TREN
Contact us

Free-Place and Scholarship Students at Private Schools: Revenue at Arm's-Length Value Above the Statutory Rate, Invoicing and VAT

VAT · ExemptionsFree-Place and Scholarship Students at Private Schools: Revenue at Arm's-Length Value Above the Statutory Rate, Invoicing and VATPrivate ruling · 29 July 2025
Rast note

A private educational institution subject to Law No. 5580 asked about the documentation, corporate tax and VAT treatment where it teaches free-place students beyond the 10% ceiling in the regulation and grants full or partial scholarships.

The Administration's view:

  • Corporate tax: Amounts not collected for free-place/scholarship students within the statutory rate are not recorded as revenue; for the part exceeding the rate, revenue is recorded at arm's-length (emsal) value. These amounts may be deducted as marketing and advertising expenses if the students are not related to the institution and were selected on merit criteria. Scholarship spending in the form of stationery and allowances may also be expensed.
  • Documentation: For services requiring neither revenue nor VAT, a zero-value invoice annotated "Free-place/scholarship student" is issued; for those requiring them, an invoice at arm's-length value under Tax Procedure Law Article 267; for partial scholarships, an invoice showing the discount/scholarship amount and the annotation. Stationery and allowance payments can be supported by expense vouchers or by bank/payment institution/PTT documents.
  • VAT: Free education not exceeding 10% of capacity is exempt under VAT Law Article 17/2-b and input VAT is deductible; VAT is calculated on the part exceeding the rate. Discounts given to other students after the quota is filled, if in line with commercial practice, are excluded from the VAT base under Article 25/a.

The ruling is relevant to private schools and private educational institutions.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Scholarship discounts
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: …

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that you operate under Private Educational Institutions Law No. 5580 and teach free-place students under the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Educational Institutions, our Directorate's evaluation is requested of how documentation should be arranged where you teach more free-place students than the regulatory ceiling of 10% and grant 100% or partial scholarships as required by the Regulation, and of the matter for value added tax and corporate tax purposes.

Evaluation with Regard to the Corporate Tax Law:

Article 13 of Private Educational Institutions Law No. 5580 provides that private educational institutions defined in the Law are obliged to teach free-place students amounting to not less than three percent of the number of students enrolled, that the Ministry may increase this rate up to ten percent, that the procedures and principles on the percentage, selection and admission conditions of free-place students are determined by regulation, that private educational institutions may also grant scholarships, and that the procedures and principles for granting scholarships are also determined by regulation.

Under this provision, Articles 57 to 63 of the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Educational Institutions, published in Official Gazette No. 28239 dated 20.03.2012, contain explanations on students and trainees studying free of charge or on scholarships. Article 63 of that Regulation states that in schools, scholarships are given to students in the form of covering tuition and stationery costs, an allowance at least equal to the minimum scholarship set by the Ministry of National Education for public school students, and similar; and that institutions other than schools may give scholarships to students or trainees in the form of covering tuition and stationery costs, an allowance at least equal to the minimum scholarship set by the Ministry for public school students, and similar.

Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income earned by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.

Article 40 of Income Tax Law No. 193, headed "Deductible Expenses", lists the expenses deductible in determining net income, and sub-paragraph (1) of its first paragraph provides that general expenses incurred to earn and maintain commercial income are deducted in determining net income.

In commercial income, earning is based on the accrual principle. Considering this principle, unless there is a specific rule, an income or expense item must be taken into account in the income of the period in which it becomes final in nature and amount.

Under these provisions and explanations, since the services provided by your economic enterprise are within commercial activity, the principles and provisions on determining commercial income will apply. Since earning income in commercial income is based on the accrual principle, the amount to be calculated on the basis of arm's-length value must be included in corporate income as an element of commercial income, even if all or part of the tuition is not collected from students studying free of charge or on scholarship at your economic enterprise.

In this context, limited to the rate set under the Private Educational Institutions Law and the said Regulation, where all or part of the tuition of free-place or scholarship students is covered, there is no need to record revenue for the uncollected amounts relating to free-place or scholarship students. However, it goes without saying that revenue will be recorded at arm's-length value for uncollected amounts relating to free-place or scholarship students above the rate set in the relevant legislation.

