A company producing, selling and importing lubricants asked whether the recovery contribution fee it declares and pays under Additional Article 11 of the Environment Law can be shown separately on invoices, whether it is part of revenue and whether it is included in the VAT base.
The Administration's view:
- For corporate tax, amounts collected from customers as recovery contribution fee are revenue; the fee declared and actually paid is an expense under ITL 40/1 as of the payment date.
- Under the TPL, if the fee is not included in the product price, it can be shown separately on the invoice provided the mandatory invoice information is included; if it is included in the price, a footnote stating how much of the price is declared and paid as recovery contribution fee may be added.
- As the fee is an element like a tax, duty, fee or levy relating to the goods delivered, it is included in the VAT base under VATL 24/b.
The ruling is relevant to producers and importers placing products subject to the recovery contribution fee on the market.
Full text
Subject: Recovery contribution fee
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your company is engaged in the sale, marketing, distribution and import of fuel and lubricants, and that your company, which carries out lubricant production, sale, marketing, distribution and import operations with EPDK licence no. ..., has become liable to declare and pay the recovery contribution fee under the "recovery contribution fee" application under Additional Article 11 of Environment Law No. 2872, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the recovery contribution fee can be shown separately on invoices issued to your customers, whether it is included in revenue, and whether it is included in the VAT base under Value Added Tax Law No. 3065.
I- UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
The first paragraph of Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 states that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period, and the second paragraph states that the provisions of Income Tax Law No. 193 on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income; the expenses in Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law and Article 40 of the Income Tax Law may be deducted from corporate income determined under this provision.
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in the first paragraph of Article 37: "Earnings from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are business income."
- in Article 38:
"Business income on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of the equity in the enterprise at the end and at the beginning of the accounting period. During this period, by the owner or owners:
1. Values added to the business are deducted from this difference;
2. Values withdrawn from the business are added to the difference.
In determining business income in this way, the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are complied with."
Subparagraph (1) of the first paragraph of Article 40 of the same Law provides that general expenses incurred to obtain and maintain business income may be deducted in determining net income; for expenses to be deductible under this provision, there must be a direct and clear causal link between them and obtaining the income. Expenses not of this nature cannot be deducted in determining business income.
On the other hand, Additional Article 11 of Environment Law No. 2872 provides:
"For products in list (1) annexed to this Law placed on the market domestically, a recovery contribution fee in the amount specified in this list is collected from points of sale for bags and from those placing on the market/importers for other products. If any product in this list is placed on the market together with the import of a different product, material or item, the recovery contribution fee is collected from the importer. The amounts in this list are applied each year, effective from the beginning of the calendar year, increased by the revaluation rate determined and announced for the previous year under Repeated Article 298 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 dated 4/1/1961. Fractions not exceeding 5% of the amounts so calculated are disregarded. The President is authorised to increase the amounts in this list or determined by applying the revaluation rate under this paragraph up to twice or reduce them by up to half.
Recovery contribution fees are declared by the end of the twenty-fourth day of the month following the date the product is placed on the market/imported to the tax office to which those concerned are attached for income or corporate tax, or by those without income or corporate tax liability to the tax office to be determined by the Revenue Administration, and paid by the end of the same month. If it is determined that the contribution fee was not declared on time or was under-declared, the person concerned is notified that the undeclared or under-declared contribution fee must be paid within one month. The contribution fee not declared on time or under-declared is collected under Law No. 6183 on the Procedure for Collection of Public Receivables with interest at the late payment surcharge rate calculated under Article 51 of that Law for the period from the last day it should have been declared to the date of payment. Amounts collected under this article are recorded as general budget revenue.
..."
Furthermore, Recovery Contribution Fee Return General Communiqué Serial No. 1 contains detailed explanations on the procedures and principles for declaring and collecting the recovery contribution fee payable for products in list (1) annexed to Environment Law No. 2872 dated 9/8/1983.
On the matter, Article 5 titled "Principles" of the Regulation on the Recovery Contribution Fee sets out the administrative and technical procedures and principles for products in list (1) annexed to Environment Law No. 2872.
Accordingly, at the stage of placing on the market products subject to the recovery contribution fee under Additional Article 11 of Environment Law No. 2872 and defined as lubricants by the Energy Market Regulatory Authority:
- amounts collected by your Company as Recovery Contribution Fee must be taken into account as revenue,
- the Recovery Contribution Fee paid by your Company must be taken into account as an expense in determining corporate income under the first paragraph of Article 40 of the Income Tax Law as of the date it is declared and actually paid.
UNDER THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Article 227 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides: "Unless otherwise provided in this Law, it is mandatory to document the records kept under this Law relating to relations and transactions with third parties", and these records must be documented with the appropriate document among those in Article 229 et seq. of the same Law or those made mandatory based on the authority given to our Ministry.
In this context, that Law provides:
- in Article 229: "An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work, showing the amount owed by the customer for the goods sold or work done.",
- in Article 230:
"An invoice contains at least the following information:
1. Date of issue, series and sequence number of the invoice;
2. Name, trade name if any, business address, tax office and account number of the issuer;
3. Name, trade name, address, tax office and account number if any of the customer;
4. Type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or work;
5. Delivery date and waybill number of goods sold, ..."
In addition, Additional Article 11 of Environment Law No. 2872 provides: "For products in list (1) annexed to this Law placed on the market domestically, a recovery contribution fee in the amount specified in this list is collected from points of sale for bags and from those placing on the market/importers for other products. If any product in this list is placed on the market together with the import of a different product, material or item, the recovery contribution fee is collected from the importer...", and the administrative and technical procedures and principles for determining, declaring, collecting and monitoring the recovery contribution fees to be collected from points of sale for bags and from those placing on the market/importers for other products in annex-1 of that Law, and the provisions to be complied with by points of sale for plastic bags and by those placing on the market/importers for other products, are set out in the "Regulation on the Recovery Contribution Fee" published in Official Gazette No. 30995 (4th Repeated) dated 31/12/2019.
Accordingly, on invoices to be issued for deliveries at the stage of placing on the market products subject to the recovery contribution fee under Additional Article 11 of Environment Law No. 2872 and defined as lubricants by the Energy Market Regulatory Authority, it is possible:
- if the recovery contribution fee is not included in the product price, to show/state the recovery contribution fee separately, provided the information required under Law No. 213 (type, quantity, price, amount of goods/work, etc.) is included,
- if the recovery contribution fee is included in the product price, to include a footnote/explanation such as "TL ... of the price is declared and paid as recovery contribution fee under the relevant legislation."
II- UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 20/1, that in deliveries and services the tax base is the consideration for these transactions,
- in Article 20/2, that consideration means the total of money, goods and benefits, services and values obtained in other ways that can be represented in money, received in any way or owed by those receiving the goods or services or acting on their behalf in return for these transactions,
- in Article 24/b, that packaging costs, insurance, commission and similar expense items and elements such as taxes, duties, fees, levies and fund contributions are included in the base.
Accordingly, the recovery contribution fee required to be declared for lubricants within the Recovery Contribution Fee legislation, which is an element such as a tax, duty, fee, levy or fund contribution relating to the goods delivered, must be included in the VAT base under Article 24/b of the VAT Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.