A licensed payment institution, which calculates banking and insurance transactions tax (BSMV) on the 7% commission it charges customers, asked whether it can offset against the BSMV payable the BSMV the bank withholds and charges on the 5% commission it takes from the institution.
The Administration stated that the payment institution's BSMV base is the commission remaining in its favour after deducting cost items arising at the time of the transaction and clearly calculable (the commission passed to the bank). However, since the legislation contains no provision allowing BSMV charged to taxpayers to be deducted from BSMV calculated, the BSMV charged by the bank cannot be offset.
The ruling is relevant to payment and electronic money institutions.
Full text
Subject: Offsetting in banking and insurance transactions tax (BSMV)
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
TO … PAYMENT INSTITUTION SERVICES JOINT STOCK COMPANY
Reference: Your ruling request form dated … with document registration number ….
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that your company is a payment institution licensed under the relevant legislation, that you are a banking and insurance transactions tax (BSMV) taxpayer as a banker under Article 28 of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802, that within payment services you charge customers a 7 per cent commission and calculate BSMV on it, while banks charge your company a 5 per cent commission, withhold BSMV on it and debit your accounts, an opinion is requested on whether the deductible BSMV can be offset against the BSMV payable in the accounting records.
Article 3(1)(ü) of Law No. 6493 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions defines payment institutions as legal persons authorised under this Law to provide and carry out payment services, and Article 14(1) of the same Law provides that payment institutions wishing to operate in payment services may do so with permission from the Bank (Central Bank of the Republic of Türkiye).
Article 28 of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802 provides:
"Amounts received in cash or on account, under whatever name, in their own favour by banks and insurance companies due to all transactions they carry out in any manner whatsoever, except for transactions under Financial Leasing Law No. 3226 of 10/6/1985, are subject to banking and insurance transactions tax.
Amounts received in cash or on account, under whatever name, in their own favour by bankers due to banking transactions and services they carry out (including amounts remaining in favour of those who make it their profession to buy and sell securities for their own or others' account, intermediate in purchases and sales or undertake to pay debts in return for securities bought and sold, from these activities, and amounts received under names such as commission, fee or service charge on income and benefits provided on funds collected by those continuously engaged in collecting money to pay deposit interest or provide interest and similar benefits under other names) are also subject to banking transactions tax.
Those engaged in lending under Decree Law No. 90 and those carrying out any of the transactions and services specified in the second paragraph as their main business are deemed bankers for the purposes of this Law. A person engaging exclusively in buying and selling gold does not require being deemed a banker."
Article 30 of the Law, determining the taxpayer, provides that BSMV is paid by banks, bankers and insurance companies, and Article 31 provides that the base of this tax is the amount of the sums specified in Article 28.
On the subject, Article 5 of Expenditure Taxes General Communiqué Serial No. 91 states:
"(1) Since payment services carried out under Law No. 6493 essentially within the permission granted by the BRSA and subject to its supervision are among the banking transactions and services specified in Article 28(2) of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802, electronic money and payment institutions carrying out these transactions as their main business under paragraph 3 of that article become BSMV taxpayers as bankers.
(2) As a rule, the entire amount of commissions, fees etc. collected by electronic money and payment institutions for services provided to payment service users is taxed. A part of the commission being transferred to an institution resident abroad or in Türkiye has no effect on the BSMV base.
(3) In payment services, where there is a commission amount calculated by electronic money and payment institutions in direct connection with the transaction and transferred per transaction to other taxpayers, this amount may be taken into account as a transaction cost in calculating the amount received in their favour. However, cost items not arising at the time of the transaction, or arising at the time of the transaction but whose amount cannot be clearly calculated, are not taken into account in calculating the amount received in their favour."
Furthermore, the third section of that Communiqué, headed "Taxation of Payment Services", contains explanations and examples on the taxation of various payment services.
Accordingly, the BSMV base for the payment services provided by your company is the commission remaining in your favour after deducting from the commission received for the service the cost items arising at the time of the transaction and whose amount can be clearly calculated (the commission transferred to the bank), and BSMV must be calculated on this amount. In this case, the bank must naturally also calculate BSMV on the commission it receives in its own favour.
However, since current BSMV legislation contains no provision allowing BSMV amounts charged to taxpayers to be deducted from the BSMV they calculate, it is not possible to offset the BSMV amounts calculated by banks on the commissions they receive in their own favour and charged to your company against the BSMV calculated by your company on commissions received in its favour for the payment services it provides.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.