A collecting society for film, theatre and series actors asked about documentation, withholding and VAT on royalties it collects from foreign bodies for broadcasts abroad of productions featuring its members and passes on to the actors, and the taxation of the "contribution share" it deducts.
The Administration's views were:
- The society as a legal entity is not a corporate taxpayer, but since these services are provided for consideration, an economic enterprise arises within it whose profit is subject to corporate tax; the portion paid to actors is deductible.
- Actors cannot use the exemption in Article 18 of the Income Tax Law. Payments to registered actors are self-employment income and to unregistered actors occasional self-employment income; 20% is withheld in both cases.
- If the service is benefited from exclusively abroad, the economic enterprise's service abroad is within the export of services exemption. VAT is charged on the actors' documents and on the enterprise's intermediary service.
- The economic enterprise issues invoices for the royalty income it collects.
The ruling is relevant to collecting societies and artists earning royalty income.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of royalties paid to member actors through a collecting society
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: …
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that due to the broadcasting abroad and in various media of films or series featuring film, theatre and series actors who are members of your Union, royalty payments are made to the actors through your Union by the royalty bodies in the broadcasting countries, an opinion is requested regarding the taxation of these royalty payments made to your Union on:
- whether a document must be issued for payments received in the Union's account and, if so, what type of document,
- whether a self-employment receipt, invoice etc. is to be obtained from the actors and tax withheld when royalty payments made to your Union are paid to the actor right holders,
- whether, if documents are to be issued by your Union when paying the actor right holders, VAT is to be calculated in these documents,
- since a certain percentage is deducted under the name "contribution share" when paying the actor right holders and this deduction is used for the Union's expenses, whether any tax is payable on this "contribution share" and whether tax registration is required.
Corporate Tax Law
Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists economic enterprises belonging to associations among corporate taxpayers; paragraph 5 of that article provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or affiliated to associations, whose activities are continuous and which are not capital companies or cooperatives, are economic enterprises of associations; and paragraph 6 provides that economic enterprises belonging to associations not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties assigned by law, their lack of legal personality, independent accounts and allocated capital or workplaces do not affect their tax liability, and that the price of goods and services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their nature as economic enterprises.
Article 6(1) of that Law provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate profit earned by taxpayers within an accounting period, and Article 6(2) that the commercial profit provisions of the Income Tax Law apply in determining net corporate profit.
Article 38 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that commercial profit on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of equity in the enterprise at the end and beginning of the accounting period; that values added to the business by the owner(s) during the period are deducted from this difference and values withdrawn are added; and that in determining commercial profit in this way the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are observed. The expenses in Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law and Article 40 of the Income Tax Law may be deducted from corporate profit so determined.
Section (2.4) of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which explains the application of the Corporate Tax Law, explains that the distinctive features of economic enterprises are affiliation, continuity and the activity being commercial, industrial or agricultural in nature; in other words, the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as buying and selling, manufacturing goods or providing services for consideration within the market economy based on an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity; that rather than listing such cases one by one, the Law covers all economic activities carried out by an association or foundation within the market economy; that the price of goods or services sold being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their status as economic enterprises; and that even without a profit motive, an economic enterprise of an association or foundation is accepted to arise where the subject and activity of the business consist of all kinds of sales of goods and services or similar and are carried out continuously.
It is clear that for there to be continuous commercial, industrial or agricultural activity within the definition of an economic enterprise, the enterprise must participate in the circulation economy, in other words the goods produced or services provided in the enterprise must be sold for consideration; otherwise there can be no economic enterprise even if the other elements exist.
Furthermore, Article 42 of Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works, headed "Establishment of collecting societies", provides:
"Authors and holders of rights related to those of authors, and those who reproduce and distribute non-periodical publications by taking over from the author or right holder the authority to use financial rights through contracts drawn up in accordance with Article 52 of this Law and using rights over scientific and literary works under Article 10 of this Law, may establish more than one collecting society in the fields to be determined in accordance with the regulation and model statutes issued by the President, to protect the common interests of their members and to ensure the administration and pursuit of the rights recognised by this Law, the collection of fees and their distribution to right holders. Natural or legal persons qualified to be members, numbering four times the number of principal members of the mandatory bodies for authors or performers, and twice the number of principal members of these bodies for producers or radio-television organisations, must apply to the Ministry for permission to operate as a collecting society. Collecting societies operate in the field in which they are established after obtaining this permission."
