TREN
Contact us

A Fixed Record Correction Fee Applies When Shares Are Cancelled by Court Order and Registered in the Former Owner's Name

Fees · Title deed feesA Fixed Record Correction Fee Applies When Shares Are Cancelled by Court Order and Registered in the Former Owner's NamePrivate ruling · 2 October 2024
Rast note

A land registry directorate asked what fee applies to registering, in the name of the former owner (the contractor), land shares given as security to plaintiffs in a building where condominium ownership could not be established despite a sale promise agreement, after the land registry records were cancelled by a final court decision.

The Administration's view:

  • Since the court ordered cancellation of the shares registered in the plaintiffs' names and registration in the former owner's name, the transaction is treated as a record correction rather than a transfer for consideration (I/20-a).
  • A fixed fee is sought for this registration under Tariff (4) I/13-c of the Fees Law.

The ruling is relevant to property owners and land registry directorates handling cancellation and registration by court order.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Fee rate applicable to a registration transaction at the land registry
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: Your letter dated 24.11.2023 and numbered 10819336 and the ruling request form.

From examination of your letter referred to above and the ruling request form and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that by the decision of the … Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal given as a result of an appeal against the decision of … Consumer Court and the decision of the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation given upon an appeal on points of law against that decision, it was decided to cancel the land registry record of the shares registered in the names of the plaintiffs in the land-type immovable registered at parcel … block … … Neighbourhood … district and to register them in the land registry in the name of the defendant ..., an opinion is requested on how fees should be collected from the registration transactions to be made at your Directorate.

Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) attached to this Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; paragraph 13/c of the section titled "I - Land registry transactions" of Tariff (4) attached to the Law provides for a fixed fee for all kinds of type and record corrections other than paragraph (a) (for each transaction); and paragraph 20/a provides that a proportional fee is collected separately from the transferor and the transferee on the transfer and acquisition of immovables for consideration, under a lifetime maintenance contract or according to barter provisions, on the property tax value, not less than the declared transfer and acquisition price of the immovable (on the sale price in cases of compulsory execution or dissolution of co-ownership, on the assessed price in expropriations).

From examination of the decision dated … with Merits No. ... and Decision No. … of the … Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal and the decision dated … with Merits No. … and Decision No. … of the … Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation annexed to your letter, it is understood that a real estate sale promise agreement was signed between the plaintiffs and the defendant … for flats in the building to be built on the immovable at parcel … block … … Neighbourhood … district, but the defendant contractor did not carry out the work necessary to establish condominium ownership and chose to give land shares to the plaintiffs as security; that, alleging that the contractor later filed a lawsuit for dissolution of co-ownership at … Court on the grounds that he had a share in the land, a Land Registry Cancellation and Registration Lawsuit (Due to Purchase of Housing from the Contractor) was filed at … Court under Merits No. … requesting cancellation of the land registry of the unbacked land share registered in the defendant's name, distribution of independent units suitable for condominium ownership in accordance with the owners' shares and the location of the independent unit, if this is not possible replacement of the purchased immovables with defect-free equivalents, and if there is no replacement payment as compensation of market values to be determined according to the defect-free equivalent of the immovable; that the court accepted the lawsuit and ruled for cancellation of the land share portions in the plaintiffs' names and collection from the defendant of compensation determined in favour of the plaintiffs, but the … Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation decided to reverse the judgment and the decision was taken to appeal; that the lawsuit filed by the heirs of the landowner …, claiming that the landowner was a party to this lawsuit, was also joined with this lawsuit; that the reply letter obtained from the writs sent to … Municipality in line with the Court of Cassation's reversal decision stated that despite three building stop reports being drawn up for the immovable subject to the lawsuit, the project violations were not eliminated and it is not possible to obtain a building permit under current laws and regulations; that the expert report dated … gave the opinion that there are many works contrary to the project in the building subject to the lawsuit, that these violations cannot be eliminated by an amendment project under current laws and regulations, and that construction servitude and condominium ownership cannot be established in the building subject to the lawsuit; and that, on the grounds that the defendant contractor did not become entitled to the receivable and therefore cannot be compelled to perform and that there is no contractual or legal relationship between the landowner … and the plaintiffs, and upon evaluation of the evidence, … Court ruled for cancellation of the land registry record of the plaintiffs' shares registered in the land-type immovable and registration in the land registry in the name of the defendant …, and collection of material compensation from the defendant in favour of the plaintiffs, while in the joined lawsuit the lawsuit filed by the heirs of the landowner … was dismissed.

Accordingly, since under the decision dated … with Merits No. … and Decision No. … of the … Chamber of … Court it was ruled to cancel the land registry record of the shares registered in the names of the plaintiffs in the land-type immovable registered at parcel … block … … Neighbourhood … district and to register them in the land registry in the name of the defendant …, the former owner, a fee must be sought under subparagraph I/13-c of Tariff (4) attached to Law No. 492 during the registration transaction to be made at your Directorate based on that court decision.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.