TREN
Contact us

Economic Enterprise of an Exempt Cooperative with Non-Member Transactions: Separate Corporate Tax Liability, VAT Stays with the Cooperative; Ba-Bs and New-Generation Cash Register Duties

Tax Procedure · DocumentationEconomic Enterprise of an Exempt Cooperative with Non-Member Transactions: Separate Corporate Tax Liability, VAT Stays with the Cooperative; Ba-Bs and New-Generation Cash Register DutiesPrivate ruling · 23 July 2024
Rast note

A cooperative exempt from corporate tax that began non-member transactions and restaurant activity asked whether separate VAT liability must be opened for its economic enterprise, and about Ba-Bs notifications and cash registers.

The Administration's view:

  • Non-member transactions create a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative; corporate tax liability is established for it from the date of the non-member transaction and the exemption is not affected.
  • This rule concerns only corporate tax; all VAT-able transactions, member and non-member, continue to be declared under the cooperative's existing VAT liability.
  • An exempt cooperative does not submit Ba-Bs; but if corporate tax liability is established for the economic enterprise, the cooperative submits Ba-Bs covering the enterprise's transactions.
  • The economic enterprise must use New Generation Cash Registers; if documents are issued in the cooperative's name, the devices may be registered in the cooperative's name.

The ruling is relevant to corporate tax-exempt cooperatives engaging in non-member transactions.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Tax liability status of an economic enterprise belonging to a cooperative
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

….

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your cooperative, which has no non-member transactions and benefits from the corporate tax exemption, has VAT liability due to its member transactions, that from …. it began to engage in non-member transactions as well as member transactions, that it also leased premises for restaurant activity, and that due to these transactions corporate tax and provisional corporate tax liability was established for the economic enterprise formed attached to your cooperative, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether it is necessary to open VAT liability for the economic enterprise given that it will operate within the cooperative and at branches and your cooperative is also a VAT taxpayer, whether the economic enterprise will submit Ba-Bs notifications, and whether cash registers will be acquired in the name of the economic enterprise.

UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW:

Subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:

"Excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions on not distributing profit on capital, not giving shares of profit to the chairman and members of the board of directors, not distributing reserves to partners and doing business only with partners, and which actually comply with these provisions, and, in addition to these restrictions and conditions, building cooperatives that from formation until completion of construction do not include on their management and audit boards natural persons or representatives of legal persons undertaking the construction work in whole or in part, or persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or those in an employee-employer relationship with them, and whose building permit and land title are registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity. (Transactions of cooperatives with persons other than their partners and transactions with their partners on matters not included in the cooperative articles of association are "non-member" transactions. The disposal by cooperatives of fixtures, machinery, equipment, vehicles and similar depreciable economic assets allocated to their activity that have completed their economic life, and building cooperatives obtaining one workplace or residence for each share by giving their own land in return for flats, are not deemed non-member transactions. A separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to the non-member transactions of cooperatives. Cooperatives obtaining profits from their economic enterprises and from participating in the capital of another fully liable entity, and later distributing these profits to partners, does not affect the exemption. The procedures and principles for taxing profits from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.)"

The sub-section titled "4.13.1. Exemption conditions" of the section titled "4.13. Cooperatives" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:

"For cooperatives to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, their articles of association must contain provisions on:
- Not distributing profit on capital,
- Not giving shares of profit to the chairman and members of the board of directors,
- Not distributing reserves to partners,
- Doing business only with partners,
and these restrictions and conditions must actually be complied with.
Cooperatives that do not include these conditions in their articles of association or include them but do not comply with them in practice will not benefit from the exemption provisions."

The sub-section titled "4.13.3. Taxation of non-member transactions in cooperatives exempt from corporate tax" of the same Communiqué states:

"By the parenthetical provision added to subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of Law No. 5520 by Law No. 7061, effective from 1/1/2018, it was provided that a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity is deemed to arise due to non-member transactions of cooperatives exempt from corporate tax, that cooperatives obtaining profits from these economic enterprises and from participating in the capital of another fully liable entity and later distributing these profits to partners does not affect the exemption, and that the procedures and principles for taxing profits from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.
Thus, the exemption of cooperatives will not be affected by non-member transactions carried out from 1/1/2018; however, profits from these transactions will be subject to corporate tax at a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity. Therefore, the profits from non-member transactions of cooperatives meeting the other exemption conditions will be subject to corporate tax at a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity, and profits from member transactions will not be subject to corporate tax.
The necessary corporate tax liability will be established in the name of the economic enterprise deemed to arise attached to the cooperative legal entity in relation to non-member transactions.
On the other hand, the corporate tax liability records of cooperatives for which corporate tax liability was established before 1/1/2018 due to non-member transactions will be terminated as of 1/1/2018, provided they meet the other exemption conditions. Profits of these cooperatives from non-member transactions carried out from 1/1/2018 will be taxed by establishing corporate tax liability at a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.
Cooperatives exempt from corporate tax must monitor separately revenue, cost and expense items within and outside non-member transactions in determining the profit from non-member transactions and the corporate tax base, must not associate revenue, cost and expense items of non-member transactions with other transactions, and must record them in the books kept by the cooperative in a way that ensures this separation.
..."

