An agricultural development cooperative stated that it will distribute free to its members, after parcelling, three fields held in its assets for more than two years and merged into a single title through land consolidation, and asked whether it can benefit from the CTL Art. 5/1-e and VATL Art. 17/4-r exemptions.
The Administration's view:
- For the two-year period, the dates the properties were first recorded in the cooperative's assets are taken as the basis, not the consolidation date.
- However, transferring the fields to members after parcelling is deemed trading in real estate, so the CTL 5/1-e exemption cannot be used; the arm's-length value of the transferred properties is included in corporate income, and 10% withholding is applied on this value under ITL 94/6-b-i and declared on the withholding return.
- Since real estate trading is involved and free transfers are outside the exemption, the transaction cannot be exempted from VAT under VATL Art. 17/4-r.
The ruling is relevant to cooperatives and companies planning to distribute real estate to members or shareholders.
Full text
Subject: Tax treatment of free distribution to members of an agricultural development cooperative's land after parcelling
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that you request an opinion from our Presidency on whether you can benefit from the provisions of Article 5/1-e of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 and Article 17/4-r of the Value Added Tax Law for the properties to be given free to your members, stating that you are a taxpayer registered with the … Tax Office under tax identification number …, that three field-type properties belonging to your cooperative were merged into a single title, and that this property, recorded in your assets for more than two years and merged, will be distributed free to cooperative members after parcelling.
In Terms of Corporate Tax
The second paragraph of Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists cooperatives among corporate taxpayers, and subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the same Law contains the provisions on the conditions required for cooperatives to be exempt from corporate tax.
Subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of that Law, as amended by Law No. 7456, provides:
"75% of the earnings arising from the sale of participation shares held in the assets of entities for at least two full years, and founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights held for the same period, and participation units of investment funds forming the source of exempt earnings under subparagraph (a) of this paragraph.
This exemption applies in the period of sale, and the exempt portion of the sale gain is held in a special fund account in liabilities until the end of the fifth year following the year of sale. However, the sale price must be collected by the end of the second calendar year following the year of sale. Taxes not accrued on time due to the exemption corresponding to the sale price not collected within this period are deemed lost.
...
Earnings obtained by entities engaged in securities trading from the sale of assets they hold for this purpose are outside the exemption."
By Article 19 of Law No. 7456 published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, real estate sales have been removed from that exemption from 15/7/2023, and Provisional Article 16 added to the Corporate Tax Law by Article 22 of the same Law provides: "For real estate held in the assets of entities before the date this article enters into force, the provisions of subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 before its amendment by the Law introducing this article apply. However, the 50% rate in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of this Law is applied as 25% for real estate sale gains made after the date this article enters into force."
Detailed explanations on the matter are given in the section titled "4.13. Cooperatives" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1.
On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 75 of Income Tax Law No. 193 defines income from movable capital, and subparagraph (2) of the second paragraph states that earnings from participation shares (profit shares of limited company partners, partners of business partnerships and limited partners, and earnings distributed by cooperatives are included in this group. Distribution to members of profits arising from the cooperative's transactions with its members, in proportion to their transactions with the cooperative, is not deemed profit distribution) are income from movable capital.
The first paragraph of Article 94 of that Law lists those obliged to withhold, and sub-subparagraph (b/i) of subparagraph (6) of the same paragraph provides that withholding is made on profit shares listed in subparagraphs (1), (2) and (3) of the second paragraph of Article 75 distributed by fully liable entities to fully liable individuals, to those not subject to income and corporate tax and to those exempt from these taxes. Under BKK No. 2009/14592 as amended by Presidential Decision No. 4936, the withholding rate has been set at 10% from 22/12/2021.
In addition, from a query of our Presidency's records, it is understood that your Cooperative has had corporate tax liability at the … Tax Office since 1/3/1980, and from examination of the cooperative's articles of association annexed to the ruling request form, that Article 6 titled "Purpose" sets the Cooperative's purpose as developing members' production in all kinds of crop, livestock and forestry matters and carrying out supply, procurement, operation, marketing and processing activities relating to their needs, helping members develop economically and socially, providing employment, using natural resources to increase members' economic strength, and taking measures to develop handicrafts and home crafts and agricultural industry.
According to these provisions and explanations, for the property bought on 20/04/1993, 03/11/1998 and 15/01/2014 and recorded in your cooperative as fields, but given as a single title as a field of … m² on 22/7/2019 as a result of land consolidation under Law No. 3083, the dates on which the property was recorded in your cooperative's assets (20/4/1993, 03/11/1998 and 15/1/2014) must be taken as the start of the two-year period in applying the exemption in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law.
On the other hand, since transferring your cooperative's field-type properties (three fields merged into a single title through consolidation) to your cooperative's members after parcelling will be deemed trading in real estate, it is not possible for you to benefit from the exemption in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520.
However, the arm's-length value of the transferred assets must be taken into account in determining corporate income, and 10% income tax withholding must be made on this value under subparagraph (6/b-i) of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law and declared on the withholding and premium service return.
In Terms of Value Added Tax
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/4-r, that transfers and deliveries made by sale of participation shares held in entities' assets for at least two full years are exempt from VAT,
- in Provisional Article 43, that for real estate held in entities' assets before the effective date of this article, the provisions before the amendment made to subparagraph (r) of paragraph (4) of Article 17 of this Law by the Law introducing this article apply.
Section (II/F-4.16.1) titled "Exemption on Real Estate Sales" of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:
- in the section titled "4.16.1.1. Exemption on the Sale of Real Estate Held in Entities' Assets Before 15/7/2023":
"Provisional Article 43, added to Law No. 3065 by Law No. 7456 published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, provides:
"For real estate held in entities' assets before the effective date of this article, the provisions before the amendment made to subparagraph (r) of paragraph (4) of Article 17 of this Law by the Law introducing this article apply."
In this context, the VAT exemption will continue to apply to transfers and deliveries made from 15/7/2023 by sale by entities of real estate held in their assets before 15/7/2023.
For the exemption to apply to sales of real estate (land, plots, buildings) and participation shares, they must have been recorded in the entities' assets for at least 2 full years (730 days).
...
The exemption does not apply to deliveries of real estate held for this purpose by entities trading in assets within the exemption (habitually buying and selling or leasing real estate).
The exemption applies to transfers and deliveries made by sale. Transfers and deliveries in the form of donation or gift are outside the exemption.
..."
- in the section titled "4.16.1.2. Sale of Real Estate Recorded in Entities' Assets From 15/7/2023":
"By the amendment made to Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065 by Article 7 of Law No. 7456 published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, the VAT exemption for transfers and deliveries made by sale of real estate recorded in entities' assets has been abolished as of 15/7/2023, and from this date transfers and deliveries made by sale of real estate recorded in entities' assets will be subject to VAT under the general provisions."
Accordingly, if your Cooperative's three fields are consolidated into a single title and transferred to your members after parcelling, since real estate trading will have been engaged in and free transfers are not within the exemption, it is not possible to exempt this transaction from VAT.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.