For tax purposes, collecting societies established under Law No. 5846 by authors (lyricists, composers, poets, writers, painters, directors, screenwriters, computer programmers etc.) and related right holders (musicians, actors, phonogram producers, film producers, radio/TV broadcasters) to protect their members' common interests and to ensure the administration and pursuit of rights recognised by that Law, the collection of fees and their distribution to right holders have no corporate tax liability as legal entities.
However, where the activities of collecting societies operating under Law No. 5846 consist of commercial, industrial and agricultural activities carried out continuously and for consideration within the market economy based on an organisation, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic enterprise affiliated to the collecting society, separate from its legal personality, due to these activities. These activities of collecting societies being among duties assigned by law does not prevent an economic enterprise from arising.
Accordingly, where the services that collecting societies carry out by protecting their members' common interests and ensuring the administration and pursuit of rights recognised to their members, the collection of fees and their distribution to right holders are provided for consideration, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic enterprise arising within the collecting society due to these services and the profits earned must be subject to corporate tax.
Therefore, due to royalties paid to your Union by the relevant bodies in the broadcasting countries for the broadcasting abroad of films or series featuring film, theatre and series actors who are members of your Union, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic enterprise affiliated to your Union, separate from your Union's legal personality, and the profits earned must be subject to corporate tax.
In addition, the portion of royalties paid to your Union that is paid to the actor right holders may be taken into account as an expense in determining the corporate profit of the economic enterprise to be established.
Income Tax Law
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 65, headed "Definition of self-employment income": "Profits arising from all kinds of self-employed professional activities are self-employment income. Self-employed professional activity is the carrying out, in one's own name and for one's own account under personal responsibility without being subject to an employer, of work based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital and not commercial in nature. ...",
- in Article 66, headed "Self-employed professionals": "Those who carry out self-employed professional activity as a habitual occupation are self-employed professionals. ..."
Article 94(1) of the same Law, headed "Tax withholding", provides: "Public administrations and institutions, public economic institutions, other corporations, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed professionals required to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural profits on the balance sheet or agricultural operating account basis are obliged to withhold tax, to be offset against the income tax of the recipients, when making the payments listed in the following subparagraphs (including advances) in cash or on account", and point (2) of the same article provides for income tax withholding at 17% on payments for self-employed work within Article 18 and 20% on others.
Furthermore, Article 18 of the Income Tax Law, governing exemptions for self-employment income, provides:
"Revenue earned by authors, translators, sculptors, calligraphers, painters, composers, computer programmers and inventors and their legal heirs from publishing their works such as poems, stories, novels, articles, scientific research and studies, computer software, reportage, caricatures, photographs, films, video tapes, radio and television scripts and plays in newspapers, magazines, computer and internet media, radio, television and video, or selling their works in the form of books, CDs, diskettes, paintings, sculptures and sheet music and their patents, or transferring, assigning or leasing their existing rights over them, is exempt from Income Tax.
Prices and fees received for exploiting works by publication, performance, execution and exhibition are included in the exemption.
Earning the above profits occasionally does not prevent the exemption from applying.
The self-employment income exemption does not extend to tax to be paid by withholding under Article 94 of this Law.
Those whose total profits within this article exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 cannot benefit from this exemption. Those in this situation are not subject to the obligation to withhold under the first paragraph of Article 94."
and explanations on the subject are given in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 311.
Article 3 of that Communiqué, headed "Scope of the exemption and conditions for using it", states:
"(1) Article 18 of Law No. 193 lists the taxpayers benefiting from the self-employment income exemption and the works within the exemption, and also specifies which revenue is within the exemption. Accordingly:
a) The right to benefit from that exemption is granted to authors, translators, sculptors, calligraphers, painters, composers, computer programmers, inventors and their legal heirs.
b) The exemption covers works such as poems, stories, novels, articles, scientific research and studies, computer software, reportage, caricatures, photographs, films, video tapes, radio and television scripts and plays, and patents.
c) The revenue to which the exemption applies is revenue earned from publishing works in newspapers, magazines, computer and internet media, radio, television and video, or selling works in the form of books, CDs, diskettes, paintings, sculptures and sheet music and patents, or transferring, assigning or leasing existing rights over them. Prices and fees received for exploiting works by publication, performance, execution and exhibition are also included in the revenue within the exemption.
