TREN
Contact us

Law No. 222 Stamp Duty Exemption Can Apply to Documents in School Construction Under the Ministry of Education–TOKİ Protocol

Stamp Duty · ContractsLaw No. 222 Stamp Duty Exemption Can Apply to Documents in School Construction Under the Ministry of Education–TOKİ ProtocolPrivate ruling · 23 October 2024
Rast note

A joint venture that undertook a school construction work tendered by TOKİ under a school construction protocol between TOKİ and the Ministry of National Education (MEB) asked whether the stamp duty exemption under Articles 78 and 83 of Law No. 222 applies to documents issued for this work.

The Administration's view:

  • Under Additional Article 12 of Law No. 2985, TOKİ is an official office for stamp duty purposes.
  • Provided the work is within the TOKİ–MEB protocol and it is documented by a letter from MEB that payments to TOKİ are made using primary education appropriations, the stamp duty exemption under Articles 78 and 83 of Law No. 222 can apply to the tender decision, the contract and the documents issued for progress payments.

The ruling is relevant to contractors undertaking school and education building construction carried out through TOKİ.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether the Law No. 222 exemption applies to documents issued in school construction works under the protocol between the Ministry of National Education and TOKİ
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, stating that a protocol on school construction was drawn up between the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change Housing Development Administration (TOKİ) and the Ministry of National Education (MEB), and that the "… Work" with tender registration number … tendered by the Housing Development Administration was awarded to your Joint Venture, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether the exemption under Articles 78 and 83 of Primary Education and Education Law No. 222 will apply to the documents issued for that work.

Article 1 of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides that the documents listed in Table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; Article 3 provides that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents, and that the stamp duty on documents drawn up for transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons; Article 8 provides that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages.

Paragraph A/9 of the section titled "I. Documents related to contracts" of Table (1) annexed to that Law provides that contracts drawn up with the tendering administration in tenders made by official offices for purchases of goods and services; Article 2 of the section titled "II. Decisions and minutes" provides that all kinds of tender decisions of official offices and public legal entities whether or not subject to tender laws; and paragraph 1/a of the section titled "IV. Receipts and other documents" provides that receipts and release deeds containing a certain amount of money given by persons to official offices due to payments (including advances) relating to purchases of goods and services made by official offices, and documents ensuring that these payments are transferred to accounts opened or to be opened in the name of persons on behalf of official offices or paid to their orders and remittances, are subject to proportional stamp duty.

On the other hand, Article 7 of Primary Education and Education Law No. 222 provides that primary education is a National Education and Training Institution consisting of a four-year compulsory primary school and a four-year compulsory secondary school established to achieve the purpose specified in Article 1; Article 83 provides that all revenues of primary education and the expenses specified in Article 78 (excluding personnel expenses) are exempt from all kinds of duties and taxes.

The expenses listed in Article 78 of that Law cover expenses to be made by primary education institutions, and the article lists as expenses of primary education:

in paragraph (a), the construction, modification and major repair of village, town and city primary education institutions and teacher housing, all kinds of initial installations and school supplies, teaching tools and land and plot expropriations,

in paragraph (b), all kinds of expenses such as minor repairs, general expenses of schools, the price of school books and teaching supplies to be given free of charge to poor students, making up for students' lack of food and clothing, treatment of serious illnesses, and the expenses of boarding primary schools and supplementary courses and classes.

Our Ministry's general letter dated 22/10/1998 and numbered 37904, explaining the application of that provision in Article 83 of Law No. 222, states that contracts and tender decisions drawn up will not be subject to stamp duty provided they relate to expenditure for the construction, modification and repair of primary education institutions and teacher housing and the supply of school supplies and teaching tools and the acquisition of land or plots, and that one party is the primary education administration.

Stamp Duty Law Internal Circular Serial No. 2022/1 states: "...provided it is documented that the work subject to progress payments made by official offices to contractor firms is done on behalf of the primary education administration using primary education appropriations within the scope of Primary Education and Education Law No. 222, the stamp duty exemption in Article 83 of Law No. 222 applies, including the documents drawn up due to progress payments made by official offices to contractor firms for those works..."

In addition, subparagraph (m) of the first paragraph of Additional Article 1 of Housing Law No. 2985 lists among TOKİ's duties carrying out or having carried out the requested projects and applications upon the request of ministries and the approval of the Minister to which it is attached; subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 2 lists among TOKİ's revenues the administration service share, not less than three percent and not more than ten percent of the construction cost determined by protocols signed for the requested projects and applications to be carried out or had carried out by the Administration under subparagraph (m) of the first paragraph of Additional Article 1, to be received from the relevant institutions and organisations; and Additional Article 12 provides: "The Housing Development Administration is considered within the scope of special budget administrations for the application of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 and Fees Law No. 492." Accordingly, TOKİ falls within the scope of official office in stamp duty application.

It is understood that Article 4 of the Protocol annexed to your ruling request form states that the subject of the protocol covers having education buildings (schools, dormitories, etc.) requested by MEB built by TOKİ on behalf and for the account of MEB according to a long-term payment plan, and the payment of the price of works had built by TOKİ from the MEB budget according to the payment plan agreed between the parties; and Article 5 states that MEB is responsible for carrying out and following up the procedures relating to the annual investment program and budget before the relevant institutions for all payments under this protocol to be paid by MEB to TOKİ, that additional costs to be borne by TOKİ if instalments are not paid on time will also be paid by MEB to TOKİ according to the provisions of this Protocol, that VAT will be added to the payments made by TOKİ for the works subject to the protocol (TOKİ Service Fee will be applied to all kinds of taxes, duties, fees, licences, contribution shares, consultancy expenses payable to official institutions and additional payments arising according to the rate to be determined in obtaining bank financing) and this price will be the Final Realisation Price of the work to be taken into account in the offsetting, and that the TOKİ service fee will be calculated on the 3% rate determined within subparagraph (g) added to Article 2 of Law No. 2985.

Within the framework of the explanations above, if the "…" work subject to your application is within the protocol between TOKİ and the Ministry of National Education, provided it is documented by a letter to be obtained from MEB that payments to be made to TOKİ for that work are made using primary education appropriations, it is possible to apply the stamp duty exemption under Articles 78 and 83 of Primary Education and Education Law No. 222 to the tender decision taken, the contract drawn up and the documents drawn up due to progress payments for those works.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.