A lawyer stated that he sold the crop of a 14,500-tree olive grove inherited, together with his mother and three siblings, from his father who died in 2023, and that the producer receipt was issued in his name, and asked whether he must declare the income corresponding to his share.
The Administration's view:
- Farming on co-owned land is treated as a partnership and the business size is considered collectively. Since the number of trees exceeds the 4,500-tree threshold in Income Tax Law Article 54, the ordinary partnership's income is determined under the actual method; the heirs pay tax in proportion to their shares.
- The income of heirs who receive only a share of the crop without actually taking part in the activity is income from immovable property; that of those who farm the land themselves is agricultural income.
- If the heirs continue the business, liability for agricultural income under the actual method is established from the date of death; the agricultural income is included in the annual return together with the professional income.
The ruling is relevant to heirs acquiring agricultural land by inheritance.
Full text
Subject: Whether income from olive trees inherited from a father must be declared
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: a) Ruling request form No. 1281554 dated 14.03.2024. b) Ruling request form No. 1435756 dated 25.03.2024. c) Petition No. 1463946 dated 26.03.2024.
On examination of your ruling request forms and petition referred to above, stating that you practise as a lawyer, that your father, who died on 22/07/2023, was registered in the Farmer Registration System (ÇKS) before his death, had (14,500) olive trees on his agricultural land and was engaged in olive farming, that after your father's death you sold the crop of these olives to a company, that the olives sold were harvested from the trees and collected by the company, that the producer receipt issued by the company was issued in your name and payments were made to you, and that the agricultural land of your late father was inherited by your mother, your 3 (three) siblings and you, it is understood that our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the part of the total income belonging to the 5 (five) heirs that corresponds to your share should be declared on the annual income tax return.
Article 52 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
"Income from agricultural activity is agricultural income.
Agricultural activity means the production, hunting, keeping by hunters and breeders, transport, sale or other use of plants, forests, animals, fish and their products, on land, at sea, in lakes and rivers, by sowing, planting, care, production, raising and improvement, or by directly using nature.
...
Processing of products for their utilisation and as an adjunct to agricultural production is also within agricultural activity. However, if this operation takes place in an enterprise forming part of the same undertaking, for it to be deemed agricultural activity the enterprise must not be of the importance and extent of an industrial establishment and must confine its activity to the products of the undertaking of which it forms part.
...
Enterprises in which the above activities are carried out are called agricultural enterprises, individuals (including ordinary partnerships) operating these enterprises are called farmers, whether taxable or not, and materials produced as a result of these activities are called crops.
..."
Article 53 of the same Law provides:
"Agricultural income earned by farmers is taxed by withholding on their revenue under Article 94 of this Law. The income of farmers exceeding the business size limits in Article 54 and of farmers owning a combine harvester or a motor vehicle of this nature or more than two tractors up to ten years old is determined and taxed under the actual method (on a farm account basis or, if they wish, on a balance sheet basis). Farmers whose income is not taxed under the actual method do not file returns for this income. However, income from operating a combine harvester or a motor vehicle of this nature or more than two tractors up to ten years old belonging to the farmer but not included in the agricultural enterprise is taxed under the provisions on business income.
In applying this provision, for enterprises belonging to the spouse living with the head of the family and children under guardianship, and for enterprises held in partnership, the business size is considered collectively. In partnerships, the partnership relating to more than one enterprise or the enterprises being in separate places does not change the situation..."
Under that article, it is provided that in enterprises held in partnership the business size is considered collectively; that in partnerships, the partnership relating to more than one enterprise or the enterprises being in separate places does not change the situation; that in single enterprises listed in Article 52, even if the enterprise belongs to more than one partnership, the business size of these partnerships is considered by aggregation; that farmers whose own enterprise and partnerships each fall below the business size limit independently, but whose own enterprise and partnership shares together exceed that limit, are taxed under the actual method, while other partners whose shares together do not exceed the limits are taxed by withholding; and that sharecropping is deemed a partnership.
Furthermore, Article 54 of that Law sets the business size limits to be considered in a calendar year for determining agricultural income under the actual method, and the 16th group of paragraph (A) of the first paragraph of that article sets the business size limit for olive groves that have reached fruit-bearing age at (4,500) trees.
The last paragraph of Article 70 of that Law provides that the income of landowners who receive only a share of the crop without actually taking part in agricultural activity is deemed income from immovable property.
The first paragraph of Article 94 of the same Law lists those obliged to withhold tax on payments they make in cash or on account, and sub-paragraph (11) of that paragraph states that income tax must be withheld on payments for agricultural products purchased from farmers at 2% for animals and their products and land and water hunting products, 4% for other agricultural products, 1% for animals and their products and land and water hunting products purchased by registration on commodity exchanges, and 2% for other agricultural products purchased by registration on commodity exchanges.
On the other hand, although the number of olive trees belonging to your father exceeded the business size limit (4,500 trees) set in Article 54 of the Income Tax Law, examination of GİB Intranet records showed that your father … had no tax liability before the date of his death.
Furthermore, the second paragraph of Article 620 of Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 provides that a partnership not having the distinguishing characteristics of partnerships regulated by law is deemed an ordinary partnership, and Article 688 of Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 provides:
"In co-ownership, several persons own the whole of a thing that is not physically divided, in specific shares.
Unless otherwise determined, the shares are deemed equal.
Each co-owner has the rights and obligations of an owner with respect to its own share. The share may be transferred, pledged and attached by creditors."
As is understood from that provision, the characteristic of co-ownership is that the immovable is divided in a legal manner. In other words, the share amount is known but which part of the thing belongs to which person is not. Only each owner's share is known.
In this respect, whether arising from the Law or from other legal relations or dispositions, the activity of those farming land subject to co-ownership must be accepted as a partnership and the business size limit must be considered collectively.
In this context, whether the agricultural land left by your late father to your mother, your (3) three siblings and you is operated jointly by all the heirs forming the partnership, or part of it is operated by being given to others in partnership or on lease, does not change the form of the partnership, and since the business size limit set in Article 54 of the Income Tax Law has been exceeded for the olive farming on that land, the ordinary partnership's income will be determined under the actual method, but the heirs forming the partnership will pay tax in proportion to their shares.
Accordingly, provided the inheritance has not been renounced,
- the income of landowners who lease the agricultural land corresponding to their share in the ordinary partnership, receiving only a share of the crop without actually taking part in agricultural activity, must be determined under the provisions on income from immovable property,
- the income of landowners who operate the agricultural land corresponding to their share in the partnership in their own name, or by leasing the agricultural land corresponding to the shares of other partners and agricultural land belonging to third parties, must be determined under the provisions on agricultural income.
On the other hand, if the activity of the enterprise (agricultural land) passing to your mother, your 3 (three) siblings and you on the death of your father (the deceased) is continued by the heirs, the inheritance partnership must be accepted as operating as an ordinary partnership and tax liability for agricultural income under the actual method must be established for the heirs as of the date of death.
In that case, it goes without saying that the agricultural income you will earn from the ordinary partnership must be included in the annual income tax return you file for your professional activity.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.