TREN
Contact us

Gains on Product Certificates for Goods Placed in a Licensed Warehouse by a Grain Trading Company Are Exempt From Corporate Tax; Depositing Is Not Subject to VAT

VAT · ExemptionsGains on Product Certificates for Goods Placed in a Licensed Warehouse by a Grain Trading Company Are Exempt From Corporate Tax; Depositing Is Not Subject to VATPrivate ruling · 30 April 2025
Rast note

A wholesale grain trading company asked whether changes in the value of purchased products until they enter the licensed warehouse are taxable, and whether the gain exemption on disposals of electronic product certificates also applies to non-producer firms.

The Administration's view:

  • Corporate tax: the ITL Provisional Article 76 exemption applies to gains from disposals by depositors of product certificates issued for goods delivered by depositors to a licensed warehouse. A company that is not a producer and only trades grain can also benefit until 31/12/2028. Increases/decreases in product value until transfer to the warehouse do not affect taxable income unless a sale takes place.
  • VAT: placing purchased products in a licensed warehouse is not subject to VAT. Withdrawal of the product by the company without the certificate being sold on the exchange is also outside the scope of VAT; if the product is withdrawn with the same certificate after the certificate is delivered on the exchange, it is subject to VAT under 1/3-d. For product certificate supplies an invoice is issued to the buyer but no VAT is shown.

The ruling is relevant to grain traders using the licensed warehousing system.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Applications under the Licensed Warehousing Law
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your company is engaged in wholesale grain trade and that there are certain doubts about applications under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 relating to its field of activity, it is understood that an opinion is requested on:

- whether, given that products you purchased from producers against a producer receipt or from traders against an invoice are transferred to a licensed warehouse on the same day or some time later and that the product value may increase or decrease between the purchase date and the date of entry into the licensed warehouse, changes in product value before these purchased products are delivered to the licensed warehouse are taxable,

- whether the exemption introduced for gains from disposals of Electronic Product Certificates issued under Law No. 5300 is valid for firms other than producer firms, in other words, whether firms engaged only in grain purchase and sale are also subject to the exemption provisions under corporate tax and value added tax.

CORPORATE TAX LAW

Article 6, headed "Net Corporate Income", of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned by taxpayers in an accounting period, and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on business income apply in determining net corporate income.

Provisional Article 76 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that gains from disposals of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 of 10/02/2005 are exempt from income and corporate tax until 31/12/2028.

The section headed "Gain Exemption on Product Certificates Issued Under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:

"38.1. Corporate tax exemption
Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 entered into force on 17/2/2005, and the Law regulates the procedures and principles for the establishment, operation and supervision of licensed warehouse operators and authorised classifiers and other matters relating to the licensed warehousing system, with the aims of determining standards for standardisable basic and processed agricultural products suitable for storage such as cereals, pulses, cotton, tobacco, hazelnuts, oilseeds, vegetable oils and sugar, storing them in safe and healthy conditions, and facilitating their trade through product certificates.
By Provisional Article 76 added to the Income Tax Law by Law No. 5904 and in force from 3/7/2009, in order to encourage the agricultural products licensed warehousing system created to facilitate and develop trade in agricultural products, gains from disposals of product certificates were exempted from income and corporate tax until 31/12/2014.
38.2. Withholding Application
Since product certificates essentially represent ownership of an agricultural product whose standard, qualities and features are determined, ownership of the product defined in the certificate changes hands in parallel with the change of hands of the product certificate..."

Article 1 of Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 provides that the procedures and principles for the establishment, operation and supervision of the agricultural products licensed warehousing system are regulated to develop trade in agricultural products with determined standards; paragraph (e) of Article 3 provides that a licensed warehouse is a facility providing services of preservation in healthy conditions and storage for commercial purposes of agricultural products under this Law; paragraph (ı) that a product certificate is a negotiable instrument representing ownership of products and securing their pledge, issued by the licensed warehouse operator to name or to order, which can be given as security, may or may not be endorsable, and in cases not provided for in this Law is subject to the provisions on warehouse receipts in the Turkish Commercial Code; and paragraph (k) that a depositor means the natural or legal person who delivers his product to a licensed warehouse for storage services or holds in accordance with the legislation the product certificate issued by the licensed warehouse operator.

