Bs from the accounting period in which it benefits from the exemption. However, if, although the cooperative is exempt from corporate tax, corporate tax registration is established in a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity due to its non-partner transactions, Form Ba and Bs must be filed by your cooperative covering the activities and transactions of the economic enterprise.

Kindly be informed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.