On the other hand, it has been considered that educating successful students at the institution and announcing their achievements contributes to promoting the institution and increases demand, and that expenses incurred in this context may therefore be treated as marketing and advertising expenses.

In this context, amounts not collected from free-place or scholarship students above the rate set in the relevant legislation but recorded as revenue may be deducted from corporate income as marketing and advertising expenses, provided that the students are not related persons of the institution and have been selected according to specific merit criteria.

In addition, where the stationery costs of scholarship or free-place students are covered and/or scholarships are given in the form of an allowance at least equal to the minimum scholarship set by the Ministry of National Education for public school students and similar, the amounts spent in this context may be taken into account as expenses.

Evaluation with Regard to the Tax Procedure Law:

Article 227 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213, headed "Evidentiary papers", provides: "Unless otherwise provided in this law, records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties must be documented." These records must be documented with the documents regulated in Article 229 and the following articles of the same Law or made mandatory on the basis of the authority given to our Ministry.

In this context, the said Law provides:

- in paragraph (B) of Article 3,

"B) Proof: In taxation, the taxable event and the real nature of the transactions relating to it are essential.
The taxable event and the real nature of the transactions relating to it may be proven by all kinds of evidence except oath. However, witness statements not naturally and clearly related to the taxable event cannot be used as evidence.
Where a situation is claimed that does not conform to economic, commercial and technical requirements or is not normal and customary given the nature of the event, the burden of proof lies with the party making the claim.",

- in Article 229, "An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work, showing the amount the customer owes in return for the goods sold or the work done.",

- in Article 231,

"The following rules are observed in issuing an invoice:
...
The invoice is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised, taking into account the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, the field of activity, the sector or the type of tax liability separately or together, to reduce this period or to require the invoice to be issued at the moment the goods are delivered or the service is performed. Invoices not issued within these periods are deemed never to have been issued.
...",

- in Article 232,

"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method, and farmers required to keep books are required to give invoices for the goods they sell or the work they do to:
1. First and second class merchants;
2. Self-employed professionals;
3. Merchants whose income is determined under the simple method;
4. Farmers required to keep books;
5. Tax-exempt tradesmen,
and these are required to request and receive invoices.
...",

- in Article 234,

"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method, and self-employed professionals and farmers required to keep books issue an expense voucher, to be signed by the person doing the work or selling the goods, for work they have done by, or goods they buy from, persons not required to issue documents under this Law (except goods bought from farmers not taxed under the actual method). An expense voucher issued for tax-exempt tradesmen has the effect of an invoice given by these persons.
The expense voucher contains the nature of the work, the type and kind, quantity and price of the goods, the wage for the work, the names and surnames (titles for legal entities) and addresses of the person commissioning and the person doing the work, or of the buyer and seller of the goods, and the date, and is drawn up in two copies, one of which is given to the person doing the work or selling the goods.
Expense vouchers are numbered consecutively by series and serial number.
An expense voucher is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. An expense voucher not issued within this period is deemed never to have been issued.
Provided they contain the information specified in the second paragraph;
a) Where the price of the goods or service is paid to the seller within the period specified in the fourth paragraph through a bank defined in Banking Law No. 5411 dated 19/10/2005, payment institutions authorised under Law No. 6493 dated 20/6/2013, or Posta ve Telgraf Teşkilatı Anonim Şirketi established under Postal Services Law No. 6475 dated 9/5/2013, documents issued by these institutions,
b) On return of goods bought under Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 dated 7/11/2013 to those required to issue expense vouchers, where amounts to be refunded under Law No. 6502 are refunded through the institutions in sub-paragraph (a), documents issued by these institutions,
c) Documents issued by public institutions and organisations not required to issue documents under this Law, within their applicable legislation, for work they do or goods they sell, replace the expense voucher.
The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this article."

- in Article 267,

"Arm's-length value is the value that goods with no actual price, or whose actual price is unknown or cannot be determined correctly, would have by comparison with similar goods if sold on the valuation date.
Arm's-length value is determined in order according to the following principles:
First: (Average price basis) ...
Second: (Cost basis) ...
Third: (Assessment basis) ..."