As understood from the provisions above, the exemption allows gains from disposals by depositors of product certificates issued for products delivered by depositors to a licensed warehouse under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 to be exempted from corporate tax.

Accordingly, even where one is not a producer and engages only in grain purchase and sale, gains from disposals of product certificates issued for products delivered to the licensed warehouse can be exempted from corporate tax until 31/12/2028.

Furthermore, increases or decreases that may occur in the value of products purchased from producers against a producer receipt or from traders against an invoice during the period until their transfer to the licensed warehouse will not be considered increases/decreases affecting taxable income as long as no sale takes place.

VALUE ADDED TAX LAW

Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the framework of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities, and in Article 1/3-d, that sales made at auction places and in customs warehouses and the supply of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 of 10.02.2005 to those who will withdraw the product represented by the certificate from the warehouse, are subject to VAT,

- in Article 2/1, that supply is the transfer of the right of disposition over goods by the owner or those acting on his behalf to the buyer or those acting on his behalf,

- in Article 9/3, that licensed warehouse operators are responsible for paying the VAT on supplies of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 to those who will withdraw the product represented by the certificate from the warehouse,

- in Article 10/k, that the taxable event occurs with the withdrawal from the warehouse of products represented by product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300,

- in Article 13/ğ, that the first supply of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 through product specialisation exchanges and commodity exchanges authorised by the Ministry of Industry and Trade to buy and sell product certificates,

- in Article 17/4-t, that supplies of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 through product specialisation exchanges and commodity exchanges authorised by the Ministry of Industry and Trade to buy and sell product certificates, excluding the transactions specified in sub-paragraph (d) of paragraph (3) of the first paragraph of Article 1 and paragraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 13 (the provision of paragraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 30 does not apply to transactions exempted from tax in this context), are exempt from VAT,

- and in Article 23/d, that in supplies of product certificates to those who will withdraw the product represented by the certificate from the warehouse, the value formed on the exchange where the certificate was last traded constitutes the VAT base.

Detailed explanations on VAT in transactions within licensed warehousing are given in section (II/F.4.18.) of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué published in Official Gazette No. 28983 of 26.04.2014 and in force from 01.05.2014, and that Communiqué states:

- in section 4.18., headed "Transactions Within Licensed Warehousing":

"........ VAT in transactions under Law No. 5300 is applied as explained below. The explanations concern VAT on supplies of product certificates under Law No. 5300 on Product Specialisation Exchanges and commodity exchanges authorised by the Ministry of Customs and Trade to buy and sell product certificates (both exchanges will be referred to briefly as "specialisation/commodity exchanges"), and also apply to supplies of electronic product certificates (ELÜS) created electronically in accordance with the Electronic Product Certificate Regulation published under Article 15 of that Law, having the status of printed product certificates under that Regulation.
Article 2 of Law No. 3065 defines supply as the transfer of the right of disposition over goods by the owner or those acting on his behalf to the buyer or those acting on his behalf; the transfer of the right of disposition over goods directly to the last person through chain contracts by two or more persons, without the goods changing hands in the meantime, is also characterised as supply, and in that case each stage is taxed separately.
Under this provision, the placing by product owners of their own products in licensed warehouses is not subject to VAT.
Furthermore, where a product placed in the warehouse and for which a product certificate has been issued is withdrawn by those who placed it in the warehouse without the certificate for that product being traded (sold) on the specialisation/commodity exchanges, there is no transaction within the scope of VAT since the right of disposition does not change hands. However, where the person who placed the product in the warehouse wishes to withdraw the product with the same product certificate after delivering that certificate through the specialisation/commodity exchanges, this transaction is subject to VAT under Article (1/3-d) of the Law.
Furthermore, each stage of change of hands of product certificates used in licensed warehousing and representing the product placed in the warehouse is a separate supply, and although these supplies are within the scope of VAT provided they are performed within commercial, industrial, agricultural or professional activities, they are exempted from VAT by Articles (13/ğ) and (17/4-t) of Law No. 3065. Therefore, VAT taxpayers holding the product certificate (excluding those with VAT liability only as responsible parties) issue invoices and similar documents to the buyer for product certificate supplies but do not show VAT on these documents.
Where the product certificate is supplied by those without VAT liability to VAT taxpayers, an expense voucher is issued by the VAT taxpayers.
Where the parties to the purchase and sale have no VAT liability, there is no need to issue invoices and similar documents. These transactions can be documented by a delivery report, undertaking or letter to be drawn up between the parties.
Where those without VAT liability supply product certificates in a manner of a commercial nature, if the transactions consist only of product certificate supplies, there is no need to establish VAT liability in their name because of these VAT-exempt transactions.",