(2) Under Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works of 5/12/1951, registration is mandatory for some works and optional for others. To benefit from the self-employment income exemption in Article 18 of Law No. 193, works for which registration is mandatory must be registered, while no registration condition applies to other works.
(3) Works registered by the Ministry of Culture and Tourism must also be among the works listed in Article 18 of Law No. 193 or works similar to them; not all works registered under Law No. 5846 fall within the exemption.
..."
In this context, that exemption is granted to authors, translators, sculptors, calligraphers, painters, composers, computer programmers and inventors, and film, theatre and series actors cannot benefit from the exemption in Article 18 of the Income Tax Law for the profits they earn from the broadcasting abroad in various media of films or series in which members appear.
Under the above provisions and explanations:
- where film, theatre and series actors who are members of your Union are registered for self-employment income, payments collected by your Union and made to members due to the broadcasting abroad in various media of films or series in which they appear must be treated as self-employment income,
- payments to members of your Union who are not registered for tax and carry on acting occasionally must be treated as occasional self-employment income under Article 82 of the Income Tax Law, and payments collected by your Union and made to members must be taxed as occasional self-employment income,
and in both cases income tax must be withheld at 20% on the amounts paid under Article 94(1)(2)(b) of the Income Tax Law.
Value Added Tax Law
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional supplies and services of establishments belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, associations and foundations are subject to VAT,
- in Article 11/1-a, that export supplies and services relating to these supplies are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that for a service to be treated as an export of services, it must be performed for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad,
- in Article 32, that VAT shown on invoices and similar documents relating to transactions exempt under Articles 11, 13, 14 and 15 and Article 17(4)(s) of this Law is deducted from the VAT calculated on the taxpayer's taxable transactions, and where there are no taxable transactions or the tax calculated is less than the deductible tax, the VAT that cannot be deducted is refunded to those carrying out these transactions under principles to be determined by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance, provided it is claimed by the end of the second calendar year following the period in which the transaction took place.
Section (II/A-2.1.) of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation also states: "... That the service was performed for a customer abroad is documented by an invoice or similar document issued in the name of the customer abroad. Benefiting from the service abroad means that the service performed in Türkiye for the customer abroad relates to the customer's business, transactions and activities abroad and has no connection with its activities in Türkiye. ..."
Accordingly, where the service provided by the economic enterprise arising within your Union to the customer abroad for broadcasting films or series in foreign countries is benefited from exclusively abroad, this service may be treated as an export of services under Article 11 of Law No. 3065.
On the other hand, VAT must be calculated under the general provisions in documents issued by the actors who are your members for amounts transferred to them from fees collected from foreign broadcasters for this service. VAT must naturally also be calculated on the service provided by the economic enterprise affiliated to your Union for intermediating these transactions.
Tax Procedure Law
In applying Tax Procedure Law No. 213, the duties of taxpayers are regulated in Book Two of the Law, and the documents required to be issued/used under that Law are regulated in Article 229 and subsequent articles.
Furthermore, Article 227 of that Law provides: "Unless otherwise provided in this Law, records kept under this Law and relating to relationships and transactions with third parties must be documented.", and these records must be documented with the appropriate document among those in Article 229 and subsequent articles of the same Law or those made mandatory on the basis of the authority granted to our Ministry.
In this context, Article 229 of that Law defines an invoice as a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work to show the amount owed by the customer in return for the goods sold or work done; Article 230 contains provisions on the form/content of invoices; and Article 232 provisions on the obligation to use invoices.
In addition, persons other than those provided for in that Law and the related secondary legislation (such as first and second class merchants, those whose profits are determined under the simplified method, farmers required to keep books and self-employed professionals) have no obligation to issue the documents required to be used under this Law in their transactions.
Accordingly, since an economic enterprise arises within your Union due to royalties paid to your Union by the relevant bodies in the broadcasting countries for the broadcasting abroad of films or series featuring film, theatre and series actors who are members of your Union, the duties/obligations provided for in the Tax Procedure Law and the related secondary legislation must be fulfilled by your Union's economic enterprise, and in this context an invoice must be issued for the royalty income you earn.
Furthermore, records relating to royalties paid to right holders who are members of your Union must naturally be documented, depending on the type of tax liability of these persons, with the documents in Article 229 and subsequent articles of that Law or those made mandatory on the basis of the authority granted to our Ministry.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.