TREN
Contact us

Property Converted into a School and Donated: Donation Protocol Is Stamp Duty-Exempt, Expenditures Are Deductible Under CTL 10/1-ç, but Renovation Is Outside the VAT 13/k Exemption

Stamp Duty · ExemptionsProperty Converted into a School and Donated: Donation Protocol Is Stamp Duty-Exempt, Expenditures Are Deductible Under CTL 10/1-ç, but Renovation Is Outside the VAT 13/k ExemptionPrivate ruling · 3 June 2024
Rast note

A company that signed a protocol to convert immovables not having the character of a school building into a primary school building by renovation, maintenance and repair and to donate it to the National Education Directorate, and that drew up a construction contract with a contractor, asked about stamp duty on the contracts and the corporate tax and VAT treatment of the expenditures.

The Administration's view:

  • Stamp duty: the protocol drawn up with the primary education administration for donation is exempt under SDL Table (2) IV/55; the construction contract with the contractor containing a price is not covered and is subject to proportional stamp duty under Table (1) I/A-1.
  • Corporate tax: the whole of the expenditures for converting the immovable into a primary school building may be deducted under CTL 10/1-ç from corporate income of the year of expenditure; any part not deductible due to insufficient income cannot be carried forward.
  • VAT: the VATL 13/k exemption covers deliveries and services for constructing a school; expenditures for converting an existing immovable into a school by renovation, maintenance and repair cannot benefit from it.

The ruling is relevant to companies donating schools or similar facilities to public administrations.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Stamp duty, VAT and corporate tax treatment of expenditures on a school to be donated
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that a donation protocol was signed under "…" for converting immovables belonging to … into a primary school building and transferring it to …, and that a protocol was drawn up with a contractor firm for carrying out that work, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the contracts to be drawn up under this donation are exempt from stamp duty, and on the treatment of the expenditures made under the donation under VAT and corporate tax legislation.

1) IN TERMS OF STAMP DUTY:

Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides in Article 1 that the papers listed in Table (1) annexed to the Law are subject to stamp duty; in Article 3 that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the papers, and that stamp duty on papers relating to transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons; in Article 8 that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages, and that economic enterprises attached to these offices with separate legal personality are not deemed official offices; and in Article 4 that, to determine the tax to which a paper is subject, the nature of the paper is examined and the tax in the table is found accordingly; that in determining the nature of papers, for those whose form is specified in laws their names in the laws are considered and for others the provision and meaning contained in the writing on them; and that if a paper whose nature is to be determined refers to another paper, tax is levied according to the nature it acquires under the provisions of the referenced paper.

Paragraph A/1 of Section "I. Papers relating to contracts" of Table (1) annexed to the same Law provides that contracts, undertakings and assignments containing a specific amount of money are subject to proportional stamp duty.

Paragraph (55) of Section "IV-Papers relating to commercial and civil matters" of Table (2) annexed to that Law, added by Article 54 of Law No. 7338 and effective 26/10/2021, provides that papers drawn up between the relevant administration and donors relating to donations to general and special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages are exempt from stamp duty.

In this framework, examination of your ruling request form and its annexes shows that the paper dated …/…/2022 titled "Protocol on the Transfer to the National Education Directorate, to Be Opened as a Primary School, of the School Building Built on the Land in … Block … and … Parcels, … Neighbourhood, … District" was drawn up for donation purposes and that one of its parties is the primary education administration; and that the paper titled "Construction Contract" drawn up on …/…/2022 between … Ltd. Şti. and … Ltd. Şti. was drawn up for the Construction and Repair Work of the … 12-Classroom Philanthropist Primary School and includes the price of the work.

Accordingly, the paper dated …/…/2022 titled "Protocol on the Transfer to the National Education Directorate, to Be Opened as a Primary School, of the School Building Built on the Land in … Block … and … Parcels, … Neighbourhood, … District" may be exempted from stamp duty under paragraph IV/55 of Table (2) annexed to Law No. 488.

On the other hand, since the paper titled "Construction Contract" drawn up on … between … cannot be considered within that paragraph, that paper must be subject to proportional stamp duty under paragraph I/A-1 of Table (1) annexed to Law No. 488.

