TREN
Contact us

In Registration by Court Order Based on a Sale Promise, the Land Registry Fee Is on the Actual VAT-Exclusive Sale Price, Not Less Than Property Tax Value, Not the Expert Market Value

Fees · Title deed feesIn Registration by Court Order Based on a Sale Promise, the Land Registry Fee Is on the Actual VAT-Exclusive Sale Price, Not Less Than Property Tax Value, Not the Expert Market ValuePrivate ruling · 25 September 2024
Rast note

A company that sued and obtained a court order for registration after title to a villa bought under a sale promise agreement was not transferred despite full payment stated that the land registry calculated the fee on the expert's market value, and asked on which value the fee is to be collected.

The Administration's view:

  • The land registry fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value; under Internal Circular No. 1997/5, VAT is not included in the base.
  • In registration by court order, the fee is collected under I/20-a on the VAT-exclusive actual sale price determined and paid under the sale promise agreement and the additional agreement, not less than the property tax value on the transaction date.

The ruling is relevant to buyers who win title cancellation and registration lawsuits based on sale promises and to land registry directorates.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Fee base on registration by court decision of real estate purchased under a contract but not registered
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: Ruling request forms dated 13.08.2024 numbered 3682831 and dated 12.08.2024 numbered 3668153.

From examination of the ruling request forms referred to above and their annexes, stating that:

- a real estate sale promise agreement dated 2/10/2017 was signed between ….. and ….. for villa number …. within … Project,

- subsequently a transfer agreement relating to the property was signed on 22/12/2017, under which the real estate sale promise agreement dated 2/10/2017 was transferred to your company, later villa number … was replaced with villa number …. by an additional agreement concluded between the parties on 24/12/2018 and the contract price was increased accordingly, and in its final form the price paid by your company for the property was TRY 3,000,000,

- although the whole of the actual sale price of the property subject to the sale promise agreement was paid in advance and in cash on the relevant dates, the title was not transferred, so your company filed a land registry cancellation and registration lawsuit based on the sale promise on 19/4/2019, and by decision numbered …. of … Commercial Court of First Instance it was decided to cancel the title of independent unit no. …. villa …. at parcel …. block …. … locality …. Village …. district … province registered in the name of the defendant ….. Gayrimenkul Geliştirme A.Ş. and register it in your company's name, and this decision became final on 17/7/2024,

- upon this finalisation your company applied to … Land Registry Directorate to which the property is attached for registration of the title in your company's name by court order, and the Land Registry Directorate calculated the land registry fee based on the value of TRY 50,900,000 determined as of 18/7/2022 as the basis for the court fee after the expert report, whereas your company purchased that property for a total of TRY 3,000,000 (TRY 2,542,372.88 excluding VAT) under the agreement dated 31/12/2017 and the additional agreement dated 24/2/2018 made due to the villa change,

it is understood that our Presidency's opinion is requested on which value the land registry fee will be calculated during the registration by court order to be made at the land registry.

Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) attached to this Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; the second paragraph of Article 63 provides that in transfers and acquisitions of immovables the land registry and cadastre fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value; and paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) attached to the Law provides that a proportional fee is collected separately from the transferor and the transferee on the transfer and acquisition of immovables for consideration, under a lifetime maintenance contract or according to barter provisions.

On the other hand, Fees Law Internal Circular No. 1997/5 dated 7/10/1997 explains that value added tax must not be taken into account in determining the land registry fee base.

Accordingly, although in transfers and acquisitions of immovables subject to value added tax VAT must not be included in the land registry fee base, where the VAT-exclusive sale price of the transferred immovable is lower than its property tax value, the property tax value must be taken into account in calculating the land registry fee.

On the other hand, from examination of the decision numbered …… of … Commercial Court of First Instance, it is understood that it is stated that the market value of the villa subject to the lawsuit was TRY 13,000,000 as of the lawsuit date 19/4/2019 and TRY 50,900,000 as of the lawsuit renewal date 18/07/2022, and that it was decided to cancel the title of that property in the name of the defendant …… Gayrimenkul Geliştirme A.Ş. (recorded in the land registry as ….. Gayrimenkul Geliştirme A.Ş.) and register it in the land registry in your company's name.

In this respect, during the registration in your company's name of independent unit no. … villa … at parcel … block … … locality … village … district … province under decision numbered …. of … Commercial Court of First Instance which became final on 14/5/2024, a land registry fee must be sought under subparagraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) attached to Law No. 492 on the VAT-exclusive amount of the actual sale price understood to have been determined and paid for the property under the real estate sale promise agreement and the additional agreement, not less than the property tax value valid as of the transaction date.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.