TREN
Contact us

Effect on corporate tax exemption of an expense contribution fee charged on membership transfer in an exempt cooperative

Corporate Income TaxEffect on corporate tax exemption of an expense contribution fee charged on membership transfer in an exempt cooperativePrivate ruling · 17 January 2024
Rast note

A cooperative exempt from corporate tax under CTL Art. 4/1-k asked whether charging a transfer fee as an expense contribution when members transfer their memberships affects its exemption.

The Administration's view:

  • If the transfer fee is not distributed to members but spent in line with the cooperative's purposes, the transaction is not a non-member transaction and does not affect the exemption.
  • Distributing the fees to members or to the chair and members of the board breaches the condition of "not distributing profit on capital"; corporate tax liability is established from the date of breach.

The ruling is relevant to cooperatives exempt from corporate tax.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether charging a transfer fee when members of an exempt cooperative transfer their memberships affects the corporate tax exemption
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Cooperative is exempt under Article 4/1-k of the Corporate Tax Law, our Administration's opinion is requested on whether charging a transfer fee, as an expense contribution, when members transfer their memberships affects your cooperative's corporate tax exemption.

Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists cooperatives among corporate taxpayers in the second paragraph of Article 2, and subparagraph (k) of Article 4/1 provides that, except consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions that profit is not distributed on capital, no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board, reserves are not distributed to members and business is done only with members, and which actually comply with these provisions, are exempt from corporate tax (Transactions of cooperatives with persons other than their members, and transactions with members on matters not in the articles of association, are "non-member" transactions. Disposal by cooperatives of fully depreciated fixtures, machinery, equipment, vehicles and similar depreciable assets allocated to their activity, and building cooperatives obtaining a workplace or dwelling for each share by giving their land in return for units, are not non-member transactions. A separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal personality is deemed formed due to non-member transactions. Earning income from their economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another full-liability corporation, and later distributing this income to members, does not affect the exemption. The procedures for taxing income from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.).

Section "4.13. Cooperatives" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 explains the exemption conditions in detail, and subsequent sections illustrate non-member transactions by type of cooperative; the Communiqué states:

- in section "4.13.1.1. Not distributing profit on capital": "Distribution of profit on capital is a feature of capital companies. If cooperatives distribute their profit to members according to their capital shares, there will be no difference between cooperatives and capital companies. Therefore, for a cooperative to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, its articles of association must contain a provision that profit is not distributed on capital and this provision must actually be complied with.",
- in section "4.13.1.4. Doing business only with members": "Since cooperatives aim to provide and protect certain economic interests of their members, especially needs relating to their profession and livelihood, their activity should normally be limited to members. Therefore, for a cooperative to benefit from the corporate tax exemption, its articles of association must contain a provision that business is done only with members and this provision must actually be complied with.
Non-member transactions cover not only transactions with non-members but also transactions with members on matters not in the articles of association.
...",
- in section "4.13.3. Taxation of non-member transactions in cooperatives exempt from corporate tax": "By the parenthetical provision added to Article 4/1-k of Law No. 5520 by Law No. 7061, effective from 1/1/2018, it is provided that a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal personality is deemed formed due to non-member transactions of exempt cooperatives, that earning income from these economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another full-liability corporation and later distributing it to members does not affect the exemption, and that the procedures for taxing income from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.
Thus, from 1/1/2018 the exemption of cooperatives will not be affected by non-member transactions; but income from these transactions will be subject to corporate tax within a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal personality. Therefore, income from non-member transactions of cooperatives meeting the other exemption conditions will be subject to corporate tax within the separate economic enterprise, while income from member transactions will not be subject to corporate tax.
Corporate tax liability will be established in the name of the economic enterprise deemed formed attached to the cooperative's legal personality for non-member transactions.
Furthermore, for cooperatives whose corporate tax liability was established before 1/1/2018 due to non-member transactions, provided they meet the other exemption conditions, their corporate tax liability records will be terminated as of 1/1/2018. Income from their non-member transactions from 1/1/2018 will be taxed by establishing corporate tax liability within a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal personality.
For determining income and the corporate tax base from non-member transactions, exempt cooperatives must track separately revenue, cost and expense items within and outside non-member transactions, not associate revenue, cost and expense items of non-member transactions with other transactions, and record them in the books kept by the cooperative so as to ensure this separation."
..."

Furthermore, Article 1 of Cooperatives Law No. 1163 provides that cooperatives are entities with variable membership and variable capital established by natural and legal persons to provide and protect certain economic interests of their members, especially needs relating to their profession or livelihood, through mutual assistance, solidarity and surety by their labour and financial contributions; and Article 17 provides that whether members leaving or expelled from the cooperative, or their heirs, have rights over the cooperative's assets and what these rights consist of are shown in the articles of association, and that these rights are calculated, excluding reserves, according to the balance sheet of the year the member leaves.

On the other hand, for a transaction carried out by a cooperative to be considered a member transaction, it must fall within the purpose of activity, in other words the field of business stated in the articles of association, and the business within the purpose of activity must be carried out exclusively with a cooperative member.

Under these provisions and explanations, if the transfer fee to be charged as an expense contribution when members transfer their memberships is not distributed to members but spent in line with the cooperative's purposes, this transaction will not be deemed a non-member transaction and will not affect your corporate tax exemption.

However, naturally, if the transfer fees collected are distributed to your members or the chair and members of the board, the exemption condition of "not distributing profit on capital" will be breached, and your corporate tax liability will have to be established as of the date this condition is breached.

Kindly be informed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.