TREN
Contact us

A Plot Allocation Right in an Organised Industrial Zone Held Under a Parcel Allocation Certificate and Not Registered in the Land Registry Cannot Be Subject to Partial Division

Corporate Income Tax · Mergers, demergers and transfersA Plot Allocation Right in an Organised Industrial Zone Held Under a Parcel Allocation Certificate and Not Registered in the Land Registry Cannot Be Subject to Partial DivisionPrivate ruling · 10 June 2024
Rast note

A company that signed a plot allocation agreement in an organised industrial zone, received a parcel allocation certificate and paid part of the price asked whether the plot can be subject to partial division under CTL 19/3-b.

The Administration's view:

  • Under Article 18 of the OIZ Law, allocated plots cannot be sold, transferred or assigned before the debt is fully paid and the facility starts production.
  • The plot allocation right arises from the allocation agreement between the OIZ and the company; it has no land registry record and is therefore not real estate or a registered real right under the Civil Code.
  • Therefore the parcel allocation certificate cannot be subject to partial division (in addition, Law No. 7456 removed stand-alone immovables from partial division as of 01/01/2024).

The ruling is relevant to companies with allocated plots in OIZs planning restructurings.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether a plot held under a parcel allocation certificate can be subject to partial division.
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

….

In the ruling request form and its annex referred to above, stating that:

- a plot allocation agreement was drawn up between you as a participant company and ….,
- based on that agreement, parcel allocation certificate dated …. and numbered ….. was given to your company,
- payment of ….. was envisaged for the allocated plot-type immovable, 18 instalments of this price were paid and 6 instalments remain,

our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the plot with the parcel allocation certificate can be subject to partial division under subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph of Article 19 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520.

Subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph of Article 19 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, before its amendment by Article 20 of Law No. 7456, provides:

"Partial division: The transfer by a fully liable capital company, or the workplace or permanent representative in Turkey of a foreign entity in the nature of a capital company, of immovables in its balance sheet and participation shares held for at least two full years, or one or more of the production or service enterprises it owns, at their book values as contribution in kind to an existing or newly established fully liable capital company is deemed a partial division in the application of this Law. However, in transferring production or service enterprises, it is mandatory to transfer all assets and liabilities necessary for the continuation of the activity in a way that preserves business integrity. In partial division, the shares of the acquiring company obtained in return for the assets transferred may remain in the transferring company or be given directly to its partners. In the transfer of immovables and participation shares under this subparagraph, if the shares of the acquiring company are given to the partners of the transferring company, the debts relating to the immovables and participation shares transferred must also be transferred."

By Article 20 of Law No. 7456, immovables were removed from the application of that article, and the effective date of this amendment was set as 01/01/2024 in Article 30 of Law No. 7456.

The third paragraph of Article 20 of the Corporate Tax Law provides: "Profits arising from transactions in subparagraphs (b) and (c) of the third paragraph of Article 19 of this Law are not calculated or taxed. In partial division transactions carried out under subparagraph (b) of the third paragraph of Article 19, entities taking over the assets of the divided entity are jointly and severally liable, limited to the arm's length value of the assets they take over, for the tax debts of the divided entity accrued and to accrue up to the date of division."

In addition, detailed explanations on the matter are given in the section titled "19.2.2. Partial division" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1.

Article 704 of Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 lists the subject of immovable ownership as:

- Land,
- Independent and permanent rights registered on a separate page of the land register,
- Independent units registered in the condominium register,

and under Article 998 of the Code, land, independent and permanent rights over immovables and independent units subject to condominium ownership can be registered in the land register as immovables. Again under the same article, one of the conditions for independent and permanent rights over immovables to be registered as immovables in the land register is that the right is indefinite or for at least 30 years.

On the other hand, Article 18 titled "Plot allocations" of Organised Industrial Zones Law No. 4562 provides: "... Plots allocated or sold to participants cannot be used in any way outside the purpose of allocation. These plots cannot be sold, transferred or assigned by participants and their heirs before the entire debt is paid and the facility starts production. This is annotated in the land register. Where plot allocation and sale are made to participants in company status, the Ministry is authorised to take measures to prevent the sale of the plot and the transfer of ownership through speculative transactions before the debt is paid and the facility starts production...."

Article 58 titled "Issuing title deeds" of the Organised Industrial Zones Implementing Regulation, which contains detailed explanations on the matter, states that in Organised Industrial Zones, among participants allocated industrial parcels, unencumbered title deeds will be issued to those paying the allocation price in a lump sum or submitting a letter of guarantee for the remaining debt of the allocation price and a notarised undertaking stating that they will participate without objection in plot prices to be finally determined by the Organised Industrial Zone and other investments to be made, without a buy-back right annotation for those starting production, and with a buy-back right annotation for those whose facility has not started production, provided they obtain a building occupancy permit.

According to these provisions and explanations, companies allocated plots in Organised Industrial Zones cannot in any way sell, transfer or assign these plots before the facility starts production. In this respect, a title deed may be given to a company allocated a plot in an Organised Industrial Zone before the facility starts production, but a "buy-back" annotation is placed on it. This annotation aims to prevent the participant from transferring, selling and assigning that plot allocation right before the facility starts production.

On the other hand, plots in Organised Industrial Zones are first allocated to plot holders. That plot allocation takes place by signing a "Plot Allocation Agreement" made between the Organised Industrial Zone management and the company and prepared by ….. Therefore, for companies holding plots in an Organised Industrial Zone, the "plot allocation right" is a right arising from that "Plot Allocation Agreement". It has no record on the title deed and therefore does not have the character of real estate.

Accordingly, since the plot allocation right is not real estate or a real right registered in the land register under the Turkish Civil Code, it is not possible to subject that parcel allocation certificate to partial division.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.