2) IN TERMS OF CORPORATE TAX:

Article 10 titled "Other deductions" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:

"(1) In determining the corporate tax base, provided they are shown separately on the corporate tax return, the following deductions are made in order from corporate income:
...
c) The part, up to 5% of that year's corporate income, of the total donations and aid made against receipt to general and special budget public administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages, foundations granted tax exemption by the President, associations working for the public benefit, and institutions and organisations engaged in scientific research and development activity.
ç) The whole of expenditures made for the construction of schools, health facilities, student dormitories with a capacity of not less than 100 beds (50 beds in priority development regions), nurseries, orphanages, nursing homes and care and rehabilitation centres donated to the public institutions and organisations listed in subparagraph (c), places of worship to be built subject to the permission and supervision of civil administrators, facilities providing non-formal religious education under the supervision of the Presidency of Religious Affairs, and youth centres and youth and scouting camps of the Ministry of Youth and Sports, or all kinds of donations and aid made to these organisations for the construction of these facilities, and all kinds of cash and in-kind donations and aid made for existing facilities to continue their activities.
...
(2) Where donations and aid are not made in cash, the cost or recorded value of the asset or right donated or forming the subject of aid, or if this value does not exist, the value to be determined by assessment commissions under the Tax Procedure Law, is taken as basis."

In this regard, section 10.3.2. of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 contains the necessary explanations on donations and aid, and section "10.3.2.2.4 Documentation of Donations and Aid" of that Communiqué states:

"For in-kind or cash donations and aid to be taken into account as a deduction by corporate taxpayers, it is necessary and sufficient that they are made against receipt.
Where in-kind donations and aid are donated by withdrawing them from the business's assets or stock, it is sufficient that taxpayers issue an invoice for the values they withdraw from the business and donate, and that an annotation stating that the values in the invoice were received as donation or aid by the relevant public institution and organisation is placed on the back of the invoice and signed by authorised persons.
Where in-kind values are purchased from outside by taxpayers and donated to a public institution and organisation, it is sufficient that a delivery document is issued for the values to be received by this institution and organisation, and the document must state the value, type and quantity of the donated asset in a way that leaves no room for doubt. Also, the backs of the invoices issued for the donated values will bear the signatures of the officials of the relevant public institutions and organisations within the explanations above.
Cash donations can be deducted provided they are documented by a receipt issued by the organisations accepting the donation or by bank receipts showing deposit into accounts opened at banks for this purpose...."

Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, the whole of the expenditures you made under the protocol with … for converting an immovable that does not have the character of a school building into a primary school building by renovation, maintenance and repair may be deducted in determining corporate income for the year in which the expenditure is made.

Also, it goes without saying that the part that cannot be deducted because the activity results in a loss or income is insufficient in the period in which the donation and aid are made cannot be deducted in later years or carried forward as a loss.

3) IN TERMS OF VALUE ADDED TAX:

Under subparagraph (k) added to the first paragraph of Article 13 of Law No. 3065, deliveries and services made to those who will donate for the construction of schools, health facilities, student dormitories with a capacity of not less than one hundred beds (fifty beds in priority development regions), nurseries, orphanages, nursing homes, care and rehabilitation centres, places of worship subject to the permission and supervision of civil administrators, facilities providing non-formal religious education under the supervision of the Presidency of Religious Affairs, and youth centres and youth and scouting camps of the Ministry of Youth and Sports, to be donated to general and special budget public administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages, are exempt from VAT.

On the other hand, sub-heading "15.1.1. Facilities within the Exemption" of section "15.1. Scope of the Exemption" of the VAT Implementation General Communiqué states:

"The exemption covers deliveries of goods and performances of services relating to the construction of the following facilities to be donated to general and special budget public administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages:
- School,
- Health facility,
- Student dormitory with a capacity of not less than one hundred beds (fifty beds in priority development regions),
- Nursery,
- Orphanage,
- Nursing home,
- Care and rehabilitation centre,
- Places of worship subject to the permission and supervision of civil administrators,
- Facilities providing non-formal religious education under the supervision of the Presidency of Religious Affairs,
- Youth centres of the Ministry of Youth and Sports,
- Youth and scouting camps
This exemption cannot be used for deliveries and services relating to the construction of facilities donated to those other than general and special budget public administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages, or of facilities donated to them but not among those listed above.
The term "school" in the regulation should be understood as the basic units in which education and training services are provided directly, and guidance and research centres, vocational training centres, job training centres, vocational and technical education centres and evening art schools are also considered within this scope.
...."

Section "15.1.3. Transactions within the Exemption" states:

"The exemption covers deliveries and services made to those who will donate due to the construction of the facilities listed in section (II/B-15.1.1.) of the Communiqué to be donated to general and special budget public administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages. Deliveries and services for renovation, maintenance and repair of these facilities are not within the exemption.
..."

Accordingly, in the activity of converting an immovable that does not have the character of a school building into a primary school building by renovation, maintenance and repair and donating it under the protocol with …, the expenditures made for converting that immovable are considered within renovation, maintenance and repair of the building and cannot be treated as exempt under Article 13/k of the VAT Law.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.