A company that will sell its factory building to a bank and lease it back under financial leasing asked on what amount the land registry fee is calculated when the property is transferred to the bank.
The Administration's view:
- On a sale to the lessor under a sale-and-leaseback on condition of repurchase by the lessee at the end of the agreement, a land registry fee of 4.55 per thousand is collected from the transferor under Tariff (4) I/20-g of the Fees Law.
- The amounts in the lease payment plan are not the sale price of the property but lease payments relating to the leasing.
- The fee is calculated on the declared actual sale price, not less than the property tax value of the property.
The ruling is relevant to companies financing their real estate through sale-and-leaseback.
Full text
Subject: On what amount the land registry fee is calculated when real estate is transferred to a financing company under a financial leasing agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated 14.12.2022 and numbered 2192080.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that within the financial leasing agreement signed between your company and …. Bankası A.Ş., your factory building registered at parcel … block … … Neighbourhood …. district …. province will be sold to ….. Bankası A.Ş. and leased back, an opinion is requested on on what amount the land registry fee will be calculated on the transfer of the property to that Bank.
Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) attached to this law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; paragraph 20/a of the section titled "I - Land registry transactions" of Tariff (4) attached to the Law provides that a fee of 20 per thousand is collected separately from the transferor and the transferee on the transfer and acquisition of immovables for consideration, under a lifetime maintenance contract or according to barter provisions; and paragraph 20/g provides that a land registry fee of 4.55 per thousand is collected from the transferor on the sale to the lessor of immovables leased under leasing agreements carried out by the sale-and-leaseback method on condition of being repurchased by the lessee at the end of the agreement period (where it is determined that the immovable is not repurchased by the lessee in any way, the fee amount corresponding to the difference between the rate in subparagraph (a) and the rate in this subparagraph is collected from those concerned together with late payment interest under Law No. 213).
Accordingly, in transactions to be made at the land registry due to the sale to the lessor of immovables leased under financial leasing agreements carried out by the sale-and-leaseback method on condition of being repurchased by the lessee at the end of the agreement period, a land registry fee must be sought from the transferor under paragraph I/20-g of Tariff (4) attached to Fees Law No. 492.
Article 63 of Law No. 492 also provides:
"In transfers and acquisitions of immovables, the land registry and cadastre fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value.
In transfers and acquisitions of immovables with construction servitude, the fee is calculated on the whole of the transfer and acquisition price.
Where, after the transaction at the land registry, it is determined that the fee was paid on a price lower than the property tax value or that the declared transfer and acquisition price does not reflect the actual situation, the fee corresponding to the difference is assessed additionally or ex officio. For the land registry and cadastre fee to be assessed in this way, the tax loss penalty in Tax Procedure Law No. 213 is applied at 25%. No assessment can be made under this paragraph based on valuation commission decisions."
Accordingly, the value to be the basis for the land registry fee in transfers and acquisitions of immovables is the declared actual purchase-sale price, not less than the property tax value of the immovable on the transaction date, and where, after the transaction at the land registry, it is determined that the fee was paid on a price lower than the property tax value or that the declared transfer and acquisition price does not reflect the actual situation, the fee corresponding to the difference must be assessed additionally or ex officio and a penalty imposed for this fee.
On the other hand, Article 18 of Law No. 6361 on Financial Leasing, Factoring and Financing Companies provides: "A financial leasing agreement is an agreement under which the lessor leaves to the lessee, in return for rent, the possession of an asset purchased from a third party or from the lessee itself or otherwise obtained upon the request and choice of the lessee, or previously acquired, so as to provide all kinds of benefit."
On the other hand, it is understood that the Financial Leasing Agreement dated .......... signed between ……… Katılım Bankası A.Ş. and your company was drawn up for the leasing by the lessor to the lessee by financial leasing of the immovable registered at parcel … block …. … Neighbourhood …. district … province, and that the expression "Rent" in the agreement means the amount the lessee will pay under the agreement and shown in the payment plan; it is seen that the lease payment plan annexed to the agreement states that the total rent is TRY ………….., of which TRY …………. is principal and the remaining TRY ………… is profit, and that a proforma invoice dated …………. for TRY …………… was issued by your company for the sale of that immovable to …. Bankası A.Ş.
Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, considering that the amounts in the lease payment plan annexed to the Financial Leasing Agreement dated … do not relate to amounts for the sale of the relevant immovable by the lessee to the financial leasing company but are rents for its leasing by the financial leasing company to the lessee, during the transfer of that immovable to …. Bankası A.Ş., a land registry fee must be sought under subparagraph I/20-g of Tariff (4) attached to Law No. 492 on the declared actual purchase-sale price, not less than the property tax value of the immovable subject to transfer.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.