TREN
Contact us

Refund Receivable From Long-Term Construction Withholding of a Sole Proprietorship Converted Into a Company Cannot Be Offset Against Company Debts Until It Reaches the Cash Refund Stage

Personal Income Tax · Tax residencyRefund Receivable From Long-Term Construction Withholding of a Sole Proprietorship Converted Into a Company Cannot Be Offset Against Company Debts Until It Reaches the Cash Refund StagePrivate ruling · 9 October 2024
Rast note

The owner of a sole proprietorship engaged in long-term construction works, with a refund receivable arising from withholding on progress payments, stated that he converted the business into a joint stock company and asked whether this refund receivable can be offset against the company's tax debts.

The Administration's view:

  • The sole proprietorship ends on the date the conversion decision is registered in the trade registry; the long-term work is also deemed completed for the sole proprietorship.
  • Accounts are closed up to this date, the profit or loss of the long-term work is determined and declared on the annual return, and taxes withheld from progress payments are credited against the tax calculated.
  • A refund receivable arising after the credit cannot be offset directly against the company's tax debts; however, if it reaches the cash refund stage under Income Tax General Communiqué No. 252, it can be offset against the company's tax debts.

The ruling is relevant to long-term construction contractors converting a sole proprietorship into a company.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Request to offset a sole proprietorship's refund receivable from long-term construction works against the debts of a joint stock company formed by conversion
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: Your ruling request dated 19.09.2022.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you have had income tax liability since 19/8/2020 for the activities of constructing non-residential and residential buildings, that you have a refund receivable due to income tax withheld from progress payments made to you within construction and repair work spanning more than one calendar year carried out within that activity, and that on 21/9/2021 you converted your sole proprietorship with all its assets and liabilities into ... İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş., you request an opinion on whether these refund amounts can be offset against the tax debts of ... İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş.

Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

- in Article 42: "In construction (stripping works are also deemed construction work) and repair works spanning more than one calendar year, profit or loss is determined definitively in the year the work ends, and all of it is deemed income of that year and shown in that year's return."

- in Article 44: "In construction and repair works, in cases subject to the provisional and final acceptance procedure, the date the minutes showing the provisional acceptance was made are approved by the administration; in other cases, the date the work was actually completed or actually abandoned, is accepted as the completion date. Expenses incurred and revenue obtained under whatever name relating to these works after the completion date are taken into account in determining the profit or loss of the year in which these expenses are incurred or the revenue obtained."

In addition, the first paragraph of Article 94 of that Law provides that the persons and organisations listed will withhold tax on the payments listed in subparagraphs of the same article when they make them, and subparagraph (3) of the same article provides for income tax withholding by the responsible parties on the entitlement amounts paid to those carrying out works within Article 42 of this Law (including institutions) for such works; the withholding rate applied as 3% was set at 5% by Presidential Decision No. 3491 published in Official Gazette No. 31385 dated 04/02/2021.

On the other hand, Article 121 of that Law provides:

"Taxes withheld under this law from earnings and revenues included in the income shown in the annual return are credited against the Income Tax calculated on the return.
Where the amount credited exceeds the Income Tax, the difference is notified to the taxpayer by the tax office and refunded to him upon his application within one year from the date of notification.
The Ministry of Finance is authorised to have the refund made by offset or in cash, to make it subject to an audit report, a sworn financial advisor report or a guarantee, and to determine the documents required for the refund.
This authority may be used separately according to types of income, forms of refund, and the legal status of the income earner or payer, as well as within certain limits.
Refund by offset is made as of the date the annual income tax return is filed, provided all required documents are completed. In additional or ex officio assessments, the offset is made based on the date the petition and annexes for the offset request are entered completely in the tax office records. No correction is made for collections made during the completion of required documents.
Taxes withheld under the second paragraph of Article 94 from payments made to controlled foreign corporations may be credited against the income tax to be calculated on the controlled foreign corporation profit declared on the annual return in Turkey. The tax to be credited cannot exceed the income tax corresponding to the controlled foreign corporation's income arising from these payments."

On the other hand, Article 161 titled "Definition of Ceasing Business" of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides: "The complete stopping and ending of transactions requiring tax liability means ceasing business."

In addition, the section titled "1. Offset and Refund of Taxes Withheld" of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 252 states:

"...
1.3. Offset Against Other Tax Debts or Cash Refund
1.3.1. Refund by Offset
Requests to offset the portion of withheld taxes remaining after credits on the annual return against other tax debts are fulfilled regardless of the amount, without requiring an audit report or guarantee.
For this, the offset request must be made with the refund request petition (1A) annexed to Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué (Serial No: 429) published in Official Gazette No. 28791 dated 10/10/2013. Provided the refund request petition (1A) for the offset has been submitted, taxpayers' offset requests for their tax debts are fulfilled based on the date the annual return was filed.
...
Taxpayers may, if they wish, request a refund by offset against tax debts for which ordinary partnerships or general partnerships in which they are partners are jointly and severally liable. For these requests to be fulfilled, the taxpayer entitled to the refund must have no tax debt that has become due, and the offset petition must state for which period debts of the ordinary or general partnership the offset is requested. The date the refund request petition (1A) for the offset is entered in the tax office records is taken as the basis.
...
1.3.2. Cash Refund
...
Offset of a receivable that has reached the cash refund stage against the tax debts of third parties may be requested. The "List Relating to Requests to Offset Against the Tax Debts of Third Persons/Institutions" annexed to Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué (Serial No: 429) is attached to the refund request petition (1A) to be given for this offset. Offset requests made in this way are fulfilled as of the date the correction slip is approved.
..."

Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, it must be accepted that your sole proprietorship ended as of the date the decision on the conversion into a capital company was registered in the trade registry, and that the said long-term construction and repair work ended in respect of your sole proprietorship.

Therefore, the accounts of your sole proprietorship up to the conversion date must be closed and the profit or loss of the long-term construction and repair work determined, this profit or loss must be declared by your sole proprietorship on the annual income tax return under the general principles, and the taxes withheld from progress payments made to you for the long-term construction and repair work must be credited against the income tax calculated on the declared income; if a refund receivable arises after the credit, it is not possible to offset this amount against the tax debts of the said joint stock company.

On the other hand, it is natural that if your refund receivable reaches the cash refund stage under the principles set out in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 252, it can be offset against the tax debts of the joint stock company of which you are a shareholder.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.