- in section 4.18.2., headed "First Supply of Product Certificates Through Specialisation/Commodity Exchanges":

"Under Article (13/ğ) of Law No. 3065, the first supply of product certificates issued under Law No. 5300 through specialisation/commodity exchanges is exempted from VAT. This exemption is a full exemption, and VAT amounts arising from this exemption that cannot be offset by deduction are refunded to taxpayers according to the explanations in section (II/B-9.) of the Communiqué.",

- in section 4.18.3., headed "Supplies of Product Certificates After the First Supply":

"Under Article (17/4-t) of Law No. 3065, supplies between the first supply of product certificates and their supply to those who will withdraw the product from the warehouse are within the partial exemption.
Accordingly, no VAT is calculated on supplies by VAT taxpayers of the product certificate after its first supply either (excluding supply to those who will withdraw the product from the warehouse).
Furthermore, under the same article, the provision of Article (30/a) of the Law does not apply to transactions exempted from tax in this context. Accordingly, VAT taxpayers can deduct the taxes they incurred because of these supplies within the partial exemption, but cannot claim them as a refund.",

- and in section 4.18.4., headed "Supply of Product Certificates to Those Who Will Withdraw the Product From the Warehouse and Responsibility Application":

"Under Article (1/3-d) of Law No. 3065, supplies of product certificates issued under Agricultural Products Licensed Warehousing Law No. 5300 to those who will withdraw the product represented by the certificate from the warehouse are subject to VAT regardless of whether this supply is made within commercial, industrial, agricultural or self-employment activity, and under Article (10/k) of the Law, the taxable event in this transaction occurs at the moment the products represented by the product certificates are withdrawn from the warehouse. Under Article (23/d) of the Law, the VAT base in this transaction is the exchange value at which the product certificate was last traded.
Under these provisions, the supply by those supplying product certificates to those who will withdraw the product from the warehouse is subject to VAT even if they are not VAT taxpayers. The taxable event in this transaction occurs at the moment the product represented by the product certificate is withdrawn from the warehouse.
Furthermore, Article (9/3) of the Law states that licensed warehouse operators are responsible for paying the VAT on supplies of product certificates issued under Law No. 5300 to those who will withdraw the product represented by the certificate from the warehouse."

Accordingly, as understood from the explanations above, your placing in the licensed warehouse of agricultural products you purchased by issuing a producer receipt or against an invoice is not subject to VAT. Furthermore, where a product placed in the licensed warehouse by your company and for which a product certificate has been issued is withdrawn by your company without the certificate for that product being traded (sold) on the specialisation/commodity exchanges, there is no transaction within the scope of VAT since the right of disposition does not change hands. However, where your company, having placed the product in the warehouse, wishes to withdraw the product with the same product certificate after delivering that certificate through the specialisation/commodity exchanges, this transaction is subject to VAT under Article (1/3-d) of the Law.

Your company, holding the product certificate, must issue invoices and similar documents to the buyer for product certificate supplies, but must not show VAT on these documents.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.