According to these provisions and explanations, since your cooperative actually engages in non-member transactions, corporate tax liability must be established in the name of your economic enterprise deemed to arise attached to the cooperative legal entity from the date of the non-member transaction, and the profit from these transactions must be subjected to corporate tax.

UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:

Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT, and in the second paragraph of the same article, that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activity are determined under the Income Tax Law, and where the Income Tax Law is not clear, under the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of institutions belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, provincial special administrations, municipalities and villages and the unions they form, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations, and of revolving-fund institutions or other institutions belonging or subject to them, are subject to value added tax.

On the other hand, with the amendment made to subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 by Law No. 7061, the corporate tax liability records of cooperatives for which corporate tax liability was established before 1/1/2018 due to non-member transactions will be terminated as of 1/1/2018, provided they meet the other exemption conditions, and profits of these cooperatives from non-member transactions carried out from 1/1/2018 will be taxed by establishing corporate tax liability at a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity.

As understood from the above explanations, that regulation concerns corporate tax application and has no effect on your cooperative's VAT liability. Therefore, all transactions subject to VAT (member and non-member) must continue to be declared under your cooperative's liability.

UNDER THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:

Based on the authority granted to our Ministry by Articles 148, 149 and Repeated Article 257 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213, the procedures and principles to be followed regarding the obligation of taxpayers keeping books on the balance sheet basis to notify purchases of goods and services exceeding a certain threshold with the "Notification Form for Purchases of Goods and Services (Form Ba)" and sales of goods and services with the "Notification Form for Sales of Goods and Services (Form Bs)" were announced by Tax Procedure Law General Communiqués Nos. 350, 362, 381 and 396 respectively.

The procedures and principles and notification thresholds for fulfilling this obligation in monthly periods of 2010 and subsequent years are explained in Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 396; the Communiqué states:

- in item 1.1.1.: "Taxpayers switching from balance sheet basis to operating account basis will not submit notifications from the accounting period in which they switch to the operating account basis.",
- in item 1.1.2.: "Taxpayers exempt from corporate tax will not submit Ba-Bs notification forms from the accounting period in which they benefit from the exemption.",
- in item 1.1.8. (added by TPL GC No. 523): "Documents issued as electronic documents under the Tax Procedure Law will not be included in Form Ba and Form Bs notifications from the period for July 2021.",
- in item 1.2.2.: "The threshold to be applied to purchases and sales of goods and/or services of taxpayers for monthly periods of 2010 and subsequent years has been re-set at TL 5,000. Accordingly, purchases of goods and/or services of TL 5,000 or more excluding VAT from one person or entity will be notified with the "Notification Form for Purchases of Goods and Services (Form Ba)", and sales of goods and/or services of TL 5,000 or more excluding VAT to one person or entity in Table II of the "Notification Form for Sales of Goods and Services (Form Bs)". (Paragraph added by TPL GC No. 523) In determining the TL 5,000 threshold for purchase amounts from one person or entity and sale amounts to one person or entity, all documents issued electronically and on paper must be evaluated together. If the threshold is exceeded, only documents issued on paper will be included in the notifications.",
- in item 3.2.4. (amended by TPL GC No. 543): "Taxpayers obliged to submit notifications but whose purchases and/or sales are all below the specified threshold or consist of documents issued as electronic documents need not submit Form Ba and/or Form Bs notifications for the relevant period.",
- in item 4.1.: "Penal action will be applied under Repeated Article 355 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 to taxpayers who do not submit notification forms within the periods set in this Communiqué or make incomplete or misleading notifications."

According to the above explanations, if the cooperative is exempt from corporate tax, it has no obligation to submit Form Ba and Bs notifications from the accounting period in which it benefits from the exemption. However, if the cooperative, although exempt from corporate tax, has corporate tax liability established at a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative legal entity due to its non-member transactions, Form Ba and Bs notifications must be submitted by the cooperative covering the business and transactions of the economic enterprise.

On the other hand, if the cooperative is not exempt from corporate tax, it is obliged to submit Form Ba and Bs notifications from the period in which the exemption conditions are breached.

UNDER LAW NO. 3100:

The first paragraph of Article 1 of Law No. 3100 on the Obligation of Value Added Tax Payers to Use Cash Registers provides: "First and second class merchants selling goods to persons other than those reselling them as they are or after processing, or providing services to the same persons, are obliged to use cash registers under this Law."

On the other hand, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 426 introduced an obligation for first and second class merchants (making retail deliveries or providing services) selling goods to persons other than those reselling them as they are or after processing, or providing services to the same persons, to use "New Generation Cash Registers" (instead of the cash registers they are obliged to use under Law No. 3100 dated 6.12.1984) in documenting sales of goods or services for which they are not obliged to issue invoices under the Tax Procedure Law.

Accordingly, the economic enterprise established attached to cooperatives is obliged to use New Generation Cash Registers since its activity falls within that Law. However, if the documents to be issued under the Tax Procedure Law are issued in the name of the cooperative legal entity, the New Generation Cash Registers may also be registered in the name of the cooperative legal entity.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.