In this context, except for transactions for which our Ministry has set a different period, the invoice must be issued within at most seven days from the delivery of goods and/or performance of the service. Accordingly, where it is customary or agreed to perform the service in parts, the invoice for each part must be issued within at most seven days from the performance of that part, regardless of whether the price has been collected; therefore, for education services lasting more than one tax period, an invoice must be issued within at most seven days from the end of each VAT tax period, consisting of the monthly periods of the calendar year.

Accordingly, of the education services subject to your application:

- for education services for which no revenue needs to be recorded for corporate tax and no VAT needs to be calculated, an invoice with a service price of zero must be issued, with the annotation "Free-place/scholarship student" on the invoices issued,

- for education services for which revenue must be recorded for corporate tax and/or VAT must be calculated, an invoice must be issued at arm's-length value under Article 267 of the Tax Procedure Law, with an explanation of the nature of the transaction also shown on the invoice,

- for education services with a partial scholarship, an invoice must be issued on the consideration for the transaction, also showing the discount/partial scholarship amount and the annotation "Partial-scholarship student".

On the other hand, records relating to scholarship payments made to students for covering stationery costs, allowances and similar purposes for scholarship/free-place students can be documented by issuing expense vouchers or, where paid through a bank, payment institutions authorised under Law No. 6493 or PTT A.Ş., with documents issued by these institutions (receipts, slips, etc.).

Evaluation with Regard to the Value Added Tax Law:

Article 17/2-b of the VAT Law, headed "Social and Military Exemptions and Other Exemptions", provides that free education services provided by private schools subject to Law No. 5580 dated 08/02/2007, not exceeding 10% of their capacity in the relevant period, and, at universities and colleges, not exceeding 50%, are exempt from value added tax.

The same Law provides in Article 25/a that discounts in amounts consistent with commercial practice shown on invoices and similar documents in supply and service transactions are not included in the VAT base, and in Article 29/1-a that taxpayers may, unless otherwise provided in this Law, deduct from the value added tax calculated on their taxable transactions the value added tax shown on invoices and similar documents issued for supplies and services made to them in connection with their activities, in the tax period in which the relevant documents are recorded in the legal books, provided the calendar year in which the taxable event occurred is not exceeded.

On the other hand, Article 30/a of the Law provides that value added tax shown on purchase documents relating to the supply of goods and services not subject to tax or exempt from tax (except transactions exempted from value added tax under sub-paragraphs (b), (c) and (d) of paragraph (2) and sub-paragraphs (ı) and (ö) of paragraph (4) of Article 17 of this Law), or included in the costs of these goods and services, cannot be deducted; and Article 33 provides that where transactions with and without a right of deduction are carried out together, only the part of the VAT shown on invoices and similar documents attributable to transactions with a right of deduction may be deducted.

The sub-heading "2.2. Exemption for Free Education Services Provided by Private Schools and Universities and Free Dormitory Services Provided by Student Dormitories" of section (II/F) headed "F. Social and Military Exemptions and Other Exemptions" of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:

"Article (17/2-b) of Law No. 3065 provides that free education services provided not exceeding
- (10%) of their capacity in the relevant period for free education services provided by private schools subject to Law No. 5580 dated 8/2/2007,
- (10%) of their capacity in the relevant period for free dormitory services provided by student dormitories established under the Law Supplementing the Law on Higher Education Student Dormitories and Canteens No. 5661 dated 24/3/1950 and the Law on the Organisation and Duties of the Ministry of National Education No. 3797 dated 30/4/1992,
- (50%) at universities and colleges,
are exempt from VAT. From 1/1/2019, VAT incurred on transactions under this exemption may be deducted, but VAT that cannot be offset by deduction is not refunded."

Accordingly:

- No VAT will be calculated for free education services provided not exceeding 10% of capacity in the relevant period under Article 17/2-b of the VAT Law, and the VAT incurred may be deducted under Article 30/a of the Law.

- Since free education services are limited to 10% of capacity, it goes without saying that VAT will be calculated for these services where free-place students are taught above the set rate.

- Discounts given by your school to other students after the 10% scholarship quota has been filled may, if consistent with commercial practice, be excluded from the VAT base under Article 25/a of the VAT Law.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.