A dairy producers union established under Law No. 5200 carries out, through its economic enterprise, purchases of milk from members for wholesale marketing and wholesale purchases of feed sold to members at a discount. The union asked whether gains from these transactions fall within the CTL 5/1-i refund (risturn) exemption.
The Administration's view:
- Agricultural producer unions, treated as associations for tax purposes, are not corporate taxpayers as legal entities, but their economic enterprises arising from continuous commercial activities are subject to corporate tax.
- The exemption in the last paragraph of CTL 5/1-i and the exemption in Article 19 of Law No. 5200 are for the unions; they do not cover the unions' economic enterprises.
- Since the activities are carried out by the economic enterprise, it cannot benefit from the refund exemption or the Law No. 5200 exemption.
The ruling is relevant to agricultural producer unions and their economic enterprises.
Full text
Subject: Corporate tax exemption for a dairy producers union
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above and the letter received with it, stating that you are an Agricultural Producer Union established under Agricultural Producer Unions Law No. 5200 of 29/6/2004, that your title as a union is … Süt Üreticileri Birliği, but that your trade with your members is carried out through … Süt Üreticileri Birliği İktisadi İşletmesi with tax identification number … established within your union on …, and that your economic enterprise buys milk from members and markets it wholesale and buys feed wholesale and sells it to members at a discount, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether the gains from these transactions can be treated within the refund (risturn) exemption of the Corporate Tax Law.
Subparagraph (ç) of the first paragraph of Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 brings the income of economic enterprises belonging to associations or foundations within the subject of the tax; the fifth paragraph of Article 2 of the same Law provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural businesses belonging to or attached to associations or foundations with continuous activities, other than those in the first and second paragraphs, are economic enterprises; and the sixth paragraph provides that the fact that public economic entities and economic enterprises belonging to associations or foundations do not aim at profit, that their activities are among duties given by law, that they have no legal personality, independent accounting or capital or workplaces allocated to them does not affect their liability, and that the price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made, or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their economic nature.
Although Agricultural Producer Unions, treated as associations for tax purposes, have no corporate tax liability by their legal personality, the economic enterprises attached to these Unions due to their continuous commercial, industrial and agricultural activities will need to be subject to corporate tax.
Subparagraph (i) of the first paragraph of Article 5, titled "Exemptions", of that Law provides:
"The portions refunded unspent from amounts paid by cooperative members as management expenses, and refunds calculated by consumer cooperatives based on the value of goods their members purchased to meet their personal and family food and clothing needs.
The distribution of these refunds to members is not deemed profit distribution. Payment of the refund in cash or in goods of the same value does not prevent the exemption from applying.
The refund exemption does not apply to gains from transactions with persons other than members and gains from transactions with members outside the membership status. In separating these from general income, the ratio of business volume with members to general business volume is taken as the basis.
(Paragraph added by Article 43 of Law No. 6009; in force: 1/8/2010) The provisions of this subparagraph also apply to transactions of Unions established under Agricultural Producer Unions Law No. 5200 of 29/6/2004 with their members."
Article 1, titled "Purpose and scope", of Agricultural Producer Unions Law No. 5200 states that the purpose of this Law is to enable agricultural producers to come together on a product or product group basis and establish agricultural producer unions with legal personality in order to plan production according to demand, improve product quality, send products conforming to applicable norms and standards to the market without taking them into their own ownership, and take measures to increase the marketing power of products on a national and international scale; and Article 5 explains which activities make up the duties of the union.
Article 19, titled "Exemption", of that Law states that all kinds of movable and immovable property belonging to the Union, their purchase, sale, construction and use, and services and activities carried out by the union are exempt from all kinds of taxes, duties, fees and contributions except stamp duty.
Therefore, the exemption provisions in the paragraph added to the end of subparagraph (i) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 and the exemption provisions in Article 19 of Agricultural Producer Unions Law No. 5200 are aimed at Unions established under the Agricultural Producer Unions Law and do not cover economic enterprises belonging to these unions.
Within the framework of these provisions and explanations, since the activity of buying milk from your Union's members and marketing it wholesale and buying feed wholesale and selling it to your members at a discount is an activity carried out by your economic enterprise, it is not possible for the economic enterprise belonging to your Union to benefit from the refund exemption defined in subparagraph (i) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law or from the exemption provisions under Article 19, titled "Exemption", of Agricultural Producer Unions Law No. 5200.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.